Gransnet forums

News & politics

Why is this not newsworthy?

(109 Posts)
dbDB77 Wed 12-Apr-17 23:37:49

On BBC Look North at 6.30pm this evening they reported on a case that started today in Huddersfield crown court. 27 Asian men and 2 Asian women have been charged with the systematic rape, abuse and trafficking for sexual exploitation of girls as young as 11 in the Kirklees area over a number of years. This was not an item on the main BBC news at 6.00pm. Why not? Have they not learned the lessons of Rotherham? Or does the London-based BBC consider that little girls in the north of England do not count for anything?

Penstemmon Sat 15-Apr-17 12:09:41

Umm..I do not consider any man who grooms girls /rapes. assaults etc etc has any true religious faith! Jimmy Saville was supposed to be a good Catholic but I do not consider him a representative of the Catholic faith any more than the number of abusive Catholic priests were/are.

It seems that a particular group of men have formed a despicable network, possibly through work as minicab drivers, to groom vulnerable girls and it has become a dreadful 'trade'. It needs to be stopped whoever is involved. We should not be tiptoeing around it but dealing with it. It would be easier to deal with head on if the sections of the media did not fuel up anti-Muslim rhetoric in their reporting. These are evil men, the fact they come from a particular section of society is irrelevant in the case against them..as is any prosecution of non Muslim abusers..of which there are also far too many.

Aslemma Fri 14-Apr-17 18:29:17

I have noticed a tendency not to specifically rate all Asian men as rapists but to call most of Moslems. Ignoring religious texts from the Koran regardimg the treatment of women, or the cultural beliefs of certain sections of that society, there are plenty of Asians who are not Moslems but Hindu, Christian, Buddhists, Jews and Atheists,, there are also many non-Asian men and women who are Moslem.

grannypiper Fri 14-Apr-17 16:29:01

Widespread abuse by Men of Pakistani origin has not just taken place in Northern towns, Oxford, Reading and High Wycombe amongst others have all had the same problem.
My Husbands Step Daughter was being groomed by Pakistani taxi drivers in a south Oxfordshire market town, at the time she was 19 (very immature) and living in a hostel.Thankfully the police found her one night in their company and realised she was at risk. They police told us it is very common in that town for the taxi drivers to start grooming young girls.

Iam64 Fri 14-Apr-17 15:42:44

I've re read my post and want to stress that the
report done by Professor Jay should ensure that the scenario I painted, where bhildre's allegations weren't believed should not happen now.

Penstemmon Fri 14-Apr-17 15:40:12

I think we should stop arguing about the racial / social profile of paedophiles and accept that individuals and groups, from very many different backgrounds and life experiences, do abuse young people (mainly girls but not exclusively). All is unacceptable, whoever the abusers are & all need to be punished and hopefully helped not to re-offend. It is a very sad situation for an alleged civilised society.

Far better to be looking at the situations that enable these horrific crimes to take place and to work and invest in processes and systems that will prevent it occurring on such a wide scale basis in the future.

Penstemmon Fri 14-Apr-17 15:32:08

In reply to posts on page 2: Until 1929 girls of 12 and boys of 14 were considered of marriageable age in UK.

Iam64 Fri 14-Apr-17 09:22:02

Eloethan is correct in saying that many of the young girls being sexually abused and exploited in Rotherham (for example) were seen by agencies as making "lifestyle choices". That issue was a huge part of the problem. 12 and 13 year old boys and girls in residential care are usually there, rather than at home or in foster care because they are resisting the ordinary boundaries parents and carers put in place. We know all teenagers push the boundaries but this group are vulnerable to the extent they have few self care/protection skills. They are targeted by groomers for exactly that reason.
They'll go missing for 3 days or longer, return dirty, distressed, spaced out on drugs and refuse to talk about where they've been. This pattern is repeated. Some of them who claimed to have been driven about the country, given drugs and raped by different groups of men won't be believed. Some have medical examinations, which sadly give no proof of their genuine experience.
I'm not defending the perpetrators or the agencies/families that failed this girls and boys. I'm suggesting it just isn't as simple as so called political correctness stopping investigation of Pakistani Muslim men.

