Gransnet forums

News & politics

What should the Tories do now?

(227 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Sun 05-May-24 17:17:17

Braverman thinks that they should tack to the right. Leave the ECHR and cut taxes thus cutting back services.

Sunak thinks they should carry on as they are.

Andrew Street thinks that they should move to a more central inclusive conservatism. One nation.

I hope that they opt for one of the first two, because I want a Labour government, and that is one of the reasons (amongst others) that the voter is rejecting them.

If they do what Street suggests I think that many more people would be tempted to vote for the Tories, although I don’t think there is sufficient time for the Tories to show that they are indeed more inclusive and have turned away from their divisive, hardline policies.

Babamaman Mon 06-May-24 11:41:11

Totally agree with you and Labour are also deluded in thinking that they can miraculously sort everything!
We are going into dangerous times with the extreme hate in many parties!
The rich will get richer and the poor poorer! The Tories have sold this country down the pan in the name of ‘investment’

Cossy Mon 06-May-24 11:50:01

I think your comment that “Labour is deluded…” quite interesting. They are campaigning, would it be better for them to say, “vote for us, we cannot do anything if we get into power because our country is already screwed” (polite way, didn’t want a ban)

sandelf Mon 06-May-24 11:50:08

What Sunak has actually done is vaguely middle of the road. Starmer is a dishonest people user who will find himself being used in return.

Current govt needs to communicate that they are just a middle of the road, finding a practical route type of crew. And show the holes and inconsistencies of Labour's claims.

HousePlantQueen Mon 06-May-24 11:53:34

For those describing Starmer as boring or mind numbing, I would suggest that this country has had enough of 'charismatic' politicians such as Johnson. Frankly, the delay in calling a GE is going to bite Sunak; it is increasingly obvious that the only motivation is the preservation of what remains of the Conservative party, there is no consideration for the electorate or the country as a whole.

Cossy Mon 06-May-24 12:12:22

Sandelf
HPQ

Sandelf Why is Starmer a “dishonest people user” I genuinely don’t understand that remark?

HPQ

I totally agree that charisma is the last thing we need now. I do think Starmer, much in a similar way was Corbyn, is often misjudged and people who do not fully know his background label him as elitist and Tory. I prefer to think of him as a Centralist and a safe pair of hands, which, imo, is actually what both our economy and people need atm.

I’ve not seen anything in Labour’s manifesto about opening the floodgates iro of immigration nor spend, spend, spend as the right consistency accuse.

MaizieD Mon 06-May-24 12:15:49

Current govt needs to communicate that they are just a middle of the road, finding a practical route type of crew.

Well, they aren't middle of the road and cannot be because they don't have any 'middle of the roaders' in government posts. They are led by the far right wing which Sunak depends on to stay as PM.

They can do absolutely nothing about the things which really concern most of the electorate; polluted waterways, inefficient and expensive railways, shortage of police, huge delays to trials in the criminal justice system, crumbling schools and shortage of teachers and support workers, NHS on its knees and barely coping, lack of social care workers, prices still rising, high mortgage and rental rates... All the things that people really care about in their daily lives - while Sunak is pratting on about Rwanda....

Casdon Mon 06-May-24 12:36:22

sandelf

What Sunak has actually done is vaguely middle of the road. Starmer is a dishonest people user who will find himself being used in return.

Current govt needs to communicate that they are just a middle of the road, finding a practical route type of crew. And show the holes and inconsistencies of Labour's claims.

What things do you think Sunak has done that are ‘vaguely middle of the road’ sandelf?

Cossy Mon 06-May-24 12:41:10

MaizieD

^Current govt needs to communicate that they are just a middle of the road, finding a practical route type of crew.^

Well, they aren't middle of the road and cannot be because they don't have any 'middle of the roaders' in government posts. They are led by the far right wing which Sunak depends on to stay as PM.

They can do absolutely nothing about the things which really concern most of the electorate; polluted waterways, inefficient and expensive railways, shortage of police, huge delays to trials in the criminal justice system, crumbling schools and shortage of teachers and support workers, NHS on its knees and barely coping, lack of social care workers, prices still rising, high mortgage and rental rates... All the things that people really care about in their daily lives - while Sunak is pratting on about Rwanda....

