Gransnet forums

News & politics

Is anyone interested in the terror attack in Moscow?

(105 Posts)
maddyone Mon 25-Mar-24 13:27:51

I was shocked when I saw the horrific terrorist attack which took place in Moscow a couple of days ago. These things always shock me and fill me with horror. All these people did was go to a concert hall and 137 of them ended up dead and many others injured. Islamic State have claimed responsibility, however Putin is blaming the Ukrainians.
There has been no thread started on Gransnet about it, which I find interesting. Is it because there is less empathy for the Russian people because of their vile war in Ukraine? I think we all probably support Ukraine in the war, but have we lost our empathy for innocent people caught up in a terrible terrorist attack because they’re Russians?

maddyone Sat 30-Mar-24 01:05:27

Monica, I’m really fed up of this tit for tat that you are engaging in, and I wanted to move on, as I normally do. Least said, soonest mended, as is often said, but it appears you cannot let it go. Therefore I will say please do not misrepresent what I have said. It is verifiable on this thread that I have not said that the BBC is not to be believed because it is so biased and on someone’s side or other. I repeat, I did not say that, and so I will respectfully request that if you wish to quote me in future, please quote me correctly, and not whatever you think I’ve said.

For reference, I actually said I do not believe everything the BBC reports.

varian Fri 29-Mar-24 19:09:33

In 2024 Russia is an ultra-capitalist dictatorship.

Trump would like to emulate this model if, by some awful mischance, he should win the 2024 US election, he will quickly transform the USA into a dictatorship, following Putin's example..

varian Fri 29-Mar-24 19:02:17

C067

Yes the Communists are schizophrenic .demons. They are Psychopaths and nutcases and of course unaware of danger. I will start a Vendetta against them.

Putin is not a communist and Russia is no longer a communist state.

After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, the country was raided by Russian oligarchs , ultra-capitalists, who stole most of the assets (eg oil and gas companies, and other formerly nationalised industries) which belonged to the Russian people.

These thieves store their money in Swiss bank accounts and in properties in the west - especially in London (sometimes called Londinistan).

These thieves, and Putin is the most successful, - probably the richest man in the world -have moved about as far away from communism as you can get

Oreo Fri 29-Mar-24 18:41:01

maddyone has reminded us that what we say ‘we know’ isn’t always the case.It’s what is reported in the public realm.
Some things are more believable than others, but there are only some things we can say are absolute facts.
As to BBC Verify, they recently got into trouble for reporting as fact everything a journalist they used in Gaza, told them. Found to be deeply antiIsrael but they swallowed everything he said.

M0nica Fri 29-Mar-24 16:12:39

Varian, maddyone has already told us several times that we do not know whether the warning was given or not.

BBC Verify has fact checked it, but wa are told that that is not to be beleved because tye BBC is so biassed and on someones side or another.

C067 Fri 29-Mar-24 05:04:16

Yes the Communists are schizophrenic .demons. They are Psychopaths and nutcases and of course unaware of danger. I will start a Vendetta against them.

Labradora Thu 28-Mar-24 19:42:55

I doubt that the lack of commentary is lack of interest or lack of sympathy for those murdered simply because they are Russians .
I am simply filled with despair when I read about any terrorist attacks particularly when they happen in indoor or outdoor stadia where large numbers of people are more or less corralled and for the terrorists it is like shooting fish in a barrel , as they say.
Anders Brevik slaughtered numerous young people when he had them corralled on a small island.There was the Arianna Grande concert in Manchester and Bataclan in Paris and more recently the Hamas terrorists targeted young people at an outdoor concert I think.
Not that one type of terrorism is any less horrendous than another . Not to forget the 9/11 attacks and the 2005 murders on London Underground experienced by both myself and my husband being in London on that day although thankfully we escaped harm.
There will also be a special place in hell for whoever invented the fashion of individualist random attacks with "domestic " cars and knives on citizens because someone has persuaded the attacker that they are doing something admirable and brave rather than revolting and cowardly.
My heart goes out to the latest batch of murdered citizens and everyone who loves them.
Like everyone I imagine I foresaw Putin's pathetic if predictable attempt to blame Ukraine. Hopefully that won't get too much traction with the Russian Public as Islamic State have , I believe, formally claimed responsibility for the murders.
End of Rant.
I wouldn't normally post about this stuff because I find it so depressing and it makes me feel hopeless.
I must "press on and rise above it" as they say.

Katie59 Thu 28-Mar-24 18:54:41

Putin has proved in Ukraine that he is willing to sacrifice manpower to achieve his aims, the concert attack was likely further evidence that The Motherland is under threat. That enables him to justify increasing military expansion, think of him as Stalin with nuclear weapons.

varian Thu 28-Mar-24 18:14:22

Putin chose to ignore warnings from US intelligence that this attack was imminent. He failed to protect the Russian concert goers because it suited him better to have an atrocity to blame on Ukraine.

