Gransnet forums

News & politics

Would the EU ever trust us and want us back???

(304 Posts)
Kali2 Sun 25-Jul-21 09:19:46

Let's imagine the majority of people in the UK change their mind about leaving. Comes a new PM next election, who is pro EU and wants to negotiate a return, with the backing of a strong majority of the population, say 65% + -

what would the EU say?

As many headlines around the world have been saying this week- Can the UK ever be trusted again?

Alegrias1 Tue 27-Jul-21 09:41:47

25Avalon

Lincslass

Why even ask the question, we won’t be going back. I for one never trusted the EEC, voted no, done to benefit the major players of France and Germany, those who want their eyes opened should read this excellent book.

Thanks Lincslass proof of what I have long suspected. I have ordered a Kindle copy for £3.19. Thank God for Nigel Farage.

Just reading the title and reviews of a book self-published by a committed brexiter in 2014, does not constitute "proof".

No wonder we're in this mess.

Callistemon Tue 27-Jul-21 09:37:44

MaizieD

^And we are told that young people are annoyed with the older generation, blaming them for Brexit.^

If this holds true, then, despite the hopes of the largely Leave voting generation, there is a fair chance that they will make their way back into the EU once we're out of the way.

I only have Gransnetters' word for that!!
It's supposition.

The other supposition is that the EU will no longer exist
Anything could happen including a new world power taking over.

All we do is speculate.

MaizieD Tue 27-Jul-21 09:33:42

If we're going to get into conspiracy theories about the EU, perhaps people should be aware of this one, which deals with why the UK was manipulated out of the EU.

bakerstreetherald.com/2020/09/case-1-the-tabula-rasa/

25Avalon Tue 27-Jul-21 09:24:16

Lincslass

Why even ask the question, we won’t be going back. I for one never trusted the EEC, voted no, done to benefit the major players of France and Germany, those who want their eyes opened should read this excellent book.

Thanks Lincslass proof of what I have long suspected. I have ordered a Kindle copy for £3.19. Thank God for Nigel Farage.

Lincslass Tue 27-Jul-21 08:10:56

Why even ask the question, we won’t be going back. I for one never trusted the EEC, voted no, done to benefit the major players of France and Germany, those who want their eyes opened should read this excellent book.

vegansrock Tue 27-Jul-21 07:47:08

Many people were certain that all the EU countries were deeply envious of the U.K. leaving and there would be mass exodus from the EU straight away. Hasn’t happened, they’ve looked at the divisions, the costs, the political chaos caused, now the EU has a high approval rating in most EU countries.

Kali2 Tue 27-Jul-21 07:46:28

Yes, that is the key, I am sure.

MaizieD Tue 27-Jul-21 07:30:24

And we are told that young people are annoyed with the older generation, blaming them for Brexit.

If this holds true, then, despite the hopes of the largely Leave voting generation, there is a fair chance that they will make their way back into the EU once we're out of the way.

grannypiper Tue 27-Jul-21 06:37:06

Why on earth would we want to go back ? I don't think that in 10 years time there will be an E.U.

nanna8 Tue 27-Jul-21 01:47:32

Throughout history the UK or parts of it ( the Scots have more sense!)have always had a love hate relationship with various parts of Europe. Perhaps it is going through a hate phase? Sometimes France, sometimes Spain, sometimes Germany, sometimes Russia. Totally reciprocated of course. That was one of the reasons I totally rejoiced when they started the EU, I though it might prevent any future wars. Hah, little did I know.

Callistemon Mon 26-Jul-21 21:00:46

If younger people are blaming older voters then I believe it was younger voters who cba to vote.
And we are told that young people are annoyed with the older generation, blaming them for Brexit.

I am very annoyed with the CBA Brigade who now moan about the fact we left.

Welshwife Mon 26-Jul-21 21:00:00

I think that many of the people who didn’t vote chose not to because they had no understanding of what the EU was or what was at risk. The most googled thing after the voting was - what is the EU? — says it all really.

25Avalon Mon 26-Jul-21 20:56:45

You never know there might have been even more votes to leave.

Callistemon Mon 26-Jul-21 20:43:39

Shouldn’t you be blaming all those who couldn’t be bothered to vote? You never know they may well have voted to remain…

Yes.

You cannot blame voters for exercising their franchise but you can blame those who just couldn't be bothered to get off their backsides and vote.

varian Mon 26-Jul-21 19:31:12

GrannyGravy13

varian

Only 17m out of a population of 67m ever voted for this brexit nonsense.

Most of us would ;love to reverse that ridiculous decision.

Whether our erstwhile EU partners would ever contemplate allowing us to rejoin is another thing.

I do wish you would stop laying the blame on the 17.4 million who voted to leave the EU.

