Gransnet forums

News & politics

Gransnet, Facebook and Twitter.

(62 Posts)
nanna8 Sat 26-Feb-22 11:41:05

I preferred the previous incarnation, not so aggressive and more reasonable. And not such an obvious troll.

growstuff Sat 26-Feb-22 11:37:38

I think it depends Dickens. I run a closed group for people with a specific interest. They have to apply to join and I do a cursory background check - nothing heavy, but if people have no online presence, I'm very wary.

Dickens Sat 26-Feb-22 11:34:17

Facebook versus Gransnet...

... I've read many more considered, objective and intelligent posts on GN than on FB - and I include those GNers whose political views are not the same as mine. Perhaps with maturity comes a certain amount of wisdom...

FB is just so random, the world and its wife can post - but on GN, we have common ground; shared experiences from a past era, etc, and often face similar future problems. So I find more sanity on GN.

Of course, there are some who post outlandish claims, misinformation, and not infrequently, they are hostile and dismissive if anyone dares to make a challenge. Then there's what I call the 'grenade lobbers'... posters who jump in write a few controversial words directed at no-one in particular... and then you never hear from them again. One the other day said "shut up"... not sure which group of posters the comment was directed at grin but that was it! They are often ignored, which is probably best!

Pittcity Sat 26-Feb-22 10:28:00

I agree OP.
That said I have just checked Facebook and Gransnet haven't added anything to their page since last September......

MaizieD Sat 26-Feb-22 10:26:22

It isn't confined to social media, though, is it? The print media, such as formerly highly respected newspapers, are also in the business of passing on lies and distortion. Which are frequently passed on through social media.

I think it's ironic that our current PM is a journalist who delighted in making up lies for his newspaper...

I think that google is actually your friend in searching for what might be factual and true as it presents you with a range of opinions, sometimes even learned opinions on any topic.

BlueBelle Sat 26-Feb-22 10:23:46

There is nothing saintly or different about GN it’s absolutely no difference to all the others
I don’t do Twitter simply because I never really got it and haven’t bothered to ‘get it’
The rest is equal amounts of good news and rubbish news be savvy enough to takes lots of it with a big old pinch of salt

varian Sat 26-Feb-22 10:09:57

The most dangerous propaganda usually has grains of truth mixed up with the lies.

GagaJo Sat 26-Feb-22 10:05:16

Couldn't agree more volver.

Zoejory Sat 26-Feb-22 09:56:57

GrannyGravy13

All social media is the 21st century’s equivalent of gossiping on the corner or over the garden fence.

Sometimes it’s correct, sometimes it isn’t as it’s always been

So true.

There's a tragic clip of 2 young Ukraine (allegedly) women hugging their soldier partners as they leave. It's all over TikTok. I'm sure it's been posted on other sites.

I fell for it.

However it's actually a scene from a movie, made 2 years ago. Actors. So if anyone has seen that, it's fake.

GrannyGravy13 Sat 26-Feb-22 09:48:57

All social media is the 21st century’s equivalent of gossiping on the corner or over the garden fence.

Sometimes it’s correct, sometimes it isn’t as it’s always been

Germanshepherdsmum Sat 26-Feb-22 09:21:50

I entirely agree.

volver Sat 26-Feb-22 09:18:10

Very often we hear the boast from posters on this forum that they don’t have Facebook/Twitter or so on because it’s a hotbed of lies and disinformation. Well in the past couple of days we have had a poster spreading lies about the reasons Russia have attacked Ukraine, we have had speculation on the source of the coronavirus which has sparked a slew of people saying they know it all along, and we’ve had completely wrong information about the progress of the Ukrainian invasion. Then we have the relatively unimportant attacks on minor royals who we’ve decided aren’t worthy of the name and we’ve had scaremongering about covid testing.

Nobody is immune to succumbing to disinformation. Don’t think that just because you’re a savvy old bird that they’ll get nothing past you. I’d be willing to bet that there are things you think are true that are based on false facts created by some unknown source. I don’t exclude myself from this.

If something is outlandish, if something is unlikely, if something sounds plausible because it supports your preconceptions but doesn’t have any facts to back it up, please take a minute to think, is this true? Remember that half an hour on google isn’t the same as several years’ experience in a subject. There’s no point in complaining about Facebook when that’s just a bigger version of Gransnet. People spread lies there and they spread lies here.

Now please feel free to tell me I don’t run the site, people can post what they like and that I have a stick up my a***. Heard it all before.