Gransnet forums

News & politics

Yvette Cooper / Migrant Watch / Stopping The Boats

(534 Posts)
Nicenanny3 Fri 12-Jul-24 08:30:16

French police stand by and watch the boats leave for Britain. Now you are in charge Yvette Cooper what's your plan after you cancelled the Rwanda deterrent?

Wyllow3 Sun 14-Jul-24 13:18:33

This was not unexpected Nicenanny3. We all knew the small boats arriving wouldn't stop. Numbers have not gone up.

Nicenanny3 Sun 14-Jul-24 13:08:26

Figures are from Government website. Perhaps instead of some posters having their heads in the sand they should take note.

Oreo Sun 14-Jul-24 13:07:54

Whitewavemark2

Nicenanny3

Another 127 arrived yesterday on 2 boats, imagine what it will be like when the weather improves. Total 717 new arrivals since 6th July.

These are useful figures (if they are correct) as they are of course a result of the previous governments failure.

Once the present governments actions begin to take effect in a few months or so, we will hopefully see a reduction in the small boats over time.

Keep up the good work!

Is your name PollyAnna by any chance?🤔

Whitewavemark2 Sun 14-Jul-24 13:02:05

maddyone

The figures are regularly reported Whitewave and not a secret. I don’t remember them though, or note them down. I see them reported on the Southern news reports, maybe you don’t watch those reports.

No it isn’t something I regularly take note of.

Migration is a human condition, and has been in existence for as long as humans have been on this earth.

It will almost certainly increase in future years because of such push factors as climate, war, starvation etc

The only way that it can be dealt with is by cooperation with our neighbours.

Whitewavemark2 Sun 14-Jul-24 12:57:44

maddyone

Incidentally I have little confidence that the numbers will reduce any time soon.

I agree, because until the government is able to put everything in place, we are still operating on the previous governments regime.

maddyone Sun 14-Jul-24 12:50:15

Incidentally I have little confidence that the numbers will reduce any time soon.

maddyone Sun 14-Jul-24 12:49:28

The figures are regularly reported Whitewave and not a secret. I don’t remember them though, or note them down. I see them reported on the Southern news reports, maybe you don’t watch those reports.

Whitewavemark2 Sun 14-Jul-24 12:37:30

Nicenanny3

Another 127 arrived yesterday on 2 boats, imagine what it will be like when the weather improves. Total 717 new arrivals since 6th July.

These are useful figures (if they are correct) as they are of course a result of the previous governments failure.

Once the present governments actions begin to take effect in a few months or so, we will hopefully see a reduction in the small boats over time.

Keep up the good work!

Whitewavemark2 Sun 14-Jul-24 12:34:19

Blenheim Palace

Talks begin on Thursday that will see the start of greater cooperation in. Europe over the migration issue.

All migration in Europe is of course linked and the UKs involvement is welcomed according to European leaders.

Nicenanny3 Sun 14-Jul-24 12:13:20

Another 127 arrived yesterday on 2 boats, imagine what it will be like when the weather improves. Total 717 new arrivals since 6th July.

Iam64 Sun 14-Jul-24 12:03:42

The man who runs our local refugee support group arrived from a war torn African country. It took four years for him to have his application processed. The group are supporting some people who have waited 6 years.

The Rwanda plan was illegal and costing mind boggling amounts. Thankfully we had ‘faceless EU human rights judges’. Even more fortunately, our own independent high court judges also concluded it was illegal.

Germanshepherdsmum Sun 14-Jul-24 12:01:55

And still Yvette Cooper refuses to countenance digital ID.

maddyone Sun 14-Jul-24 11:48:14

People have overstayed their visas long before the last fourteen years foxie. We are having people coming to light who have overstayed their visas from the seventies. There was a feature on BBC news recently regarding one person who came here in the 1970s and simply never went home. Suddenly the authorities caught up with them and so they complained to the news and had their case featured. I assume they were hoping that would result in them being allowed to stay.

foxie48 Sun 14-Jul-24 11:44:01

The legislation kept failing because it was illegal, the Conservatives had a big majority in the Commons, in the Lords the Conservatives had 270 and Labour 175, so a majority of 95. Where do you get your £8million a day from?