👏👏👏👏

Skye17 Mon 06-May-24 12:47:24

Curtaintwitcher

I don't think calling an election now is the right thing to do. The recent elections have shown how confused people are. The turn-out was low because many Conservative voters chose not to vote.
The vast majority of people in this country are working class. This means that, in theory, our government should always be Labour. The Conservatives can only get into power if the lower classes vote for them. Johnson knew that, which is why he visited working class areas and persuaded people to vote for him.
We need a party which cares about this country and will do what is best for it. The only ones who seem to are the Reform party. Everyone else is working to a certain agenda, which is destroying Britain.
Why don't more people care about what is happening?

The vast majority of people in this country are working class. This means that, in theory, our government should always be Labour.

According to the Guardian in 2016, writing about Ipsos Mori data:

//The proportion of households working in non-manual professions (known as ABC1s) was 50.6% at the turn of the millennium. It has since increased further, reaching 54.2% last year.//

www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2016/feb/26/uk-more-middle-class-than-working-class-2000-data?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

So the working class is now a minority.

Whitewavemark2 Mon 06-May-24 12:49:58

I assume that the election will be in the autumn, as really it has got to be the latest that Sunak can call one. If he goes any later, he will competing with Christmas, NHS usual winter chaos etc, and I can’t see a single advantage to wait until then.

He could go in the summer I suppose and muck up peoples holidays, but that may have the advantage of scuppering the student vote. Desperation might prompt that.

growstuff Mon 06-May-24 12:50:05

Actually, the vast majority of people in the UK have always had to work for a living.

growstuff Mon 06-May-24 12:51:40

Whitewavemark2

I assume that the election will be in the autumn, as really it has got to be the latest that Sunak can call one. If he goes any later, he will competing with Christmas, NHS usual winter chaos etc, and I can’t see a single advantage to wait until then.

He could go in the summer I suppose and muck up peoples holidays, but that may have the advantage of scuppering the student vote. Desperation might prompt that.

There are rumours (no idea whether they're true) that it will be about the time students are going off to university and might not have thought to register in their place of study.

Siope Mon 06-May-24 13:30:01

Cynically, I think they’ll choose October because that’s when many prices will rise as a result of the new Brexit-negotiated border checks. Of course, I thought they’d choose May for the same reason, before they delayed the full implementation again, and they could do that again and cling on a bit longer.

Dickens Mon 06-May-24 13:34:30

Curtaintwitcher

I don't think calling an election now is the right thing to do. The recent elections have shown how confused people are. The turn-out was low because many Conservative voters chose not to vote.
The vast majority of people in this country are working class. This means that, in theory, our government should always be Labour. The Conservatives can only get into power if the lower classes vote for them. Johnson knew that, which is why he visited working class areas and persuaded people to vote for him.
We need a party which cares about this country and will do what is best for it. The only ones who seem to are the Reform party. Everyone else is working to a certain agenda, which is destroying Britain.
Why don't more people care about what is happening?

The recent elections have shown how confused people are

Why do you assume we are confused?

Oreo Mon 06-May-24 13:36:41

Whitewavemark2

I assume that the election will be in the autumn, as really it has got to be the latest that Sunak can call one. If he goes any later, he will competing with Christmas, NHS usual winter chaos etc, and I can’t see a single advantage to wait until then.

He could go in the summer I suppose and muck up peoples holidays, but that may have the advantage of scuppering the student vote. Desperation might prompt that.

The woman who casts the runes on tv using asparagus stalks says the GE will be in August.She also says 😲that Starmer won’t be leading Labour at that point.
😂
The asparagus has spoken🤭

Cossy Mon 06-May-24 13:39:10

I think the results of our local elections shows two things, a) apathy, the turn out is pathetic, b) people are fed up with this govt.

Neither of these things point to “confusion”

Curtaintwitcher Mon 06-May-24 13:41:06

What we really need is for Labour to get its act together, so that people really know what choice they have. At the moment, Starmer will do and say whatever it takes to get into no 10. He cannot be trusted on anything.
I and many others who didn't turn out on Thursday, would willingly vote Labour if I thought they would get this country back on its feet. Sadly, I think we would be even worse off as things stand.
One of the major problems with our current political system is that each party relies on donations. This gives donors a say in the party's policies.
The whole system really needs to be changed.