Twenty-five years ago a number of apartments in Moscow were bombed and this gave Putin an excuse to blame the Chechens (a predominately Muslim state of the former USSR) and then launch an attack on Chechnya. There is a great deal of evidence that Putin ordered the attacks in Moscow as an excuse for the invasion of Chechnya.

Perhaps Putin did not order the attack on the concert, but it is very likely that , having been warned by the Americans that this was being planned by ISIS, he deliberately ignored the warning, sacrificing the lives of many of his countrymen and women, in order to have a better excuse to make further attacks on Ukraine.

www.politico.eu/article/vladimir-putin-moscow-attack-use-the-crocus-massacre-to-his-advantage/

Katie59 Thu 28-Mar-24 16:33:53

Putin isnt a tinpot dictator, he’s a dangerous megalomaniac with a nuclear arsenal, we must not underestimate him.

NotSpaghetti Thu 28-Mar-24 15:48:48

maddyone

He’s been seen horse riding with a bare chest. I suppose he thinks it makes him look powerful and attractive. Personally I think he’s vile from head to foot, and I don’t normally wish people would fall off this mortal coil, but I wish that about him. Then perhaps the poor Ukrainians could have some peace.

I think that was many years ago... surely he wouldn't want to do it now!

Callistemon21 Thu 28-Mar-24 10:26:00

M0nica

Every day, in every way Putin sounds more and more like the tinpot dictator in North Korea. Are they morphing into one? Has Putin ever been seen in jeans?

On a lighter note, Alan Titchmarsh's gardening programmes have been digitally altered before being shown in North Korea.
Alan was wearing jeans and they have been blurred out because they are seen a sign of USA imperialism.
www.theguardian.com/world/2024/mar/26/alan-titchmarsh-jeans-north-korean-tv-censors

Who'd have thought Alan would be such a rebel at his age 😁

maddyone Thu 28-Mar-24 09:49:50

Dickens
Clearly we didn’t orchestrate this attack, but sadly I’m not even sure we have the capability if we had wanted to. Our poor armed forces have been so depleted recently that a top army person (sorry, forgot who) said we are no longer able to defend ourselves if we were attacked.

maddyone Thu 28-Mar-24 09:46:50

He’s been seen horse riding with a bare chest. I suppose he thinks it makes him look powerful and attractive. Personally I think he’s vile from head to foot, and I don’t normally wish people would fall off this mortal coil, but I wish that about him. Then perhaps the poor Ukrainians could have some peace.

M0nica Thu 28-Mar-24 08:56:51

Every day, in every way Putin sounds more and more like the tinpot dictator in North Korea. Are they morphing into one? Has Putin ever been seen in jeans?

Dickens Thu 28-Mar-24 08:01:19

Curtaintwitcher

It isn't that no-one is interested in these attacks and I certainly hope we are not becoming apathetic about innocent civilians being victims. You just run out of words to express the horror.
The most worrying thing about this, is that Putin is now blaming Britain.
The man isn't sane.

You just run out of words to express the horror.

... and these types of attacks are now so, well - frequent, that maybe we are becoming acclimatised to them?

For example, I remember at the beginning of the pandemic when we were locked-down, thinking - 'is this really happening?' It felt like a world event that one would read when studying history. And yet, after a few months it became a new 'normal' and I'm sure I wasn't alone in thinking and feeling like that because humans are able to 'adapt'.

So yes, I too hope we're not becoming apathetic and that it's more a matter of running out of words to express the horror because we've seen so much of it.

As for the Kremlin blaming Britain - along with the US and Ukraine - if it wasn't such a tragic event, it would be laughable. Apparently, our special services engineered this attack in order to prove our 'capabilities'!

Putin is a dictator and a tyrant and like all such must have become isolated from everything but his own egomaniacal need to reign as the supreme autocrat. He can't possible be sane in the sense that we understand the word.

undines Thu 28-Mar-24 07:26:16

Oh come on Dr Watson ‘bias’ is very very subtle
Our cultural ‘narrative’ permeates everything and is often extremely biased
I love the Archers and often smile at the underlying bias
At one point it was very pro hunting (and as such rather unrealistic as the majority of ‘country’ people do not support the hunt)
That has gone - maybe they had a few letters?
I’m just hoping one of the Grundies doesn’t decide to transition so we have that agenda coming to Ambridge
(Ooh wash my mouth out…)

undines Thu 28-Mar-24 07:17:51

Something does not smell right
Putin, like many people in power, is quite clearly capable of anything
‘Conspiracy theory?’ - that label is used to shut down speculation and discussion and make those of us who question the mainstream feel foolish
It does not work for me
Of course there are conspiracies
People who wield power often did not get there by being straight and true and often do not stay there by those means
Putin clearly cares nothing for the lives of his people
Like all of us my heart goes out to those poor souls and their families but sadly most of us are potential ‘cannon fodder ‘
If Putin did not orchestrate this, how can anyone doubt that he is capable of it?
And will it help his cause in Ukraine?
I would say definitely yes
End of

Curtaintwitcher Thu 28-Mar-24 06:35:42

It isn't that no-one is interested in these attacks and I certainly hope we are not becoming apathetic about innocent civilians being victims. You just run out of words to express the horror.
The most worrying thing about this, is that Putin is now blaming Britain.
The man isn't sane.