absent Fri 14-Apr-17 08:06:14

Do bear in mind that people cannot be prosecuted for any sort of crime, including people trafficking and child sex abuse (or any sort of child abuse because violence and enforced drug addiction are standard weapons in the process) without sufficient evidence. That this awful crime is happening and that the police may know about it doesn't mean that they have solid evidence the the CPS will be willing to take further.

patriciageegee Fri 14-Apr-17 08:04:19

Absolutely EVERYONE guilty of this vilest of crimes needs to be dealt with severely. The repercussions of sexual abuse as a child are enormous..it ruins lives and it ends lives. People commit suicide as a direct result of such abuse they actually take their own lives because they cannot cope with the pain of existence after such trauma. It is so serious a subject that reportage is an absolute must regardless of the background of the perpetrator/s and we must NEVER get weary and 'fed up of hearing' about it.

NfkDumpling Fri 14-Apr-17 06:13:44

What really annoys me is when something from our region makes it to the main news (usually a murder, drugs, illegal immigrants or all three) it's repeated virtually word for word from what was said on the main news. The same shots and statements used several times within a few minutes.

suzied Fri 14-Apr-17 04:20:57

There's seems to be a lot of anti South rhetoric on here. Shows how racism / prejudice grows I suppose. TheBBC has outposts everywhere in the country/ world and they don't just choose "southern" stories. There's a bigger population in the south and London is the capital/ seat of government etc , so it follows that many political stories are those that happen in London. Crime stories come from around the country. There are many horrible things , unfortunately, happening everywhere which don't make the headlines. I am sure when this case is resolved and we know the back stories it will be all over the papers. I remember Panorama of old doing a piece on "Pakistani pimps" in Bradford about 20 years ago, so this problem has been known about for a long time .

Abonet Fri 14-Apr-17 00:20:36

Even this thread has tried to be pc.
We have
Asian - instead of saying Pakistan
talk about stoking the fire of racism, if a poster is interested in all of this
not in the public interest
does it matter what the nationality and race of the abusers are
are you advising all females to avoid Asian-looking men

and that was all on page 1.

vulnerable kids still sadly stand no chance

daphnedill Thu 13-Apr-17 23:48:27

I can believe it Chewbacca - from experience, unfortunately. I've never worked in a school with significant numbers of pupils with Pakistani heritage. You might be horrified about what goes on in some white, allegedly middle class households.

daphnedill Thu 13-Apr-17 23:45:28

X post.I agree with you Eloethan.

daphnedill Thu 13-Apr-17 23:44:05

I don't agree with abonet. PC is used as an excuse by those who turn a blind eye or are too lazy to do anything about abuse.

Anniebach Thu 13-Apr-17 23:22:21

You will have to ask the RSPCC Chewbacca , but it is fact that child sex sbuse in the home is quite common place , always has been

Abonet Thu 13-Apr-17 23:01:50

As a country we should be ashamed. As a country, the flip side of being tolerant, pc and not wishing to offend, was that we went too far the other way for far too long.

As a country and as individuals, the label of, and fear of being labelled racist by others, meant that things happened, espcially to the vulnerable, got very hurt indeed.

Even on this thread, people prefer to say Asian than to say Pakistan.

It is way past time we all stopped being so very afraid.

Label it and deal with it. Stand up.

Eloethan Thu 13-Apr-17 22:54:26

What about the British (and other European and American) men who incite and watch the sexual abuse of children, some of them babies, from poor countries around the world?

What about this man:

" A paedophile Christian who targeted impoverished children is suspected of having raped and molested up to 200 children in Cambodia and Malaysia while undertaking voluntary work.

"Richard Huckle, 30, has already admitted to raping and assaulting 23 children, aged between six months and 12 years, in Cambodia and the Malaysian capital, Kuala Lumpur.

