Gransnet forums

News & politics

Anti Semitism in Labour Party and Universities.

(631 Posts)

GNHQ have commented on this thread. Read here.

POGS Thu 17-Mar-16 12:12:56

I am raising this as a separate conversation although it has been mentioned on another thread re the Muslim Female Councillors and reports of Mysogyny.

It is worrying to know Anti Semitism is reportedly rising in the UK . When a Political Party is facing accusations of Anti Semetism that becomes a major issue. Now my comment will be challenged but I for one have been asking how such blatent cases of Anti Semitism are being allowed in the UK. We have laws to handle it but they are not being used, why? I will most certainly be happy to say that I do not believe for one minute the majority of Labour MP's nor voters are Anti Semetic, quite the reverse, but is it time voices spoke out against Anti Semitism or at least understood it is an issue within some parts of the Labour Movement.

I have noticed this tendancy from certain Labour MP's and groups they belong to for many years but they were always under the radar and not thought 'influencial' enough, however times have changed. Labour run councils have used Anti Semetic behaviour over issues such as Flying the Palestinian Flag over Tower Hamlets , Calls for boycotting of Israeli goods, banning Jewish films etc. etc.

There is no doubt more interest being taken by the media over such matters and there are calls for Corbyn to show leadership over the actions of the Labour Party activism at Oxford University , indeed something is going radically wrong with our universities full stop an entire thread could be dedicated to that topic alone. I am not talking of racist tweets such as those made by MP's such as Dianne Abbot , Helen Goodman et al. Whilst they are relevant it would just dissolve into a tit for tat fest of he said she said to the left and right of politics. There are idiots in all party's !

I am not , and some will not believe a word of what I am about to say, trying to score a political point. I take my hat off to those Labour MP's who are speaking openly about this problem and calling for action from their Leader. This is not some right wing rag hyperbol taking place but there is something of a 'menacing ' tendency in some quarters of the Party and I hope those MP's who are doing their damnedest to openly stop it's progression do not fail or as some have eluded to run the risk of deselection for speaking out, that's another thread story too.

annodomini Thu 24-Mar-16 13:32:06

Try FutureLearn, niggly. They have free courses on so many subjects it's hard to choose. I suggest international politics.

nigglynellie Thu 24-Mar-16 13:22:42

I am sorry to hear about your husband Venus, and I do wish you both well. My DH has had a recurrence of prostate cancer, so I do understand a little bit how you must be feeling.
You are all so well qualified on here!!! I'm afraid I can only boast 5 O'levels, (no maths, no science!!! ) one of which was religious knowledge!! and two A'levels, english literature and british history!! I think at 70+ I'll have to leave it at that!!
Everyone has their own ideas and attitudes concerning this particular situation. It is difficult and seemingly insurmountable, and nothing we say on here will make any difference, so I can't really see any point in continuing this conversation, which is beginning to turn into, you did, you didn't!!!

Anniebach Thu 24-Mar-16 12:53:55

I doubt anyone could accuse these Jews of being anti Semitic. Thank you for the name of the web site annodomini

annodomini Thu 24-Mar-16 12:43:42

There are many Jewish people who are ashamed at the treatment meted out to the Palestinians by the State of Israel and horrified at the illegal land grabs on the West Bank. I previously mentioned a web site run by one of these groups - Jewish Voice for Peace.

Anniebach Thu 24-Mar-16 12:18:42

Perhaps he does talk to Jews, there are quite a few labour MP's who are Jews and the Tory press are far to interested in anything that put Corbyn in a bad light . So I would be interested to read hoe often he meets with Palistians for talks, as you are so sure may I ask for the dates, is it weekly, monthly ?

obieone Thu 24-Mar-16 11:50:40

Venue probably meant those who have the loudest voices on this forum.

I think many people agree that Jeremy Corbyn spending a lot of time talking to Palestenians and not Jews has raised eyebrows and questions.

Anniebach Thu 24-Mar-16 11:26:54

Thank you Grscesgran . To suggest Corbyn may be anti Semitic because of who he speaks to makes Mo Molam an IRA sympathiser - and me going over to the tories !

Gracesgran Thu 24-Mar-16 11:09:55

Of course you are Annie and you would think most would be able to smile. Life is complicated; if people want a simple answer they may find others don't agree with them.