Shouldn’t you be blaming all those who couldn’t be bothered to vote? You never know they may well have voted to remain…

Who else can we blame? The liars who conned the 17.4m people?

lemongrove Mon 26-Jul-21 19:26:28

growstuff why would you think my comments were addressed to you?

GrannyGravy13 Mon 26-Jul-21 18:59:20

varian

Only 17m out of a population of 67m ever voted for this brexit nonsense.

Most of us would ;love to reverse that ridiculous decision.

Whether our erstwhile EU partners would ever contemplate allowing us to rejoin is another thing.

I do wish you would stop laying the blame on the 17.4 million who voted to leave the EU.

Shouldn’t you be blaming all those who couldn’t be bothered to vote? You never know they may well have voted to remain…

varian Mon 26-Jul-21 18:42:42

Only 17m out of a population of 67m ever voted for this brexit nonsense.

Most of us would ;love to reverse that ridiculous decision.

Whether our erstwhile EU partners would ever contemplate allowing us to rejoin is another thing.

growstuff Mon 26-Jul-21 18:42:12

Ellianne

No paranoia from me, just referring to an article from the FT a couple of months ago when I was following the Sarkozy case.
^The sentencing of the former president has set off shockwaves in France. The country has some of the highest levels of political mistrust in Europe. In asurveycarried out in January and February in France, Germany, Italy and the UK, French citizens were the most damning of their political class. Some 65 per cent think that elected members and leaders of political parties are “mostly corrupt”; only 42 per cent take that view in Germany and 52 per cent in the UK. Moreover, only 16 per cent of the French trust their political parties versus 17 per cent in Italy, 32 per cent in the UK and 39 per cent in Germany.^

Hmmm ... I wonder what the French and Germans would make if the current British government were in charge of their countries. Would they have prosecuted them too?

growstuff Mon 26-Jul-21 18:39:51

lemongrove

It doesn’t matter if the EU trust us or not, or if we trust them or not for the future because we are extremely unlikely to ever join them again.

That wasn't the question in the OP.

growstuff Mon 26-Jul-21 18:38:31

Lincslass

Whitewavemark2

Ellianne

WWM2
Can I pick up on something said here please? The European Union can only function if it abides by the rules set done and agreed by all its members. It has a reputation for an absolute stickler to the rule book.
Do you mean big rules or little rules affecting the average man on the street. When we lived in France for several years we saw French people ignoring or breaking little rules daily, far more than in the UK. When my husband discussed business with French people he was pretty horrified to hear what they got up to, and the French were equally horrified to hear how honest and above board he was being in his business!

I mean the rules that govern the SM, freedom of movement, cash and goods.

Without those it simply wouldn’t function and the EU is very careful to keep to them.

Regarding the day to day rules regarding internal tax etc, my previous employment meant that I was totally aware of each countries compliance to their own rules. Some are more compliant than others and believe me France is not the most non-compliant. Neither are the British the most compliant. Look at the level of tax evasion etc.

here is the list of tax evading countries, France,Germany, Italy at the top.
www.statista.com/chart/17133/tax-evasion-cost-to-eu-countries, with U K fourth. May be a surprise for some.

But this is about our government, not individual companies. It's hardly a matter of pride to be associated with countries where corruption is a way of life. I used to think the UK was above that. This is about negotiating and signing agreements and going back on them and wanting to renegotiate.

growstuff Mon 26-Jul-21 18:35:41

lemongrove

Starting threads ( constantly!) running down the UK sounds like xenophobia to me.It certainly would be I bet if posters constantly started threads running down just about everything about France.
I really don’t know what posters get out of it....kali you say
“There are truly some unpleasant people on here for sure” well I may agree with you on that but would never say so, just because others don’t agree with me.
I have read your threads ( under all your different names) on here for years, and they all do down the UK for various reasons.

Under all my different names? Ahem! If that's what you think, you're assigning comments to me which I have never written and have nothing to do with me.

As I was saying ... there are some unpleasnat comments on this thread ...

I'll stick with what I wrote because that's the impression I have from following the media in other countries and it addresses the OP. It's nothing to do with what I think of my country.

25Avalon Mon 26-Jul-21 18:20:30

Just demonstrating that if one part is untrustworthy it doesn’t necessarily follow that all parts are. Nothing to do with xenophobia.

Ellianne Mon 26-Jul-21 17:40:30

Alegrias1

Not you Ellianne, no. But the suggestion was made that we can't trust the German government because a German company behaved illegally.

Still deciding if that's xenophobia or not smile

Difficult one Alegrias. It's back to lumping all and sundry under the one umbrella which only gives a snapshot at one particular time.

Alegrias1 Mon 26-Jul-21 17:26:12

Not you Ellianne, no. But the suggestion was made that we can't trust the German government because a German company behaved illegally.

Still deciding if that's xenophobia or not smile