However, National Crime Agency (NCA) investigators fear he could have abused up to 200 children after they discovered more than 20,000 indecent images of minors on his computer and camera."

Should people now assume that all British/white/western men are more prone to committing sexual crimes against children?

It keeps being repeated that the reason the Rotherham criminals got away with their crimes for so long was because of "political correctness". In fact, the report found that some of the police officers were of the opinion that young women who got drunk and consorted with Asian men were not the subjects of a crime but were making a "lifestyle choice". It is my feeling that those who were accused of ignoring these crimes used the excuse that they were scared of being called racist because they knew such a claim would be applauded by many of the white population.

Penstemmon Thu 13-Apr-17 22:50:16

annieb yes you are right & I realise that an abuser is more likely to be a family member or "friend" but in my post I was refering specifically to widespread abuse in organisatiins/ communities. It is shocking that a a society we have not been able to do enough about this.

Chewbacca Thu 13-Apr-17 22:39:06

1 in 20 Ab? Is that actually reported abuse or estimated, do you know? Seems incredible to think that in every class of approximately 30 children, more than 1 of them will have been abused.

Anniebach Thu 13-Apr-17 22:36:17

according to the NSPCC , one in twenty children are sexually abused ,that's a lot of priests, celebs and Asians

Iam64 Thu 13-Apr-17 22:26:12

Anyone who has worked in safeguarding children whether in police, probation, social work, mental health services etc, will say that the sexual abuse of children has existed throughout time. It happens in all societies, cultures, faith and non faith groups. It's much more widespread than many find it possible to believe.

Easier access to pornography, as well as the dark web have made it easier for like minded individuals to find each other. The issue of organised abuse, as seen recently in groups of men of Pakistani Muslim heritage, is not new. People who sexually abuse children are skilled at targeting, grooming, abusing and keeping their victims quiet. They also know that girls and boys who are known to use substances, drink, run away, truant are often seen as 'unreliable witnesses', not just by those charged with investigating but also by wider society.

Penstemmon Thu 13-Apr-17 22:00:52

I think the numbers of white middle class paedophiles abusing boys in public schools, RC priests abusing alter boys, celebs abusing fans etc. would, sadly, match those numbers. If we now know that there are particular groups of abusers/victims we must be more vigilent and invest in resources that will reduce the liklihood of repeating situations.

Chewbacca Thu 13-Apr-17 21:35:24

Although many men (and women for that matter) have been prosecuted for sex crimes against children and vulnerable young adults, I think that it's the sheer numbers of Asian men who have been charged with these crimes that is so upsetting. 10 in Rochdale; 8 in Rotherham; 7 in Oxford; 12 in Keighley and now more. As previous posters have said, intelligence was known to the police, social services and local people that this was a problem, but no one wanted to risk being called racist and so the victims were left to suffer for far longer. It makes no difference what the nationality of the paedophiles are, what matters is finding out why and how they select their victims and stopping them far sooner than we have done so far. And putting a child's safety before political correctness.

Penstemmon Thu 13-Apr-17 21:32:25

Whilst the perpertrators of any abuse are absolutely resposible for their own actions and need to be punished we need also to consider the context that creates the 'perfect storm' that enables this sad and abhorrent situation to happen.
The men, apparently of Pakistani heritage, have probably been through British schools, the girls generally tend to have a similar disadvantaged backgrounds. All appear (based on previous cases)to be living in somewhat depressed areas.
The abuse in public schools/RC church communities was able to thrive because nobody believed it would be a possibility. I think that is the stage that the British Pakistani community is at.
I am not advocating glossing over the fact that the perpertrators are from a particiclar "group" but it is easier for a group/community to face up to this if they are not also defending themselves from attack from the wider society.
Also if we(society) have learned anything from the previous high profile case it is that we need to listen to the girls, provide them with better support to disclose and do something radical to prevent them becoming victims.