Gransnet forums

News & politics

Theresa May 3

(1001 Posts)
MaizieD Mon 31-Oct-16 11:17:50

Very interesting article about T May. Forgive me if it's been posted before.

I think that the author is proposing that the Murdoch media have been superseded by the Daily Mail in setting the agenda for 'British' and that Theresa May is a product and perpetrator of its agenda.

www.opendemocracy.net/uk/anthony-barnett/daily-mail-takes-power-0

The Daily Mail takes power
Anthony Barnett 5 October 2016

After 25 years in politics Theresa May has no obvious connections to any think tank. She shows no interest in ideas. Asked by Conservative Home in a Quick Quiz session to choose between Burke’s “Reflections on the Revolution in France” or Louise Bagshawe’s “Desire”, she replied, “I wouldn’t read either of them, sorry.” The prime minister who faces arguably the Kingdom’s deepest constitutional predicament since George III was driven from the Cabinet by the loss of the American colonies dismissed out of hand the idea that she might ever turn to the pages of Burke, even though as a student she had chaired a society named after him.

As the country faces an unprecedented concatenation of economic, strategic, diplomatic and constitutional uncertainty, the woman at the helm seems devoid of intellectual resources. The one decision she has definitely taken is to give the go ahead to Hinkley Point C nuclear power station, a boondoggle incapable of justification by any criteria of integrity. The Pharaohs built their own pyramids, Theodoric built his own mausoleum. But these were designed as monuments to generate the admiration of posterity. Surely only an idiot would make their first decision the go-ahead for a colossal radioactive tombstone to her regime.

But Theresa May should not be dismissed as an idiot. There is a striking and potentially formidable coherence to the general direction she has set for her new government, evidenced by the self-confidence of her ministers who remarkably quickly are singing from the same song-sheet. She does seem to have a clear ideology refreshingly different from her predecessors. Where has it come from?

The answer is The Daily Mail. On Sunday in her first speech to her party as its leader, she set out her view of Brexit and announced that she intends to trigger Article 50 to start the UK’s withdrawal from the EU before March. This was a moment of upmost gravity, to recognise and measure the immense divisions that have been opened up within the country, and consider the implications for the entire continent that Britain once helped liberate from fascism. Instead, her tone, brevity and apparent practicality were drawn as if directly from a Daily Mail editorial.

Intelligent comments section, too.

whitewave Fri 27-Jan-17 17:51:18

mair globalist extremist - what a meaningless phrase

durhamjen Fri 27-Jan-17 17:39:52

And it doesn't bother you that Polish people in this country are being killed and attacked for being Polish, because of Brexit, yet the government thinks it's okay to ask Polish teachers to come and live here at the same time as we cannot guarantee the right of those who are already here to continue living here?
I find it quite obscene.

Welshwife Fri 27-Jan-17 17:37:31

I saw somewhere they are also actively trying to recruit doctors from the EU. Not sure about further afield.

Ana Fri 27-Jan-17 17:27:16

I often disagree with you, that's true durhamjen, but in this instance there was certainly no need to read your link. I'd aready read about it.

durhamjen Fri 27-Jan-17 17:18:37

'John Howson, chair of the teacher recruitment site TeachVac and a visiting professor of education at Oxford Brookes University said: “I am frankly very surprised that in the middle of the debate on Article 50, that the Government is busy going off to these European countries to try and attract teachers.
“In terms of the wider political debate it is a very odd approach to be trawling round a bunch of countries which we are trying to cut off association with.”

It comes as the Migration Advisory Committee (MAC), recommends widening the number of subjects for which schools could recruit from non-EU countries.'

3 EU countries and the USA.
Ana, you always disagree with whatever I say, even without reading the article.

thatbags Fri 27-Jan-17 17:08:26

There has been a shortage of maths and science teachers in the UK for decades so trying to source them from elsewhere seems worth a try.

Ana Fri 27-Jan-17 17:04:42

Doesn't bother me!

durhamjen Fri 27-Jan-17 17:03:22

While we are all watching Theresa May and how she will agree with him on trade and free movement of people, the Education department are advertising for teachers in Czech Republic, Germany, Poland and the USA. That'll please Brexiteers.

www.telegraph.co.uk/education/2017/01/27/governments-secret-300000-overseas-teacher-recruitment-drive/

Jalima Fri 27-Jan-17 16:52:39

I agree with GracesGran re the door opening syndrome (think it has been discussed on another thread as well).

I find it a bit odd that Gransnetters whom I would presume to be 'liberated women' are criticising him for that confused
I thought they would object to a man who rushes round to open the door and help their OH out and offering their arm as if they are incapable.

JessM Fri 27-Jan-17 16:34:12

I saw some footage of Trump surging up the steps on inauguration leaving his wife to make her own way from the other side of the car, clutching a gift for Mrs O.
Blimey I have just looked at the appointments (lack of) list. Usually the new POTUS has a full slate of staff by now.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_appointments_of_Donald_Trump
and here is different wiki page, showing those confirmed in their appointments against a beige background...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formation_of_Donald_Trump%27s_Cabinet

GracesGranMK2 Fri 27-Jan-17 13:15:23

Beware of door-opening men. Obviously not when it is necessary or simply thoughtful because you are going through first and don't want to let it slam in someone's face but I have found (purely a personal view) that the guy who nips round the car to open the door when you are perfectly capable - don't have full hands, etc., - is very much the 'little women' type and doesn't have a great perception of women as people and equal.