Nicenanny3 Sun 14-Jul-24 10:35:15

The Rwanda plan was a Deterrent and if the first plane had been allowed to take off 2/3 years ago instead of being stopped by some faceless EU human rights judge and the government had shown some balls and ignored them things might have been different now and we wouldn't be facing thousands coming over on the boats costing 8 million pounds plus a day. Labour continually tried every trick to stop any legislation going through to stop the boats so now we are paying the price and it was having an effect you only have to look at Ireland where failed UK asylum seekers who were earmarked for Rwanda went to (Youtube). The fact that over in Calais the Syrian gangs are calling Keir Starmer 'the friendly one' I rest my case.

keepingquiet Sun 14-Jul-24 10:16:09

Well said Foxie! Most of this is just media wind-up. Do people think that if Sunak was still PM plane loads of people would be being flown to Rwanda?

It was only ever a massively expensive publicity stunt and people fell for it. It was never going to solve the issue.

foxie48 Sun 14-Jul-24 10:07:22

Seems people have forgotten that the reason that the Rwanda plan failed repeatedly was because it was illegal. There were Tory MPs who voted against it for that reason. There are lots of ways we could deter asylum seekers landing in small boats, we could say we'll shoot them but that would be illegal, we could say we'll deport them to Syria by dropping them out of planes, but that would be illegal. The reason the UK spent millions of pounds and didn't manage to get one unwilling asylum seeker to Rwanda was because they would have been acting illegally. So why don't we just focus on having an effective immigration service (which the Tories didn't have), process people efficiently so those who have a right to asylum can work and start making a contribution to the UK and deport those who don't. By all means tighten up any loopholes, work closely with our European partners who take many more refugees than we do and be "grown up" about our responsibilities. BTW we have absolutely hopeless systems in place to check who is in this country legally and who has overstayed their visa, that's the result of 14 years of Conservative government!

Freya5 Sun 14-Jul-24 09:45:15

Mollygo

Reading some of the points made further up reminded me of the points system we faced when we were considering emigration.
Positive qualifications -skills, particularly those to fill shortages, health, age etc. Then negative points, lack of skills needed by the country in question and ill-health including problems children had which would cost the country money.
Do we have a points system like that?

Boris Johnson 2019, was determined to push on with an immigration system similar to Australia, and it commenced in 2022 ; House of Commons Library.

Freya5 Sun 14-Jul-24 09:39:15

Joseann

As I hear it, the French are making the most of playing piggy in the middle. They want Britain to be more co-operative over this issue, but they also want Italy to stop migrants crossing over their border. Basically, they don't want to be inundated, like no one else does.

Schengan is the problem, surely. Free movement should be for citizens , passport holder only. Not just anyone who lands on their shores. Hasn't Meloni spoken about closing their border. Has worked with Hungary.

Wyllow3 Sat 13-Jul-24 23:14:52

Primrose53

x.com/GBNEWS/status/1811473691210883108

Kevin Saunders former Chief Immigration Officer on what Labour will do.

when you actually watch the video - all Kevin Saunders says on the GB X video is how dangerous it is and how ruthless the boat smugglers are, pictures to go with.

He doesn't mention any plans at all from any party/comment in anyway what might work or not

Primrose53 Sat 13-Jul-24 22:31:47

Iam64

I’d prefer to hear from Labour than some right wing commentator on X or GBnews.

The majority of asylum seekers have their applications met. Therefore genuine

Of course you would!! However the former Chief Immigration Officer with decades of experience is a reliable source.😉

Iam64 Sat 13-Jul-24 21:08:20

I’d prefer to hear from Labour than some right wing commentator on X or GBnews.

The majority of asylum seekers have their applications met. Therefore genuine

Germanshepherdsmum Sat 13-Jul-24 20:58:34

👏👏👏

Skydancer Sat 13-Jul-24 20:52:36

The Rwanda plan was better than nothing - which is what we now have. Knowing that immigration was so important to voters, why hasn't Labour come in all guns blazing with an amazing plan. They had long enough to formulate one.

Wyllow3 Sat 13-Jul-24 18:58:21

Telegraph is turning into a Red-Top.