Anniebach Thu 24-Mar-16 11:04:02

With respect Venus, your voice has been the loudest, sorry but to accuse others when you have posted the longest and most posts is unfair,mi think you really mean - those who do not agree with me, and I do not agree with you, I am able to separate the Palestinian and Israel war from anti semitism throughout countries or British political parties

Gracesgran Thu 24-Mar-16 10:33:19

I would not be at all surprised if less educated Muslims said some strange and untruthful things based on what they think they have been brought up to believe is about their religion when it is actually cultural. It was ever thus. I can remember RCs who would tell our Jewish friends at school that they killed Jesus, that we were wrong for eating meat on a Friday and many other foolish things. Oh, and I don't think they were keen on homosexuality or, to some extent women either - very misogynistic.

Defining any religion by it's least educated or critical members is not helpful. If I had to show people a view of the UK as defined by the worst hatred I have seen, particularly from older folk on forums all said in the name of "loving our country" I think many would be quite horrified that this view of the UK then included them.

This thread was not headed Labour v Jews; it asked a question. There will, I have no doubt, be some anti any group you can think of in each and every party. Surely, what we need is the parties and the religions to keep saying what their real beliefs are.

Venus Thu 24-Mar-16 10:00:04

Thank you TerriBull for your astute understanding and as Nigglynellie says, it's all on line for anyone to read. That is the only place I researched my information. I only wish I'd have this wonderful facility when I went back to studying for my B.A. and Master's Degree in my forties.

I'm not attacking Muslims, just saying that children are indoctrinated at an ealy age at school and Sunday school to consider Jews to be the enemy.

I'm tired of the animosity, and feel there is little point in continuing. I do have a life outside of here (A husband battling cancer) so I don't need any further stress.

I'm sure those with the loudest voices will find someone else to argue with.

Thanks to those who have seen some sense in what I've posted.

nigglynellie Thu 24-Mar-16 09:46:15

I think information on line is going to be as truthful as information gleaned anywhere else, particularly if you research old documents and speeches and anythingelse written and spoken at the relevant time. It's pretty easily sifted out!

rosesarered Thu 24-Mar-16 09:46:08

The silly statement that here Muslims live in fear of their lives was just that.... A silly statement.

TerriBull Thu 24-Mar-16 09:42:37

The point Venus brought up regarding anti semitic sentiments being expressed in (some Muslim) schools, not only in schools but also in places of worship, I would reiterate that I have seen undercover investigations on Channel 4 Dispatches where bile ridden sermons with hatred directed at Jews, Christians and Homosexuals, urging the congregation to carry out violent acts against non Muslims. I can only speak as an occasional Catholic, but I don't perceive any Christian church, aside from some of the strange Bible belt churches in America, would preach such hatred and get away with it.

Apropos of a comment on here yesterday stating that Muslims live in fear of their lives in the west, bearing in mind the first two news items at the moment, the Belgian atrocities and the planned drive by shooting in West London that had been foiled, I think there are many of us who live with the constant fear, including the vast majority of peaceful Muslims, where will they strike next. Quite possibly if I were Jewish I would feel at times a sitting target.

nigglynellie Thu 24-Mar-16 09:26:49

Well, there are two sides to this argument, and it does seem strange to me that by and large the West Bank is peaceful, and Gaza is not! Could this have anything to do with Hammas?!! If your avowed intent is to annihilate your neighbour, and constantly attack them, to say the least that neighbour isn't going to be friendly towards you, which in turn will inevitably adversely affect the people you claim to be supporting!!!

Anniebach Thu 24-Mar-16 08:27:09

The title of this thread was labour v Jews, now it has become Jews v Muslims, this is not a thread on anti semitism , it starts with an attack on the Labour Party now has turned into an attack on Muslims under the pretence of anti semitism

I agree with Daphnehill and as for reading it all on line , has all on line become the truth .

The treatment of the people of Palestine by Israel is wicked and that many people believe this does not make them anti Semitic

nigglynellie Thu 24-Mar-16 07:35:01

FGS. This conversation is getting absurd. There was no country called Palestine in 1948. If you don't believe this then do some research, it's all on line! and you will find out exactly what the situation regarding the people's of the Holy Land was at this time and prior to it.
Again, with regard to whether it was possible to bomb the death camps, it's all on line for anyone to read. In fact anything you want to know about is on line, so why this pointless bad tempered argument? Just log in and find out!!