That could be just me but I am very wary of them.

MaizieD Fri 27-Jan-17 13:00:24

I think Trump will treat May with the greatest respect and charm, holding doors open for her like a gentleman. I believe he will want to be seen as that.

Be more impressive if he treated his wife as though he were a gentleman...

MaizieD Fri 27-Jan-17 12:59:33

Just who are the 'globalist extremeists, Mair?

And it must work for those who have too often felt left behind by the forces of globalisation. People, often those on modest incomes living in relatively rich countries like our own, who feel that the global system of free markets and free trade is simply not working for them in its current form.

Such a deal – allied to the reforms we are making to our own economy to ensure wealth and opportunity is spread across our land – can demonstrate to those who feel locked out and left behind that free markets, free economies and free trade can deliver the brighter future they need. And it can maintain – indeed it can build – support for the rules-based international system on which the stability of our world continues to rely.

This one doesn't sound particularly protectionist.

Mair Fri 27-Jan-17 12:32:30

Bet she struggles to get a word in edgeways. He doesn't strike me as someone who is big on listening respectfully. Specially to women.

I think Trump will treat May with the greatest respect and charm, holding doors open for her like a gentleman. I believe he will want to be seen as that.

Mair Fri 27-Jan-17 12:30:05

*T May is not just you and me, who can pick and choose our friends/allies, and it is naive to think so.
Later on, when good relations have been established she can do some heavy hinting or even plain speaking.Now is not the time, not on this first visit, which is building bridges.*

Correct Roses.
The globalist extremists bear in mind want NO success for May, Brexit or Britain. This tends to suggest that everything they call for should be ignored, which is exactly what I hope and believe May will do!

JessM Fri 27-Jan-17 11:38:52

Oh to be a fly on the Oval Office wall. Bet she struggles to get a word in edgeways. He doesn't strike me as someone who is big on listening respectfully. Specially to women.

trisher Fri 27-Jan-17 11:10:20

They said they weren't doing it before rar but of course they were and much to our shame we were involved in rendition. We need to say loudly and clearly "Never again!"

whitewave Fri 27-Jan-17 11:07:44

As you say let's wait and see. Merkel holds a very mature view on Trump -pity May doesn't emulate it.

sunseeker Fri 27-Jan-17 11:04:39

Whilst I admired Obama I do not think he was particularly friendly towards Britain. Trump hasn't been in office long enough to show whether he will prove to be a friend to UK or not. Trump has also said that he will be guided on the use of torture by his generals, he hasn't actually said he will introduce it. Personally I am against the use of torture in any circumstances. Wanting to trade with a country does not mean we need to "poodle" to them, although the EU seems to expect it.

rosesarered Fri 27-Jan-17 11:03:01

Not a black and white view at all, a sensible and pragmatic view.We have to deal with people as they are, not as we personally would prefer them to be.
So far, this early in his Presidency, we don't know all that much about what he will do.

whitewave Fri 27-Jan-17 10:56:26

sunseeker that's a very black and white view. This chat was about whether Obamas was Britains friend. I pointed out that true friendship is one where you have shared values and a common way of looking at the world. Now as far as I can see Trump has not yet shown that he does indeed share British common values, as opposed to Obama who did.

Now you need then to look at whether it is possible to have any sort of relationship with a particular country. Some countries, like Putins Russia we have chosen to sanction for obvious reasons. If for example Trump reintroduced torture, extraordinary rendition, and refused all Muslims entry to the US. Then we must ask ourselves if we can in fact live with that. I think not, not only because of my value system, but because of our standing in the rest of the world.

Don't forget, we are constantly being reminded particularly since Brexit that Britain is a strong and independent country, that many countries will be thrilled to bits to trade with us. Why then do we need to poodle to America, if they behave like idiots?

rosesarered Fri 27-Jan-17 10:50:48

T May is not just you and me, who can pick and choose our friends/allies, and it is naive to think so.
Later on, when good relations have been established she can do some heavy hinting or even plain speaking.Now is not the time, not on this first visit, which is building bridges.

rosesarered Fri 27-Jan-17 10:47:48

Trisher I have I expect, watched as much of the news as you have regarding Trump, therefore know what he said about water boarding/ torture, and although he said he agreed with it, he also said that he had taken advice and they wouldn't be doing it.
None of that is relevant about Obama, and him not being as close to Britain as some other past Presidents.

trisher Fri 27-Jan-17 10:45:56

Nobody has said don't speak to Trump, only that any conversation must emphasise that certain things are not acceptable and that friendship with Obama was easier because we shared similar values. Any deal with Trump will need to be made after clearly stating that we will not be involved, even at a distance, with rendition and torture. It's harder to get someone to moderate their views if you are standing there with a begging bowl waiting for them to drop a trade deal into it.

sunseeker Fri 27-Jan-17 10:40:17

So we should only be on friendly terms with those whose views are the same as ours? Should we refuse to speak to Trump because of his policies and not trade with USA or should we talk to them and by our own actions try to get them to moderate their views.

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion