Gransnet forums

News & politics

Really??

(93 Posts)
NfkDumpling Thu 18-Jan-18 06:59:41

The following popped up on my FB page this morning.
I usually ignore all this sort of stuff but this seems too extreme and rather nasty. It follows on from a spate of ones about pensioners being better off in prison which did the rounds and died a year or two back and has now risen from the dead. I've no idea where to go to check the facts. I would assume that someone has found a refugee family who have received this sort of help - and probably needed and deserved it - and assumed a blanket award for all refugees, legal or otherwise. But am I being too kind?

Pip Keeling
13 January 2017 ·
STATE PENSION - keep this going please

Read and pass on:
Dear Prime Minister
I wish to ask you a Question:- "Is This True?"
I refer to the Pension Reality Check.

Are you aware of the following ?

The British Government provides the following financial assistance:-

BRITISH OLD AGED PENSIONER
(bearing in mind they worked hard and paid their Income Tax and National
Insurance contributions to the British Government all their working life)
Weekly allowance: £106.00

IMMIGRANTS/REFUGEES LIVING IN BRITAIN
(No Income Tax and National Insurance contribution whatsoever)
Weekly allowance: £250.00

BRITISH OLD AGED PENSIONER
Weekly Spouse Allowance: £25.00

ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS/REFUGEES LIVING IN BRITAIN
Weekly Spouse Allowance: £225.00

BRITISH OLD AGED PENSIONER
Additional Weekly Hardship Allowance: £0.00

ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS/REFUGEES LIVING IN BRITAIN
Additional Weekly Hardship Allowance: £100.00

A British old age pensioner is no less hard up than an illegal immigrant/refugee yet receives nothing

BRITISH OLD AGED PENSIONER
TOTAL YEARLY BENEFIT: £6,000

ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS/REFUGEES LIVING IN BRITAIN
TOTAL YEARLY BENEFIT: £29,900

Please read all and then forward to all your contacts so that we can lobby for a decent state pension.
After all, the average pensioner has paid taxes and contributed to the growth of this country for the last 40 to 60 years.
Sad isn't it? Surely it's about time we put our own people first.

Oopsadaisy52 Thu 18-Jan-18 11:37:16

Don’t forget that you can ‘unfollow’ a friend, you don’t have to unfriend them, I’ve done that with some of mine because they post absolute tosh.

Baggs Thu 18-Jan-18 11:13:01

"We will all have seen and deleted the same or worse at some point"

Nope. Never. Stuff like that has never appeared on my FB page, nor have I seen it elsewhere.

And, as LucyGN says, stop attacking the poster and her friend. Attack the content and answer the OP's query about where to find the best counter-arguments to stuff like this so that she can explain things to her friend without ranting. (Not that I expect you would rant, nfk).

LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 18-Jan-18 10:47:36

Morning - just a reminder that we do ask posters to be civil to one another on the forums. NFKDumpling is clearly not in agreement with the Facebook post, and posted for advice on how to respond rather than to propagate the sentiments within it, so we think there may have been a bit of misunderstanding here. Please remember to be courteous to one another when replying.

GracesGranMK2 Thu 18-Jan-18 10:34:23

Totally disagree G23. Reference could have been made - there was no need to repost the whole thing. At the very least you have to question why it was.

I would also question the justification of the FB post with "I would assume that someone has found a refugee family who have received this sort of help". You only have to look up any of the benefits quoted. It is not justifiable and repeating it only play into the hands of the obnoxious human being who contrived it in the first place.

MaizieD Thu 18-Jan-18 10:33:13

I agree, G23

I know that some of us can be quite robust but turning on poor Nfk for posting it because she wanted information on how to refute it seems unfair to me.

It's a pity that this forum doesn't have a view counter, it's interesting to see how much, or how little notice is taken of threads. I can't see that 'News & Politics' will really have much traffic beyond the handful of regular posters so I doubt if it's done any damage.

Everyone has been unanimous in condemning it or pointing to fact checking sites so any chance visitor, apart from a rabid racist, would be most unlikely to believe it or pass it on.

MissAdventure Thu 18-Jan-18 10:30:07

That's a relief.

maryeliza54 Thu 18-Jan-18 10:28:24

Couldn’t disagree more G23 - she did absolutely not have to post it in all its glory to get advice.Those of us who are grown ups on here didn’t need to read it and those who read it who are racists will just believe it anyway. And before anyone starts jumping up and down of course there are racists who will read GN. If I wanted to discuss how awful child porn is would I need to post a photo to demonstrate that? Anyway, it’s done now and hopefully NfK has learned despite her self confessed small brain how to check such rubbish in the future. Nothing more to add from me

NfkDumpling Thu 18-Jan-18 10:27:22

I have asked for it to be deleted as requested. Perhaps Maryeliza would start a new thread, correctly worded.

NfkDumpling Thu 18-Jan-18 10:19:25

Thank you G23

Granny23 Thu 18-Jan-18 10:17:58

Oh come on you lot. We are all grown ups on here. NFK was just illustrating for us how truly awful this piece of Racist Porn is. We will all have seen and deleted the same or worse at some point and the discussion is about how to deal with a friend who posts such utter rubbish and where to find the correct information to refute the claims.

