Gransnet forums

News & politics

Our country post Brexit

(1001 Posts)
whitewave Tue 01-Aug-17 07:49:36

I thought I would start this thread to enable those who are enthusiastic Brexiters, to educate us Europhiles and show that our worries are silly and uniformed.

We hear so little from you, except to criticise our worries.

We have so many threads about the negative effects why not have one which shows the positive effects that leaving the EU will come about?

MaizieD Tue 15-Aug-17 15:35:33

Here's a starter for you, Cindersdad. A list of some of the particularly onerous EU 'rules' that leaving will release us from (courtesy the Daily Express). I'm sure Brexiters will be most relieved

MaizieD Tue 15-Aug-17 15:21:39

Sorry, Cindersdad. We've rather derailed your request sad

Just been having a nosey on the Chat forum (I wouldn't normally but I'm having a Procrastination Day). Too late to add to the 'Post Brexit' thread but would like to say that I'm really looking forward to getting my Unicorn...

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 15:01:57

Davis has been caught telling little porkies.

On R4 this morning he said how his department spent the past year consulting with business over the CU etc.

Now they are saying that they would welcome comments/discussion from and with business over the CU.

hmm to be fair I don't think anyone believes that the past year was spent very productively -not really sure what they were doing to be honest - so I think his remarks this morning were taken with a pinch of salt.

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 14:55:29

There is a Blogger surname North can't remember his Christian name, but he is a long time leaver, and he is incensed with the government. He thinks the whole think is a catastrophic cock up.

Richard!! Just remembered

MaizieD Tue 15-Aug-17 14:51:23

Here's Ian Dunt's take on the customs union position paper:

www.politics.co.uk/blogs/2017/08/15/the-government-s-customs-union-plan-is-an-absolute-dog-s-bre

I don't think he thinks it's any good:

t's hard to know where to start with the customs union position paper. It is such a mess, such a full-spectrum catastrophe of ineptitude and wishful thinking, that it's honestly quite difficult to choose which bits of it to single out for criticism.

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 14:12:39

I simply don't understand why this government isn't tackling the negotiations head on.
They know that they have to progress the Irish Border, the immigrant issues and the divorce settlement, before anything else can be tackled. Why not just get on with it?

Where are those papers?? Instead, next week we have fantasy papers about a * temporary customs union* -- dear of dear.

Welshwife Tue 15-Aug-17 13:59:35

This is a Facebook post today from Guy Verhofstadt.

The new paper announced by the U.K. Government seems to suggest that it is possible to be in and out of the customs union at the same time. Moreover, that an "invisible border" between Ireland and Northern Ireland is feasible. I fear this is all mere fantasy. In any case these discussions will be part of the second phase of the negotiations. First, we need to deal with the issues currently on the table: the rights of the citizens and the financial settlement.

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 13:57:15

You'll be lucky cinders I did ask a while back but in all honesty I don't think anyone can think of a single reason to leave.

Cindersdad Tue 15-Aug-17 12:30:14

I've just returned from a Fred Olsen Cruise, most of my fellow passengers were in our age group. I did not mention Brexit except in response to already started conversations much but everyone who expressed a view was pro remain. I have yet to hear a convincing reason for voting leave.

David Davies does seem to be getting a little softer. Unfortunately much of the damage has already been done so even if Brexit were to be stopped we would still be worse off than if the wretched business had never been started.

Please can some Brexiteers give me and others of my camp at least one good reason to change my mind.

For me Vince Cable says it how it is though his choice of words may sometimes be too vitriolic. I just hope that parliament stands up to the bully Brexiteers against the "will of the people" formed by many lies and some prejudice. If that means a second referendum then so be it; then lets hope for a better informed public and fewer lies from the politicians.

Constructive counter views really appreciated.

Welshwife Tue 15-Aug-17 11:37:51

It is very worrying - corruption gone mad really. Makes you wonder how far it will go and how the next generations will get on. It is hard enough for them now to realise their goals.

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 10:38:16

I think that the whole world thinks we are mad.

Totally shot ourselves in the foot.

It is amazing to me how a relatively small minority of vocal individuals with money and access to the media can cause such chaos and division.