Cossy Mon 06-May-24 13:44:51

Curtaintwitcher

What we really need is for Labour to get its act together, so that people really know what choice they have. At the moment, Starmer will do and say whatever it takes to get into no 10. He cannot be trusted on anything.
I and many others who didn't turn out on Thursday, would willingly vote Labour if I thought they would get this country back on its feet. Sadly, I think we would be even worse off as things stand.
One of the major problems with our current political system is that each party relies on donations. This gives donors a say in the party's policies.
The whole system really needs to be changed.

I completely agree our entire political system and voting needs a good overhaul, including the HoL.

What exactly is it you object so vehemently to with Starmer? Compared to some we’ve had governing in the recent past, lying Johnson, deluded May and utterly inept Truss?

Oreo Mon 06-May-24 13:45:13

Nothing much will change in the short term I expect whoever gets in.
Labour would need to be sure of ten years.

vegansrock Mon 06-May-24 13:54:05

No one has said a change of government would miraculously improve everything that’s gone downhill in the last 14 years. Austerity has crippled our public services and combined with privatising as much as possible to benefit Tory donors, it will take a great deal of unpicking and rebuilding. Starmer comes across as sincere and hopefully runs a tight ship. He may be perceived as boring, but if a non boring politician is a Johnson or a Trump, then I say let’s have a bit of a boring steady hand. Yes our system needs a lot of reform, but the Tories efforts to turn back the clock have sown deep divisions rather than unity. I don’t know how anyone could want more of the same.

Cossy Mon 06-May-24 14:15:19

vegansrock

No one has said a change of government would miraculously improve everything that’s gone downhill in the last 14 years. Austerity has crippled our public services and combined with privatising as much as possible to benefit Tory donors, it will take a great deal of unpicking and rebuilding. Starmer comes across as sincere and hopefully runs a tight ship. He may be perceived as boring, but if a non boring politician is a Johnson or a Trump, then I say let’s have a bit of a boring steady hand. Yes our system needs a lot of reform, but the Tories efforts to turn back the clock have sown deep divisions rather than unity. I don’t know how anyone could want more of the same.

👏👏👏

winterwhite Mon 06-May-24 14:38:19

I’ve heard the scuppering the student vote argument, must be doing the rounds. Have also heard that he’ll call it at the Tory conf so early/mid Nov. But then July is when the electorate is most cheerful….
Whenever, what I fear about Starmer is not being boring but taking too long to start Doing something wh could endanger his second term

Dickens Mon 06-May-24 15:51:51

Oreo

Whitewavemark2

I assume that the election will be in the autumn, as really it has got to be the latest that Sunak can call one. If he goes any later, he will competing with Christmas, NHS usual winter chaos etc, and I can’t see a single advantage to wait until then.

He could go in the summer I suppose and muck up peoples holidays, but that may have the advantage of scuppering the student vote. Desperation might prompt that.

The woman who casts the runes on tv using asparagus stalks says the GE will be in August.She also says 😲that Starmer won’t be leading Labour at that point.
😂
The asparagus has spoken🤭

The asparagus has spoken

😂😂

MRGUDER Mon 06-May-24 16:04:44

If I were Sunak, I'd spend every penny in the UK coffers, get massive loans to build new hospitals, increase defence, increase social care. Train loads of people to be Doctors & Nurses.

Then leave a note on Starmer's desk to say Sorry I've spent it all. Enjoy.

MaizieD Mon 06-May-24 16:24:54

MRGUDER

If I were Sunak, I'd spend every penny in the UK coffers, get massive loans to build new hospitals, increase defence, increase social care. Train loads of people to be Doctors & Nurses.

Then leave a note on Starmer's desk to say Sorry I've spent it all. Enjoy.

But as the UK doesn't have 'coffers', but is able to issue its own money in any amount it likes, so long as there are resources available on which to spend it, that wouldn't be the killer plan you might think it is.

However, it's the last thing that the current tory government would dream of doing because they are completely against increasing state spending..