I had this same post forwarded to me by a friend some years ago, but she (by her own admission not very worldly wise) sent it in the spirit of 'surely this cannot be true? The piece itself may offend you but the reason for posting it in its entirety is not offensive.

NfkDumpling Thu 18-Jan-18 10:15:23

Yes ma’am immediately.

maryeliza54 Thu 18-Jan-18 10:05:15

It’s not superior intellect - it’s called being a thinking human being. Why not ask for it to be deleted?

NfkDumpling Thu 18-Jan-18 09:58:56

You, of course, would have done that, but me, being a bear of very little brain. Didn’t. Sorry. I was thinking along different lines. I bow to your superior intellect.

maryeliza54 Thu 18-Jan-18 09:51:00

Oh come on Nfk how on earth could illegal immigrants be entitled to anything? And just to check how easily you could have found out yourself, I just now typed into Google ‘illegal immigrants and benefits’ and the first link that came up was to fullfacts. Theres something I just don’t get in your saying that you wanted to point out it was doing the rounds again by contributing to it doing the rounds again. Those who are racists believe it anyway and those who aren’t know how nasty it is and wouldn’t dream of reposting it - if they even received it in the first place. I think it’s a piece of pollution on here and you could ask HQ to delete the thread and then you could start a thread about how to check racist social media posts without giving BF the oxygen of publicity

GracesGranMK2 Thu 18-Jan-18 09:46:04

I think it always worth remembering that saying that "lies are half-way round the world before truth has got his boots on" and not repeat them.

NfkDumpling Thu 18-Jan-18 09:36:37

My reason for posting the whole thing in the first place was to 1) find out what asylum seekers and illegal immigrants are entitled to (if anything) as I couldn’t find anything reliable, only suspect media reports; and 2) point out that it’s doing the rounds again. Perhaps I shouldn’t have posted the thing in it’s entirety but I wanted to show how nasty it was and how easy to be taken in and re-post.

paddyann Thu 18-Jan-18 08:57:05

I leave a msg under these posts and explain why I am now unfriending them .I wont pass on Britain First nonsense but it surprises me that seemingly intelligent people do.When this was first posted the asylum seekers were receiving £5 a day allowance for food ,utilities etc and a roof over their heads...often in properties that are/were substandard .They lie on the breadline and on a knifeedge waiting for the Home Ofiice to come drag them out of these "homes" and take them to detention centres ..from there they are often escorted back to where they come from.I have a friend who works for the home office escorting people back .These are people who are destitute and desperate ...and a lot of their problems are of OUR making .Who bombed their cities ..or provided the bombs ? Who has left the middle east in a far worse state than it was before Iraq or Afghanistan ? We OWE them refuge

GracesGranMK2 Thu 18-Jan-18 08:49:34

you your

GracesGranMK2 Thu 18-Jan-18 08:46:15

NfkD what was you point in promulgating such obvious lies? If you were not sure, surely the thing to do was make a check of basic state pensions.

Of course I'm not going to circulate it Wilma You have! You did! You posted the vile fakery on here and someone, somewhere will be very glad to believe it because it will back their nasty little views.

NfkDumpling Thu 18-Jan-18 08:41:06

Some really nice people are easily lead - and easily upset. It can be difficult to put them right without hurt. I have replied to this friends post to the effect that it's old fake news, best to check first - but I've done that before and she's slipping back into old habits. I fear she has friends who will pass it on. I've reported it to FB in the hope they can do something. (not holding my breath on that one!)

WilmaKnickersfit Thu 18-Jan-18 08:34:19

Sorry for hijacking the thread.

WilmaKnickersfit Thu 18-Jan-18 08:30:13

OldMeg I'm leaning towards meeting up with her because even though we don't see each other much, it's like we just last met yesterday. We just clicked when we met on a training course and spent 6 weeks sharing accommodation which was some of the best times in my life. Thanks for the advice, I think I will get in touch with her. I know she'll be falling over herself trying to apologise about the whole thing.

OldMeg Thu 18-Jan-18 08:25:02

Wilma give her one last chance and meet up. But do discuss her attitude when you meet and see if she has truly taken your comments on board. If so great, but if not then you’ll have your answer.

MaggieMay60 Thu 18-Jan-18 08:23:34

Thank you Eglantine for posting the address of full fact, I always trawled the net trying to find out the truth now I can just click on my favourites bar. smile

OldMeg Thu 18-Jan-18 08:22:07

Don’t be afraid to point out to your friend thst this is blatant, racist rubbish. If she is so ready to believe this sort of stuff you almost have a duty to tell her it’s not on.

Something like ‘sorry Xxxx I just have to point out that this is a load of bollocks spread by a racist website. I hope you don’t think any of this is actually true. You’ve quite upset me.’

You can of course leave out any words you consider offensive don’t water the message down. Sometimes we are complicit in racism simply because we are too polite or timid to say anything.