Galaxy Thu 28-Mar-24 06:11:52

The public bless them has a subset of nit wits who describe others as stupid when they disagree with them. They continue with this tactic despite its ongoing failure to win others round to their point of view.

DrWatson Thu 28-Mar-24 02:47:56

For Dickens, and BBC, in general, quite so. Both major parties have tried to control BBC, or threatened it.

The public sadly has a subset of frankly nitwits who claims it is "biased" -- generally because it reported something they didn't like! In any case, just HOW are shows like Gardener's World, Sky at Night, Attenborough, Mastermind, The Archers, Gardener's Question Time, Match of the Day, Strictly, Sewing Bee, Death in or Beyond Paradise, Book at Bedtime, the Shipping Forecast, etc etc, BIASED???!

News shows or discussions like Newsnight make up only a tiny fraction of BBC's output, so the whole 'biased' theme is just one-eyed twaddle.

DrWatson Thu 28-Mar-24 02:38:37

Today (Wed) I hear that the Belarus president (Putin's puppet really) stated that the terrorists tried to escape into Belarus, were turned away, then they tried to reach Ukraine.

THAT tale didn't suit Putin, so he blamed Ukraine and the West, even with ISIL taking responsibility.

A Google search showed that this is the Afghan branch of ISIL, and an article on Al Jazeera (not my usual reading material BTW!!) says >>> Why is ISIL attacking Russia?
Defence and security analysts say the group has targeted its propaganda at Russian President Vladimir Putin in recent years over the alleged oppression of Muslims by Russia.

“Russian foreign policy has been one big red flag for ISIS [ISIL],” Michael Kugelman, director of the South Asia Institute at the Washington-based Wilson Center told Al Jazeera. “The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, Russian actions in Chechnya, Moscow’s close relationships with the Syrian and Iranian governments, and especially the military campaigns that Russia has waged against ISIS fighters in Syria and — through Wagner Group mercenaries – in parts of Africa.”

All of that has meant that Moscow has become a focus of ISKP’s “extensive propaganda war,” said Amira Jadoon, assistant professor at Clemson University in South Carolina and co-author of, The Islamic State in Afghanistan and Pakistan: Strategic Alliances and Rivalries.

“Russia’s engagement in the global fight against ISIS and its affiliates, especially through its military operations in Syria and its efforts to establish connections with the Afghan Taliban – ISIS-K’s rival – marks Russia as a key adversary for ISIS".

Dickens Wed 27-Mar-24 23:09:10

M0nica

We used to sail on the Thames around Chiswick/Barnes and later had a small cruiser on the Thames. being driven into structures by wind/tide/other boats is par for the course.

DH once dealt with a case where a captain and crew swore on every religious text known that there ship had run into the Nab Tower, off Hayling Island, because it had moved and changed its position.

DH once dealt with a case where a captain and crew swore on every religious text known that there ship had run into the Nab Tower, off Hayling Island, because it had moved and changed its position.

😂😂

M0nica Wed 27-Mar-24 22:03:30

We used to sail on the Thames around Chiswick/Barnes and later had a small cruiser on the Thames. being driven into structures by wind/tide/other boats is par for the course.

DH once dealt with a case where a captain and crew swore on every religious text known that there ship had run into the Nab Tower, off Hayling Island, because it had moved and changed its position.

Dickens Wed 27-Mar-24 20:48:42

M0nica

DH is a naval architect/ marine surveyor. Damage done to every possible marine structure from bridges to light houses to dock walls and gates when ships lose propulsion, follow the wrong course, or because no one is on the bridge and the ship is on autopilot is just about the most common marine accident out.

Conspiracy theorists should concentrate on less common accidents, like knocking drinks over, or bursting balloons.

Conspiracy theorists should concentrate on less common accidents, like knocking drinks over, or bursting balloons.

grin

... but there's no drama to be had from such accidents!

My late ex was a Thames Waterman and Lighterman and, later, so was my son - he piloted one of the large pleasure cruise ships on the Thames. Hitting bridges, piers, and other craft, is indeed a common occurrence, with or without losing propulsion. Thankfully, most accidents are minor (apart from the cost). My son once hit Richmond Bridge in Surrey because of the tide and the difficulty in navigating a large craft among lots of other smaller ones bobbing about.

It happens.