Gransnet forums

News & politics

EU wants us to pay 89 BILLION divorce charges.

(395 Posts)
Day6 Fri 20-Oct-17 13:07:50

Walk away very quickly Theresa May. This is NOT ON. Blackmail or what?

How many of us knew that was the figure the EU demanded? Spite and greed...

From the Guardian. On Thursday morning, political allies of the German chancellor, Angela Merkel, confirmed that the EU wants the UK to agree to pay up to €100bn (£89.4bn) to settle the Brexit divorce bill.

89 BILLION........89 BILLION!!! Before Brussels will even consider a trade deal.

I see the Leaving the EU thread has been pulled because of personal insults.

We have to pull the plug on the EU because this is a divorce lawyers equivalent of pure spite and greed.

We will walk away with no deal and rightly so. Being held over a barrel by EU politicians is not on. We have made an a reasonable offer ...in billions, (£17b billion I believe) just to break away, before any trade deal is discussed. This is not acceptable to the greedy Brussels gravy train.

Now we are being held to ransom by Brussels,

No business man EVER would settle for a bad deal. No wonder talks have stalled.

Walk away very quickly Theresa May. This is blackmail.

WTO talks should begin asap. We will trade with the rest of the world. The EU is cutting off it's nose to spite it's face. Let it do so.

89 BILLION. It is beyond belief...That's what the EU wants just to settle the divorce bill before any trading agreement is reached. I would not want to do business with that firm of shysters.

No deal it is and rightly so. That is all we can consider in the face of EU spite and greed. Let's start afresh.

quEEEniE Sat 21-Oct-17 09:29:03

put a cheque on the table and say "thats it from Uk " and walk away. Up to EU if they cash the cheque.

mostlyharmless Sat 21-Oct-17 09:28:00

There's a bit of hysteria about this £89 billion "divorce bill".
It is very unlikely that the final bill will be that high as this is still in negotiation. The final bill will almost definitely be somewhere between this 89 billion and the 20 billion offered by our government.

But to put this figure in a bit more perspective, it will be paid over several years.

The UK economy generates nearly £2000 billion a year. (1940 bn GDP in 2016), so the bill will be a small percentage of our total annual income (between 1 and 4 %) and paid over several years.

The greater problem will be the huge harm to our trade if there is a hard Brexit. That would dwarf them"divorce bill" and would last for up to a decade.

Nezumi65 Sat 21-Oct-17 09:09:50

Got as far as this I would imagine they won't be fighting each other for a chance to work in Frankfurt, it's not exactly London and realised I will never understand the mentality of Brexiteers.

moxeyns Sat 21-Oct-17 08:53:24

My understanding is that this is pretty much the minimum figure to meet commitments the UK is involved in.
Did the leavers think that we could just walk away?!

BRedhead59 Sat 21-Oct-17 08:42:45

This is just one of the things we were NOT told before the vote. The whole EU thing is highly complex and we are totally enmeshed. This whole thing is going to cost us. Hopefully, we will realise before it's too late. Suggest we all make a list of the good pros and cons and see how we get on.

MaizieD Sat 21-Oct-17 08:35:29

When I tried to find the source of Day6's figure the only 'result' Google gave me that mentioned it in this way was this thread shock

When I dug a bit deeper it turns out that 100 billion euros (£89 billion) was the figure that was being trumpeted by the Brexit Media before negotiations started last Spring. So OP is repeating very outdated news which is no longer true (if it ever was).

Curiously, when I googled on £89 billionI got hundreds of results citing that figure as being our trade deficit with the EU. I'm not sure what the connection is but it set me wondering why the media picked on it that figure for a possible 'divorce' payment.(Apart from continuing their very own Project Fear EU, of course)

Grampie Sat 21-Oct-17 08:34:39

Where can we study the detailed invoice for this charge?

...just so we can see if we agreed the expenditure in the first place!

jane1956 Sat 21-Oct-17 08:24:01

Paddyann the Majority were NOT remainers last June, we voted Leave. Liz Kershaw said yesterday, it is like going to the pub every week with your mates and always getting your round in. This week you say I am not going, so your mates reply that you still have to get your round in!!!! How many remainers would agree to that????

whitewave Sat 21-Oct-17 08:12:30

Just to calm the op down a tad.

This morning the report is that the final total being talked about is 20bn May has already agreed to plus another 20bn to be paid over a number of years to cover our agreed liability to planned projects, pensions etc. That is the figure over which negotiations will take place -so take heart all Brexiters, undoubtedly that figure will be negotiated down so there really is no need to panicsmile

MaizieD Fri 20-Oct-17 22:00:39

Who thought it would be easy?

Well, this guy does, for a start:

www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2017/07/20/liam-fox-is-right-brexit-is-easy-were-leaving-whats-difficult-about-that/#520a40761a2b

And John Redwood:

johnredwoodsdiary.com/2016/07/17/getting-out-of-the-eu-can-be-quick-and-easy-the-uk-holds-most-of-the-cards-in-any-negotiation/

Paul Nutall:

www.express.co.uk/news/uk/755210/Paul-Nuttall-Ukip-insists-Theresa-May-Brexit-negotiations-easy

And here they are again in company with a few more:

www.buzzfeed.com/patricksmith/nobody-said-it-was-easy?utm_term=.twjGgZg77#.jlp1585rr

While all these people may not have convinced the wise and deep thinking Gransnet Leavers I suspect that a significant number of people did believe them. Else why are so many Leavers on other social media absolutely certain that it should be easy?

durhamjen Fri 20-Oct-17 21:55:00

First minute and a half of this, Margaret, and they said that Brexit wasn't mentioned in their papers, and definitely not on the front pages.

www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/NegotiatingBrexit

durhamjen Fri 20-Oct-17 21:49:24

20,000 needed to cope with the 3million EU citizens needing thei right to remain status, Tegan.

petra Fri 20-Oct-17 21:42:32

MargaretX
Your right there Re Turkey. Merkel and the eu really are between a rock and a hard place. German citizens have been arrested in Turkey but they have to still pay Turkey money otherwise Erdogan will just let 10s of 1,000s of migrants into Europe. Then she/them will really have a problem.
Brexit is nothing compared to that would be headache.

Tegan2 Fri 20-Oct-17 21:34:14

I wish those that throw around such figures would also throw around a few figures telling us how much brexit has cost/is costing/will cost us in the future. I dread to think how many civil servants/consultants etc have been recruited, both here and in the EU, to deal with it all. Not only that but the PM was quite happy to spend a lot of money on an unnecessary election in a futile attempt to get a bigger majority in parliament, and that's even before giving vast amounts of money to the DUP.

loopyloo Fri 20-Oct-17 21:26:01

We knew the EU would not make leaving easy. Even more reason for us to escape.

suzied Fri 20-Oct-17 21:20:58

I don't recall any leave campaigners telling us leaving would be tortuous. But now they all claim they " knew it wouldn't be easy"!

NfkDumpling Fri 20-Oct-17 21:04:47

Of course leaving isn't going to be easy, but a lot better in the long run than staying in. I'll go now. I'd vowed to stay away from any Brexit thread as it only ends up in a slagging match. Don't know why I opened it.

whitewave Fri 20-Oct-17 20:53:22

Ahead of you on that

lemongrove Fri 20-Oct-17 20:50:43

Take a thermos with you.?

whitewave Fri 20-Oct-17 20:48:13

grin I’ll get back on that lemon I’m off now to ask all those voting leave. I may be some time.

MargaretX Fri 20-Oct-17 20:47:41

Brexit is to the UK everything but to the millions living in the EU it is just one more subject. Many days pass by when the news doesn't mention Brexit. The EU has other more pressing subjects to worry about - Turkey eg.

If I remember rightly the UK signed all the documents which relate to the divorce bill. The main mistake concerning the referendum was that whereas in most EU countries 70 % of all possible voters must vote yes before a refendum is successful.
Cameron should have knewn that. What a fool he was.

lemongrove Fri 20-Oct-17 20:40:01

Nobody, I should think, voted Leave ‘ because it would be easy’ no point to that at all, they voted that way for various reasons, but it being easy to do didn’t come into the equation.

durhamjen Fri 20-Oct-17 20:39:45

theconversation.com/dig-for-brexit-comments-reveal-the-uk-government-digging-a-food-security-hole-for-itself-85798

Dead easy, varian, although Brexiteers are denying they said so.
Chris Grayling thinks it is, but he's an .....

lemongrove Fri 20-Oct-17 20:36:59

Who thought it would be easy?
Since there is no actual policy in place for leaving ( the EU couldn't imagine anyone wanting to leave!) then it was always going to be time consuming working out all the negotiations.But it will be done.

varian Fri 20-Oct-17 20:31:18

Exactly lemongrove nothing much is happening. It was all supposed to be so easy. How many people voted leave because they were told it would be easy?