Gransnet forums

News & politics

Another Benefit of Brexit?

(457 Posts)
Granny23 Sun 18-Sept-22 11:14:25

Just this!

The pound is at its lowest level since the crash of 1985. The average UK household is projected to be poorer than the average Slovenian household by 2024 and Polish by 2030 (source: John Murdoch in the financial times today).
Glad we took back control eh!

Whitewavemark2 Tue 07-Feb-23 10:16:59

It isn’t that procedures have to improve, it is that they have to be introduced.

The EU fully implemented all procedures when we finally left the EU. The U.K. did not.

ronib Tue 07-Feb-23 10:13:16

Whitewavemark2 I think there’s more political fallout due their way if procedures are not improved. False move.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 07-Feb-23 10:05:43

ronib

Whitewavemark2 what is delaying the UK government in the simple matter of paperwork? Three years is quite long enough.

No, there is enough paperwork as it is, and a huge amount more expense to businesses and government.

The Tories are not prepared for the political fallout this would cause.

ronib Tue 07-Feb-23 07:54:53

Whitewavemark2 what is delaying the UK government in the simple matter of paperwork? Three years is quite long enough.

ronib Tue 07-Feb-23 07:49:44

vegansrock having dared to want to leave in the first place more likely.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 07-Feb-23 07:26:46

ronib

Normandygirl recently we bought items from an artist working in the Uk but delivered with all appropriate customs declarations from Latvia. The delivery costs were very economical too. I can’t but help think that movement of goods need not be such a big issue.

Wonder when the EU is going to let us off the naughty step?

The U.K. government has yet to introduce all checks, customs and excise charges etc.

All countries apart from those who have a trade agreement are on the so called naughty step or in grown up language treated as a third country.

It is called -the rules - such a large economic and powerful block as the EU are able to do this to protect all its members interests.

vegansrock Tue 07-Feb-23 07:07:32

What is the “naughty step”? Do you mean being treated as a non EU member? Isn’t that what Brexit suppporters want?

ronib Tue 07-Feb-23 06:33:12

Normandygirl recently we bought items from an artist working in the Uk but delivered with all appropriate customs declarations from Latvia. The delivery costs were very economical too. I can’t but help think that movement of goods need not be such a big issue.

Wonder when the EU is going to let us off the naughty step?

Normandygirl Mon 06-Feb-23 19:32:34

ronib

The skilled workers visa is a form of freedom of movement for the people we need to have here. There is another visa too for students.

The loss of freedom of movement is not just people, it's the loss of free movement of capital, goods and services also.
So, no, the visa does not replace in any way the lost freedoms.

Fleurpepper Mon 06-Feb-23 19:16:04

The Euro is not the only currency workers take into consideration when looking for work abroad. But yes, for the rest.

Casdon Mon 06-Feb-23 19:12:38

Fleurpepper

But it is not attracting new people. Sterling has tanked in last few years, so any savings would lose a lot of value now, compared to other currencies. Different for those who have settled here for some time.

I’m not a Brexit supporter Fleurpepper, but I know that what you have said about the pound tanking against the euro isn’t a phenomenon which correlates to Brexit happening. The pound has been relatively weak against the euro since 2008, and it’s not changed dramatically in the interim. I think it’s because other Europeans no longer feel welcome in the UK, and the bureaucracy, rather than the finance side of it that is putting them off coming here to work.

Fleurpepper Mon 06-Feb-23 18:48:33

So it is a treble negative combo- lower salary than elsewhere- lower exchange rate to return money home, and worse conditions and no welcome on top. No wonder!

Katie59 Mon 06-Feb-23 18:14:23

Brexit has given them the impression that we dont like foreigners, that does not help either, skilled workers often have a family, it’s more cost for them to move here. If we really wanted skilled workers there would be a “Golden Hello”.

Fleurpepper Mon 06-Feb-23 18:07:47

But it is not attracting new people. Sterling has tanked in last few years, so any savings would lose a lot of value now, compared to other currencies. Different for those who have settled here for some time.

ronib Mon 06-Feb-23 18:04:52

Fleurpepper surely this was the case before we left the EU too? In fact there are thriving French and Greek communities in London.

Fleurpepper Mon 06-Feb-23 17:55:13

Yes, but if Greek people go and work abroad, they will prefer to work where they are paid more than in the UK, and then get a much better exchange rate with their currency. Double win!

MaizieD Mon 06-Feb-23 17:54:21

ronib

MaizieD Keir Starmer has ruled out rejoining the EU apparently. I do like the idea of closer alignment with the EU but maybe it’s not that easy? I think the EU isn’t that interested in cooperating with us!

It's politic for him to do that. With possibly another 18months to go before a General Election why give the tories and the right wing, Brexit supporting, media a stick to beat him with during that period?

I think he'll move back to alignment and closer co-operation once in power. It would be foolish not to.

ronib Mon 06-Feb-23 17:53:14

Fleurpepper should have said concept of low salary depends on the country of origin. In Greece for example salaries are very very low.

Katie59 Mon 06-Feb-23 17:51:05

It is also an expensive and protracted application process, with a health service premium and proof of ability to support, it does not look attractive for a skilled worker, there are shortages in many EU countries with no beaurocracy.

ronib Mon 06-Feb-23 17:49:38

Fleurpepper skilled worker visa doesn’t mean it’s a low salary … anything over £10.10 per hour qualifies, or over £25,600 so it could be £50k? It’s the going rate for the job.

Fleurpepper Mon 06-Feb-23 17:37:07

It is very low for a skilled worker compared to other countries. This is even lower if you compare the exchange rate for Sterling with other currencies- considering many immigrant workers want to save and send money for their family back home, or save for when they go back after some years.

ronib Mon 06-Feb-23 17:25:55

Katie59 The minimum salary is
1. £25600 per annum
2. £10.10 per hour
3. The going rate for the job

There’s no maximum. Am bit confused by your comment. In what way is it too low?

Katie59 Mon 06-Feb-23 17:17:17

The skilled worker visa has a minimum wage level, that is probably too low to attract many into the UK, there are currently better prospects in other countries.

ronib Mon 06-Feb-23 17:12:05

The skilled workers visa is a form of freedom of movement for the people we need to have here. There is another visa too for students.

Katie59 Mon 06-Feb-23 17:07:30

Fleurpepper

Oh yes, they are. But not at any price or condition. It will probably have to include Free Movement, as for Norway and Switzerland.

Yes they would cooperate as long as we comply with their rules, it’s their club after all, why would they change the rules for us.