Gransnet forums

News & politics

Carillion

(479 Posts)
maryeliza54 Mon 15-Jan-18 07:55:13

So it’s happened - what an unholy mess. Why on earth were they allowed to grow so big and to diversify so much? How many companies went to the wall because they were priced out by Carillion who must have put in completely unrealistic tenders to win contracts? All those worried employees and what about the pension fund? The magic money tree will be in full working order no doubt. W hat about HS2 - they got the contract when they were already in trouble. The government has made some truly incredible decisions knowing this - is there sheer incompetence here or something more sinister?

whitewave Fri 19-Jan-18 16:21:23

Nothing to do with Carillion, but everything to do with the poor taxpayer picking up yet more.

There is a block of flats with the type of cladding that was put onto Grenfell. The cost of removing is £4million. The billionaire owner says that the tenants must pay which amounts to £31000 each. Can’t be done.

So now apparently the tax payer is to pick up the tab.

This can’t be right?

durhamjen Fri 19-Jan-18 16:21:04

So I guess you didn't read Adonis's article, MOnica.
Not surprised.

gillybob Fri 19-Jan-18 16:20:43

I don’t think the outsourced company were inexperienced, just completed overwhelmed by the rise in referrals with lack of money and resources. In other words....it’s a mess.

whitewave Fri 19-Jan-18 16:15:31

Exactly! That is what has largely to be found. Outsourcing is so frequently given to non-expertise.

gillybob Fri 19-Jan-18 16:12:17

They’re not doing much better having been outsourced whitewave . I think that referrals to children’s services have risen rapidly and the outsourced company is struggling to deliver with limited resources.

whitewave Fri 19-Jan-18 16:04:54

gilly that’s the point I think - Corbyn has recognised that essential services are, as we know ,better carried out in house, but where it is deemed to be failing it may be better to outsource them

So the preference is always to carry essential services by those with the most expertise, but recognises that this is neither always possible nor desirable.

gillybob Fri 19-Jan-18 15:57:41

www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/childrens-services-sunderland-taken-over-10594299

Children’s services in Sunderland failed terribly in Local Authority control.

whitewave Fri 19-Jan-18 15:51:40

Outsourcing essential services has found largely not to be working, for almost every reason you can think.

whitewave Fri 19-Jan-18 09:21:09

Corbyn has an article in today’s guardian.

It will be Labour policy to retain all essential services in government and only outsource if they are proving to be failing. This is of course government policy in most of Europe.

Before any right winger starts to jump up and down this does not mean wholesale nationalisation. Large infrastructure project will still be tendered forcand carried out by private industry.

M0nica Fri 19-Jan-18 09:15:41

dj nothing is just one person's fault. The Carillion collapse had ramifications. As with everything it was a combination of poor management, poor auditing, failure of City experts to see the way the cookie was crumbling, greed - and government mismanagement. That Grayling contributed to the collapse is without a doubt, but you are flattering him to think that he alone engineered the whole collapse from start to finish. For what purpose?

durhamjen Fri 19-Jan-18 00:19:50

www.independent.co.uk/voices/carillion-conservative-party-donation-tory-collapse-government-contracts-pfi-hedge-fund-public-a8166581.html

durhamjen Thu 18-Jan-18 23:42:17

inews.co.uk/news/politics/lord-adonis-east-coast-rail-bail-accelerated-carillions-collapse/

All Grayling's fault.

durhamjen Thu 18-Jan-18 16:41:48

You don't really notice unless you have to, do you, Ilovecheese?
I was telling my grandson about the Gates in Durham being a Carillion site, and he hadn't noticed, even though we went past the site on the park and ride bus about once a week. He looked at the cranes, but never noticed those big contractors signs on them.

Ilovecheese Thu 18-Jan-18 16:33:38

Have had a trip to hospital today with my husband. Suddenly started noticing how many different logos were on people's jackets or lanyards. I wondered whether these were some of the sub contractors for Carillion.

durhamjen Thu 18-Jan-18 16:26:50

Hypocritical Tories. No wonder they didn't do anything about Carillion sooner.

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/theresa-branded-total-hypocrite-trousering-11868280

durhamjen Thu 18-Jan-18 11:31:02

www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2018/01/18/after-fifteen-years-of-my-saying-pfi-does-not-work-the-nao-finally-agrees-why-has-it-taken-so-long/

NAO report written before the Carillion collapse.

durhamjen Thu 18-Jan-18 11:16:21

An excellent article by Len McCluskey.

labourlist.org/2018/01/len-mccluskey-carillion-crisis-shows-how-spivs-have-infected-public-services-at-expense-of-workers/

WilmaKnickersfit Thu 18-Jan-18 01:31:43

I wondered what you meant about the children. It looked like you were talking to Jalima!

The cost of the whole outsourcing process must be ridiculous, even if a contract is well run. As for when it goes wrong... scandalous.

Time for bed moon

maryeliza54 Thu 18-Jan-18 01:18:50

Also re pensioners - existing pensioners will get lower annual increases and surviving spouses inherit a lesser %. There’s a lot of spin around isn’t there and/or lazy journalism.

maryeliza54 Thu 18-Jan-18 01:13:23

And as for the cost to us, think of all the time and resources that will have to be spent renegotiating contracts, arranging contingency plans, on retendering at local and national government level. It’s not as though las or the government have got anything else to be getting on with is it? PS I was talking about Branson’s children.

durhamjen Thu 18-Jan-18 00:29:54

Going to bed to get warmed up. Goodnight.

WilmaKnickersfit Thu 18-Jan-18 00:20:24

jen nobody challenging the information. The discussion just got a bit off track and I'm as much to blame as anyone, more probably. We're just commenting on the fact that the rich get away with blue murder. Chill.

durhamjen Thu 18-Jan-18 00:15:28

An awful lot of whatifery, jalima. I am sure those who are going to food banks are all thinking that at least they are better off than the poor of Beijing.
They probably don't even know that the gap between rich and poor is greater in the UK than any other country in the EU. Another of Chakrabortty's statistics for you to challenge.

Jalima1108 Thu 18-Jan-18 00:11:57

That's the thing with Billionaires, they can move whenever they want, unlike the fifth of the population who have less than the living wage

Quite
why should they worry, they won't have to mix with the likes of us

durhamjen Thu 18-Jan-18 00:09:57

www.cityam.com/239517/sunday-times-rich-list-2016-the-number-of-billionaires-in-london-has-fallen-but-its-still-the-super-rich-capital-of-the-world

Chakrabborty's link, as you would have realised if you had bothered looking at the link I put on.
Some must have left since the Brexit vote.
That's the thing with Billionaires, they can move whenever they want, unlike the fifth of the population who have less than the living wage - www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/uk-population-living-wage-less-fifth-workforce-minimum-quality-life-poverty-cost-a8035616.html