Look at America.

Welshwife Tue 15-Aug-17 10:19:45

The Europeans cannot understand this Brexit - we were talking yesterday with a mixed bag of people - French. German, Polish, American, Irish and non could see any benefit at all. They were too polite to actually say to me they thought the Brits barking mad but the obviously do!

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 09:42:05

ygg I think too that business is already getting fed up and beginning to invest elsewhere. This will become a haemorrhage if decisions aren't soon made, but listening tobDavis this morning I wouldn't hold my breath.

The Tories associated with business will soon begin to agitate.

I await with interest the papers due to be produced next week by the government to see if any discernible sense is becoming more clear. I fear that I will be disappointed.

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 09:35:54

I have just caught up with the conversation about unemployed migrant workers and must concur with ww andygg

That is one of the criticisms levelled at May in her not getting a grip with immigration amongst many others.

yggdrasil Tue 15-Aug-17 09:35:27

And I am still trying to understand the benefits of Brexit.

They are now saying they want a deal as near to the Single Market as possible, with the benefits of the Customs Union.
It is clear immigration is not a problem, or wasn't until the nurses care-workers teachers etc started leaving. After all, we have full employment, apparently.
Nobody has yet told me what sovereignity is supposed to mean, and we haven't heard much about that recently anyway.
What have I missed?

yggdrasil Tue 15-Aug-17 09:30:27

POGS/WW the relevant details about staying if you can't find work is here
www.europarl.europa.eu/atyourservice/en/displayFtu.html?ftuId=FTU_3.1.3.html

Not that difficult to find:-)

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 09:28:44

I have been wondering what business is making of all the shenanigans -they must be absolutely despairing.

Since last week we've had.

Leaving on 29/03/19 - no CU no SM

Transition arrangements so won't quite leave on 29/03/19

Will stay in the CU after the 29/03/19

There will be a temporary CU arrangement after 20/03/19

No! Not a temporary CU but something called a speedy and seamless process

Wonder what scheme they will have for tomorrow's headlines.

Meanwhile the clock is ticking, nothing yet been agreed, nothing practice in place.

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 09:14:16

Meanwhile the most rightwing potential leader ever waits in the wings

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 09:13:17

Yes ww I thought exactly that.

Quite honestly until they get their asses in gear and sort out the money, the migrant issue etc. Nothing else can be discussed.

You notice he was totally unprepared to discuss cash, as it is so contentious, but he is going to have to get that sorted first, and the longer they dither, the less time they will have to sort out all the complications.

He's up for leadership so isn't prepared to be responsible for making the financial settlement decision bring down Tory anger onto his head, he'd rather leave that for patsy May.

Welshwife Tue 15-Aug-17 08:32:23

What did you understand from the remark about a permanent no border with Europe? Sounds like a sort of Schengen.

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 08:26:04

So now we know the latest little nugget

It isn't going to be a customs union but a temporary customs union

Spot the difference?

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 08:22:30

Davis

Quote of the day

"Constructive ambiguity"

grin love it

whitewave Tue 15-Aug-17 08:01:49

Now seeking a temporary CU whilst being able to pursue other trade negotiations grin good luck with that!!!

Welshwife Sun 13-Aug-17 21:20:42

It is not a thing that the UK Govt has broadcast because I suppose people would ask why it has not been implemented.. I am very surprised you haven't seen this point as it has often been quoted even before the vote - but of course I do rend to see a lot of info on ex- pat groups - both UK citizens and those from the EU.

POGS Sun 13-Aug-17 20:58:43

Welsh wife

" The salient point there is that it is AFTER work has finished - not before it has started. "

Thank you for responding. I have done a 'cursory' search during today but I cannot find anything, whether it be before or after work, that says as you do:-

"If after three months you have no work and means of support you can be sent out of the country. There are also benefit checks in place which enable the country not to pay any till a person has contributed in some way - again the UK has CHOSEN not to implement this. "

If you find anything I will be interested , rather on the thread than a PM I don't like those much. I thought perhaps living in France there was a possibility your point had been made over there but at no time have I heard it mentioned here.

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion