Gransnet forums

News & politics

Performance politics but empty words

(204 Posts)
PoliticsNerd Tue 21-Jan-25 07:41:12

Much of today's display of 'performance politics' may appear to yield results, but ultimately, it's unlikely that these promises will come to fruition. Signing public documents or holding photo opportunities in no way guarantees the passage of these bills and policies. However, this facade is what Trump supporters will initially remember. Like many Brexit supporters who have come to realise that getting what they wanted has not improved their lives or, in fact, led to nothing being done, some may eventually move towards authoritarianism.

Winston Churchill famously said that a democracy requires an informed voter. Unfortunately, too many people are either misinformed or uninformed. Those who are uninformed are, by default, the most susceptible to manipulation. My initial optimism about the potential of Citizens' Juries to empower citizens and foster informed debate now seems misplaced, as they have become mired in the complexities of government.

So, how can we, as individuals and as a society, work towards becoming better informed?

LizzieDrip Sat 25-Jan-25 12:10:02

There is a Yorkshire Party who want independence … so watch out🤣🤣🤣

maddyone Sat 25-Jan-25 12:06:47

Why does Trump get brought into every thread?

Whitewavemark2 Sat 25-Jan-25 12:04:29

😄😄😄

LizzieDrip Sat 25-Jan-25 12:03:08

We’re proud immigrants WW💪🏻grin

Mamie Sat 25-Jan-25 11:58:03

MaizieD

I had thought of them grin

And remembered that at one time I lived in the Socialist Republic of South Yorkshire...

I lived there too MaizieD. 😂 Then we moved south in the spring of 1979 and the trees were all blue with election posters. 😮

Whitewavemark2 Sat 25-Jan-25 11:56:16

No you northerners are immigrants. We claim original settlers.

MaizieD Sat 25-Jan-25 11:46:16

I had thought of them grin

And remembered that at one time I lived in the Socialist Republic of South Yorkshire...

LizzieDrip Sat 25-Jan-25 11:43:50

Yorkshire - God’s Own Countrygrin

Whitewavemark2 Sat 25-Jan-25 11:39:29

Cornwall

MaizieD Sat 25-Jan-25 11:36:49

Three countries out of five voted to remain in the EU…

I'm struggling to find the fifth country in the British Isles. grin

MaizieD Sat 25-Jan-25 11:34:43

The argument is about should we have an open border policy where anyone can come to the UK.

Not it isn't, David.

Nobody on this thread is advocating an 'open border' policy.

MayBee70 Sat 25-Jan-25 11:25:07

Mollygo

Maybee70
Three countries out of five voted to remain in the EU…
But not enough of them voted to support those in the 4th country who voted remain😥😥 and one of those countries had no more success with their own referendum that GB had.

And we said at the time that Ireland would be a major problem if we left the EU but our words of warning were ignored even though they proved to be correct.

David49 Fri 24-Jan-25 13:16:32

Syracute

David49

I think it’s time this thread ended because we have 2 sides that are not going to reconcile and it’s getting too combative.

So you are now trying to censor free thought David ? That’s a fair good beginning to fascism .

The argument is about should we have an open border policy where anyone can come to the UK.

I believe we should have a control system that gives migrants permission to enter the UK, AND it should be enforced.
I dont think that is an unreasonable aim, whatever anyone else’s opinion I’m not going to change, so there is no point arguing.

I’ve travelled in quite a few third world country and most of the population would travel to UK if they could and Ive been chatted up several times. One was a young waiter at a hotel in the capital city. “ Mr David I come to the UK and be your house boy”, houseboy is common there, along with a maid and a guard too. He probably didn’t get paid but had got food and a decent place to sleep, I spent 15mins explaining that nobody has a houseboy in the UK, there is no chance of getting a work visa and life is incredibly hard for migrants, he is likely to be much worse off.

So no I do not want an open border policy, migrants are essential for the UK, they should obey the laws.

Mollygo Fri 24-Jan-25 10:20:08

Maybee70
Three countries out of five voted to remain in the EU…
But not enough of them voted to support those in the 4th country who voted remain😥😥 and one of those countries had no more success with their own referendum that GB had.

Syracute Fri 24-Jan-25 10:01:08

David49

I think it’s time this thread ended because we have 2 sides that are not going to reconcile and it’s getting too combative.

So you are now trying to censor free thought David ? That’s a fair good beginning to fascism .

Syracute Fri 24-Jan-25 09:58:11

Whitewavemark2

Trump has just pardoned this scum and he’s been released from prison.

Note the message on the sweatshirt.

Now tell me that he isn’t a Nazi!

