Gransnet forums

News & politics

Official tonight 'Brexit is NOT done'

(249 Posts)
Kali2 Wed 02-Feb-22 22:12:37

as checks between mainland UK and NI stop. Breaking not only the signed Treaty, but International Law.

Urmstongran Thu 03-Feb-22 10:54:14

but at least they got their blue (black?) passports infantile response growstuff I expect better from you.

growstuff Thu 03-Feb-22 10:53:50

Urmstongran

Especially as the DUP didn’t support the deal. Their frustration about the situation is palpable.

Tough!

growstuff Thu 03-Feb-22 10:53:29

Whitewavemark2

What I don’t understand is that the DUP do not have a majority.

This must be being done unilaterally and unconstitutionally.

Yes, it's being argued that they are acting unconstitutionally.

Urmstongran Thu 03-Feb-22 10:52:51

Especially as the DUP didn’t support the deal. Their frustration about the situation is palpable.

growstuff Thu 03-Feb-22 10:52:34

Urmstongran

I respectfully disagree with your statement MaizieD A withdrawal Agreement with the EU was always going to mean agreeing a border between NI and the EU. And it was not the responsibility of the EU to set it up whatever Brexiters want to believe

70% of trade for NI is with the UK.
If we don’t do anything, it’ll be up to the EU to decide whether to erect a border.
They won’t of course, it’s just posturing. Use the technology that’s to hand say the hauliers.

This is about politics though, not trade.

It's about people who didn't listen, when others were asking how the situation could be resolved. They just stuck their fingers in their ears and ignored the issues - but at least they got their blue (black?) passports.

Urmstongran Thu 03-Feb-22 10:51:21

The DUP are fed up with the UK government getting “nowhere”. They’ve thrown a hand grenade into the mix. This is going to get very messy.

growstuff Thu 03-Feb-22 10:50:07

Those of you who think Northern Ireland is just a political pawn should watch this:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=nLyRufzQCw8&t=35s

Allsorts Thu 03-Feb-22 10:49:32

Let’s hope now, the government can concentrate on the things that do need intervention and govern.

Urmstongran Thu 03-Feb-22 10:49:07

I respectfully disagree with your statement MaizieD A withdrawal Agreement with the EU was always going to mean agreeing a border between NI and the EU. And it was not the responsibility of the EU to set it up whatever Brexiters want to believe

70% of trade for NI is with the UK.
If we don’t do anything, it’ll be up to the EU to decide whether to erect a border.
They won’t of course, it’s just posturing. Use the technology that’s to hand say the hauliers.

This is about politics though, not trade.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 03-Feb-22 10:47:02

What I don’t understand is that the DUP do not have a majority.

This must be being done unilaterally and unconstitutionally.

Urmstongran Thu 03-Feb-22 10:44:30

I too bet the UK government are loving it. The DUP doing the dirty work.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 03-Feb-22 10:04:51

I bet Liz Truss has her finger deep in this pie - guaranteed.

MaizieD Thu 03-Feb-22 10:01:45

It is a ridiculous state of affairs and the U.K. government should bang heads together, because at the moment the DUP is threatening to ignore an international agreement in which the U.K. is party to.

Well, they aren't going to, are they? See the NI Sec's comment above...
twitter.com/DarranMarshall/status/1488982263878623237

I bet the government are loving it

Kali2 Thu 03-Feb-22 09:57:04

Did you see on the news yesterday, the many cases of terrible bio security on farms with carcasses of sick animals? And the very clear message, that BSE has NOT gone away.

Of course the EU does not want to risk animal bio security via meat products entering their markets- now with antibiotics and all sorts of feeds disallowed by EU regulations, and/or imports from OZ and NZ, etc. If those animals or meat products, or other produce, enter NI without checks or border, they could easily go on and beyond NI.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 03-Feb-22 09:51:55

The DUP and Sinn Fein are in perpetual stand offs. This is a reflection of another one.

It is a ridiculous state of affairs and the U.K. government should bang heads together, because at the moment the DUP is threatening to ignore an international agreement in which the U.K. is party to.

MaizieD Thu 03-Feb-22 09:50:16

The NI Secretary had this to say this morning:

"This is a matter for the Northern Ireland Executive. It is something that is within their legal remit.”

Which I think is very odd. So we can force them out of the EU against their will but we can't force them to observe the terms of the Withdrawal Agreement?

And should, perhaps, be read in conjunction with D.A. Green's comment which Wwmk2 has posted above.

A withdrawal Agreement with the EU was always going to mean agreeing a border between NI and the EU. And it was not the responsibility of the EU to set it up whatever Brexiters want to believe.

If we were inside the EU looking out at another country which had this situation developing I don't think we would be showing any toleration of rogue behaviour.

Lincslass Thu 03-Feb-22 09:36:35

Oh so Poots is speaking for the U.K. is he. I don’t believe any announcement came from Downing St re stopping customs checks. Perhaps listen to what Poots says as to why he has done this. It is concerning, of course it is, but one wonders why he has done this
www.thejournal.ie/explainer-northern-ireland-checks-halt-5671906-Feb2022/. Of course many won’t read it as they back the EU no matter what the grievance of the country involved.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 03-Feb-22 09:34:52

davidallengreen
@davidallengreen
·
9m
The London government recently took the Scottish government to the Supreme Court so that devolved assembly in Scotland could not do things like this
If the London government supports the Northern Ireland executive in doing this then they can have no objection in principle to far greater autonomy for Scottish and Welsh executives

Urmstongran Thu 03-Feb-22 09:27:45

The First Minister of NI has written his resignation letter. A very unstable situation now for the power sharing government.

Petera Thu 03-Feb-22 09:23:45

Urmstongran

I think if the EU want to protect its borders they should sort out what arrangements are needed Petera. Arlene Foster says the EU could easily harness technology and ‘trusted trader’ checks. That they don’t want to speaks volumes as she said.

Meanwhile the UK are breaking an international treaty which speaks volumes. The UK repeatedly said that they had technological solutions - where are they? Has Arlene Foster described these technological solutions?

Alegrias1 Thu 03-Feb-22 09:21:28

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-60237565

Maybe it was Poots sabre rattling.

Urmstongran Thu 03-Feb-22 09:18:57

Strange there’s not a peep about all of this on SKY news this morning?

Urmstongran Thu 03-Feb-22 09:18:08

I think if the EU want to protect its borders they should sort out what arrangements are needed Petera. Arlene Foster says the EU could easily harness technology and ‘trusted trader’ checks. That they don’t want to speaks volumes as she said.

Urmstongran Thu 03-Feb-22 09:14:32

My reply was to Kali2.

Urmstongran Thu 03-Feb-22 09:13:59

That was Theresa May. She needed the support of the DUP to shore up (what was then) her minority government. It was called a ‘confidence and supply’ agreement and their votes were needed in the HoC at the time.

However, the Brexit withdrawal agreement negotiated by Theresa May's government, and then the revised agreement by Boris Johnson's government were both not supported by the DUP, who voted against the legislation in the HoC. The DUP never agreed to what they have got - annexation from the UK.