Gransnet forums

News & politics

A divided society-what can be done?

(563 Posts)
trisher Wed 02-Aug-17 09:35:46

As Newcastle gets £500000 ot fight right wing extremism
www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/right-wing-edl-newcastle-racism-13402419
there is also news that the cities 2 universities are still attracting EU students and there are increasing numbers of students from the Middle and Far East coming here. Will the money really help? And what can be done to mend a fractured society? When I see the EDL demonstrating and yelling in a city centre crowded with all nationalities I can only see more trouble ahead. Can you educate people to understand the benefits these students bring?

trisher Mon 07-Aug-17 18:41:14

Annie if you are a 'true socialist" I am the Queen of Sheba.

Primrose65 Mon 07-Aug-17 17:56:54

grin

Anniebach Mon 07-Aug-17 17:56:23

Petra, as a true socialist it has been hell not coming out sooner, oh the relief

petra Mon 07-Aug-17 17:51:03

It's like an AA meeting, isn't it, when people go to their first meeting.
" hello, I'm Petra, and I'm a landlady" grin

petra Mon 07-Aug-17 17:48:30

annie
You must feel soooo relieved. Can't imagine carrying that guilt around flowers

Smileless2012 Mon 07-Aug-17 17:43:17

Perhaps we should start a new thread Annie for all money grabbing, selfish, ageist (against the young) landlordsgrin.

Anniebach Mon 07-Aug-17 17:36:51

Gilly, Petra, oh the relief of coming out, at least I was able to make sure my grandchildren had good rentals for second and third years in university grin , forgot , I have one in Hereford too blush

petra Mon 07-Aug-17 17:25:11

devongirl
What la la land are you in? If I went into my police station and said " I have a problem with my tenant" they would have good laugh. There's more chance of me getting nicked for wasting police time.

Smileless2012 Mon 07-Aug-17 17:20:18

My posts are over the top and unfounded trisher says the poster who suggested that I had hidden the fact I was a landlord and suggested I'd done so out of guilt!!!

I doesn't work that way devongirl. If a tenant vacates the property before the final inspection it's too late for the letting agent to do anything about it. Even if the agent sees the state it's in on the day of departure, they can't prevent the tenant from leaving.

The deposit can be retained and if that doesn't cover the cost of repairs and replacements the landlord can go to court. A lengthy and costly business and even if costs are awarded, getting the money is easier said than done.

durhamjen Mon 07-Aug-17 17:07:33

"Society as a whole was probably different when you were renting, durhamjen - how long ago was it?"

No, Ana, you did not ask me that or suggest that was when you meant. I did not know it very well. Perhaps you ought to make your statements more plain.
Then I might understand.

I rented when I was 18, 22, 26, 40, 50 and twice in my 60s.

Would you like to ask me about any of those times?

Primrose65 Mon 07-Aug-17 17:02:55

They've broken a contract devongirl which is not the same as committing a crime. Just google how it works, it's not what you think and it's surprisingly incorrect for someone who has been a landlord.

Ana Mon 07-Aug-17 16:58:58

And you know very well I was asking what period it was you were talking about durhamjen (i.e. when your children were teenagers), not 7 years ago...

devongirl Mon 07-Aug-17 16:58:54

Yes, we did. If tenants are in violation of their contract, which details the expectation that it will be returned in it's original state, they have committed a crime.

durhamjen Mon 07-Aug-17 16:58:45

Where were you all when you were 34?
Did you share flats with friends?

Primrose65 Mon 07-Aug-17 16:54:17

"before the Tories had demonised under 35s"
You're joking dj
Surely the Tories have demonised everyone except the landed gentry and billionaires!

Primrose65 Mon 07-Aug-17 16:49:05

That's not how it works devongirl. It's nothing to do with the police! Did you rent your property on an AST?

durhamjen Mon 07-Aug-17 16:44:38

Last time I rented was 7 years ago.
Yes it was a different society, before the Tories had demonised under 35s.

devongirl Mon 07-Aug-17 16:40:39

It's not a matter of blaming agents for the actions of a tenant, but they should check the property when the tenants move out, with the tenants there, and if damage is found it should be deducted from their deposit; if that's not enough, it should be reported to the police. A good agent will perform regular checks on the property so damage on a large scale would not be able to accumulate.

Primrose65 Mon 07-Aug-17 16:26:30

I'm not keen on blaming agents for the actions of a tenant, I much prefer personal responsibility. If landlords have had problems with a particular demographic, they're going to avoid them in future. Blame the idiots who trash properties or who don't pay rent. My youngest is renting at the moment and I was surprised at the hoops she had to jump through - I've been a landlord in the past and although things have changed, I can see both sides.

devongirl Mon 07-Aug-17 16:25:07

Off to a tangent here - when I was living in London I found it impossible to find an agency that would keep a proper eye on the house we rented out while working overseas. However where I live there is an excellent agency which would never have allowed the tenants to check out leaving that kind of damage behind, so yes, smileless, you DO need a better agent!

trisher Mon 07-Aug-17 16:19:25

What moral high ground? You really have some sort of problem Smileless2012 I don't know what it is but your responses are over the top and unfounded. Why is believing in higher taxation 'moral high ground'? I'm lost!

trisher Mon 07-Aug-17 16:16:02

And yes f your tenant comes through an agency and wrecks your property you need a better agent-seems obvious to me.

Smileless2012 Mon 07-Aug-17 16:15:05

You know what trisher you appear to be so tunnel visioned that you are either unable or unwilling to digest the content of others' posts. So, I do not feel guilty, there's no reason why I should. I didn't keep quiet, my being a landlord wasn't relevant to any of the posts I've made on this thread until I responded to dj's.

You're not alone in believing "higher incomes should be (and are) taxed more as well". Be careful that you don't take a fall from the moral high ground you've set yourself on, you might get injured.

trisher Mon 07-Aug-17 16:14:31

I don't think you can judge young people by 1or 2 bad experiences. There are a number of properties rented by young people down my street. They seem well cared for and they have had numerous tenants over the years. This is a student city and there are heaps of young tenants.

Ana Mon 07-Aug-17 16:09:41

Society as a whole was probably different when you were renting, durhamjen - how long ago was it?

Sadly, some people (and especially some young people) don't care about the home they are renting and treat it with disdain.