Venus Thu 24-Mar-16 00:52:48

And one more thing. My grandson goes to a Jewish state school, which has high academic success rates. Not only that, it doesn't preach to the children that Muslims are bad, or that any other faith is wrong. . . unlike Muslim faith schools that tend to spew out anti semitic propaganda.

Venus Thu 24-Mar-16 00:47:19

'For goodness sake' Daphnedill, get your facts right. On 9th February 2016, when meeting the Jewish Board of Deputies, Mr Corbyn affirmed his support for Jewish Faith schools.

He also gave a solid commitment to the right of Israel to live within secure and recognised boundaries as part of a two state solution to the Israel- Palestinian conflict.

Venus Thu 24-Mar-16 00:17:02

Daphnedill
I was answering Anniebach, who said that that it was the Arab's land, when it wasn't. Archeological evidence supports the fact that the Israelis had presence there for 3,000 years.

The UN planned the partition and it was accepted by the Jews as a Jewish State. It was certainly not taken by force. I hardly think Israels' military capabilities matched up to the assault of four Arab nations either. I also dispute that Israel has expanded it's terrritory, infact quite the opposite, which I have already explained. I have no history books. All information is checked on the internet.

Could it be that you have a distorted view as to who should have Israel? In 1917 the Balfour Declaration promised the land to the Jews, way before 1948.

'Quite honestly, I don't need your history lessons' either.

Be as sympathetic as you like to the Palestinian cause, for as long as the State of Israel is not recognised by them, they will continue to guard it's borders and protect its people. I'm am, indeed, somewhat surprised that one Jew's opinion can sway you one way or another!

daphnedill Wed 23-Mar-16 23:49:14

Oh for goodness sake, Venus! Get yourself a decent history book! If you want to talk ancient history, let's all go back to Africa.

daphnedill Wed 23-Mar-16 23:47:20

I'm sure you know, Venus, that the State of Israel was actually declared the day before the British Mandate was due to end. This was because Ben Gurion and the Jewish Agency didn't want to accept the UN terms. The Arab states didn't accept it either, but Israel had military supremacy and Israel became a 'de facto' state. Since then, Israel has continued to expand its territory by military means. Did you really expect Arabs who had their land taken away from them to accept it?

Quite honestly I don't need your history lessons and I rather suspect that some pages have been ripped out of your text books. Your distorted view of history makes me, if anything, more sympathetic to the Palestinian cause.

None of your views alter the fact that Arabs in Israel are discriminated against and that their homes and villages are being taken over by Jewish Israelis. Attempts are even being made to silence dissident Israeli Jews.

None of this has much to do with anti-Semiticism in the UK. Most anti-Semitic thugs are racists and they don't care whether their victims are Jewish, black, Muslim or just different. Most of them are thick as **, but not all. Nick Griffin is a Cambridge graduate. In his twisted mind, there is a white supremacy ideology. You really should be seeking out real racism, including anti-Semiticism, rather than lecturing on ancient history. You don't speak for 100% of Jews, nor is the Israeli state the mouthpiece for all Jews.

PS. I am glad that Corbyn doesn't support Jewish faith schools. Ironically, the investigation into their curriculum has come about as a result of the criticism of Muslim faith schools. Neither should be publicly funded. It seems that Arkush is upset that he can't get Corbyn on his side.

Anniebach Wed 23-Mar-16 23:44:01

1882 was some time before the forties , so it was a country called Palestine but few Palestinians lived there ?

Venus Wed 23-Mar-16 23:38:13

'Their country!' 3,000 years ago there existed the KIngdom of Judea. The Jewish people have maintained ties with their historic homeland for more than 3,700 years.

The twelve tribes of Israel formed the first constitutional monarchy in Palestine about 1,000 BC The second king, David, first made Jerusalem the nation's capital.

1882, Palestine was never exclusively an Arab country, fewer the 25,000 Arabs lived there. and the majority arrived in recent decades. No Palestinian or Arab state ever existed in Palestine, nor was it exclusively an Arab country.

Anniebach Wed 23-Mar-16 23:19:47

Who would be happy to have part of their country taken from them and made a new country