I am not sure how many people are aware of how many neo nazis were a part of the Jan 6 insurrection . Just so disgusting that Trump released them ( one is already back in jail) and another told a British newscaster he is loading up on guns .

Syracute Fri 24-Jan-25 09:54:06

It most certainly does as he literally supports and talks to Nazi sympathetic groups like the AFD . He is trying to pull a fast one by saying it want a Nazi salute but he had just had discussions with the AFD . You simply can’t ignore these facts !

PoliticsNerd Fri 24-Jan-25 09:16:33

JudyBloom

Just to point out that Brexit was never fully implemented and if it had have been this country wouldn't be in the decline that it is in now! The elected governments were too busy listening to the Quangos and unelected bodies instead of implementing what they were voted in for - this has to stop. We have been well and truly betrayed.

It's not a question of 'unelected bodies' or 'Quangos' blocking the implementation of Brexit. What is true is that the UK's elected government and parliament have made compromises and trade-offs to try and achieve a Brexit that works for the country, rather than simply reverting to a pre-Brexit status quo.

The idea that a 'fully implemented' Brexit would have solved the country's economic woes is overly simplistic. Brexit was always a complex issue, and its effects are still being felt. It's possible that a more gradual or managed transition to a post-Brexit world might have been less disruptive.

As for betrayal, Brexit was a decision taken by the UK government and parliament after a national referendum. While not everyone supported the decision, it was a democratic outcome that was respected and implemented by the UK government. While it's understandable to feel frustrated or disillusioned with the process, implying that the decision was 'betrayed' by unelected bodies or politicians is unfair, unhelpful and untrue.

Kandinsky Thu 23-Jan-25 16:25:01

Brexit was voted throughwith a wafer thin majority. if the poll had been held on another day, in either direction it might have gone another way

Yep. and If I’d been born with balls and in the 16th century I could have been Henry VIII.

MayBee70 Thu 23-Jan-25 16:17:16

Mollygo

^Brexit was voted through with a wafer thin majority. if the poll had been held on another day, in either direction it might have gone another way.^

It might indeed, but only, I suspect, if the CBBs had changed their attitude or if the results of the original referendum had been leaked to act as a spur.

Over a million more people voted leave, than voted remain.
In percentages, that’s wafer thin. In actual figures, that’s an awful lot more people who voted than people who didn’t bother to vote which is why we are no longer in the EU.

Three countries out of five voted to remain in the EU…

Mollygo Thu 23-Jan-25 16:05:00

Brexit was voted through with a wafer thin majority. if the poll had been held on another day, in either direction it might have gone another way.

It might indeed, but only, I suspect, if the CBBs had changed their attitude or if the results of the original referendum had been leaked to act as a spur.

Over a million more people voted leave, than voted remain.
In percentages, that’s wafer thin. In actual figures, that’s an awful lot more people who voted than people who didn’t bother to vote which is why we are no longer in the EU.

M0nica Thu 23-Jan-25 15:10:30

Brexit was voted throughwith a wafer thin majority. if the poll had been held on another day, in either direction it might have gone another way.

Because of the problems wafer thin majorities cause, it is usual to require 60% approval for constitutional change.

Yes, the Leavers won, but talk about the people of Britain voting to leave is palpably not true, as those voting to stay and those who did not care either way, well outnumbered the leavers.

On those rare occasions when you get votes like this it is usual for a solution to be negotiated that takes account of the views of both sides.

You may feel betrayed Judy, but the majority of the population, those who voted remain, or did not vote at all, just feel dissatisfied that several British governments have made so little effort to reconcile the two sides in this argument andfind a solution that is good for all.

David49 Wed 22-Jan-25 19:39:07

JudyBloom

Just to point out that Brexit was never fully implemented and if it had have been this country wouldn't be in the decline that it is in now! The elected governments were too busy listening to the Quangos and unelected bodies instead of implementing what they were voted in for - this has to stop. We have been well and truly betrayed.

The selling points of Brexit were controlling migration, getting a “special deal”(cherry picking ) and better deals with the US and others, not realistic aims, none have been achieved.

Allira Wed 22-Jan-25 19:35:58

JudyBloom

Trump can only be a good thing for the world, certain media want you to believe he is far right. This is not true. Someone finally squashing the poisonous woke agenda and bringing back common sense and working for the majority.

Of course you are entitled to your opinion, JudyBloom

However, what do you think of the picture Whitewavemark2 has just posted and the slogan on this ex-prisoner's sweatshirt?

Whitewavemark2 Wed 22-Jan-25 19:32:16

Trump has just pardoned this scum and he’s been released from prison.

Note the message on the sweatshirt.

Now tell me that he isn’t a Nazi!