Gransnet forums

News & politics

BBC calling President Zelensky *Mr*Zelensky

(92 Posts)
Wyllow3 Sat 15-Mar-25 12:03:45

The complaints about not using "president" are quite justifed when they occur

- but I've just been doing a walkabout round the BBC and CNN using "president" Zelensky and the tendency is to initially use "president" for them both then just the surnames. However googling "Mr Zelensky" alongside "Mr Trump" is also used in a number of newspapers so it's hard to tell.

Galaxy Sat 15-Mar-25 11:53:18

The BBC are hilarious. It's not a storm in a teacup. If you lie about that you will lie about anything.

Sallyforth Sat 15-Mar-25 11:46:41

Going into any negotiations you go in on equal terms, and that terminology makes President Zelenskyy appear less significant than the other two.

I thought it was a huge mistake that President Zelenskyy went into the White House meeting alone. Trump had his side kick there and Zelenskyy should have had a deputy or an aide beside him. The savage treatment might not have been so devastating had another key person representing the Ukraine been present.

Always equal numbers, and equal in seniority.

Silverbrooks Sat 15-Mar-25 11:45:04

Zelenskyy’s term as president would have expired in April 2024 but Ukraine has been under martial law since 24 February 2022 in response to the Russian invasion. Ukrainian law does not allow presidential elections to be held when martial law is in effect.

Article 19 of Ukraine's "On the Legal Regime of Martial Law" bans presidential, parliamentary, and local elections under martial law while Article 10 states that the powers of the President, Parliament, and Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine cannot be terminated under martial law.

Article 108 of the Constitution of Ukraine stipulates that "The President of Ukraine exercises his or her powers until the assumption of office by the newly-elected President of Ukraine" allowing incumbent President Volodymyr Zelenskyy to legitimately remain president until the next president is sworn in, even after the expiration of the five-year term to which he was elected in 2019. (Wiki)

Trump has said that Ukraine should hold elections to potentially replace Zelenskyy.

Quite how a country at war stages an election is hard to say. 14 million Ukrainians have either fled abroad or been displaced internally. Polls have shown that 81% of Ukrainians did not want elections until the war was over and more than 200 civil society institutions, NGOs, and human rights groups have formally opposed wartime elections.

He is entitled to be called President Zelenskyy until this war is over.

AGAA4 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:40:13

The BBC does make mistakes as in Eddie Izzard being referred to as a man but the missing out of Zelensky's title was deliberate as two different reporters failed to call him President while giving Trump his title.
I know who deserves the title of President more and it isn't Trump.

Wyllow3 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:29:57

Iam64

Yes it is a highly charged area but ……

its a storm in a teacup!

Wyllow3 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:29:33

Whitewavemark2

AGAA4

I just felt there was a bias there for President Trump against 'Mr' Zelensky. He should be given his proper title as President of Ukraine.
Of course Putin prefers him to be called just Mr as he doesn't recognise Ukraine as a separate country.

Language does matter.

It does, I player got it right so I hope that it will be lesson learnt, as AGAA4 says there is pressure I think from both US and Putin to miss out the "President".

Iam64 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:25:24

Yes it is a highly charged area but ……

Wyllow3 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:23:58

eazybee

Yes, i agree.
BBC has apologised for a Today presenter referring to Eddie Izzard as a man, which he is, because apparently it is 'a highly controversial area'.

But it is a highly charged area. the Telegraph is enjoying making much of it, of course. the irony is that as the DT said itself,
"despite the comedian not caring about pronouns and gender labels"

Iam64 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:23:56

eazybee

Yes, i agree.
BBC has apologised for a Today presenter referring to Eddie Izzard as a man, which he is, because apparently it is 'a highly controversial area'.

It was the excellent Anita Anand on the radio 4 PM programme on Friday. I missed her calling him (!) a man but heard her apology. My initial thought was was the last I heard of Eddie Izzard was that he had ‘girly days’ when he wore pink.

Honestly 🙈

Whitewavemark2 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:22:12

AGAA4

I just felt there was a bias there for President Trump against 'Mr' Zelensky. He should be given his proper title as President of Ukraine.
Of course Putin prefers him to be called just Mr as he doesn't recognise Ukraine as a separate country.

Language does matter.

Baggs Sat 15-Mar-25 11:19:30

How childish.

AGAA4 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:19:14

I just felt there was a bias there for President Trump against 'Mr' Zelensky. He should be given his proper title as President of Ukraine.
Of course Putin prefers him to be called just Mr as he doesn't recognise Ukraine as a separate country.

Wyllow3 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:15:26

I'm generally very happy with the I player news, the live news feed is detailed and informative:
I don't watch a lot, but totally agree that if the conversation involves President Trump then it should be President Zelensky.

and it is this morning on the I player feed

as in

A virtual summit on the war in Ukraine is under way as UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer says Putin will have to come to the table '"sooner or later"

Around 25 leaders, including European partners, the EU commission, Nato, Ukraine and Canada, are expected to be in attendance at the 'coalition of the willing' meeting

Earlier, Starmer said Russian President Vladimir Putin "cannot be allowed to play games" with the US-proposed ceasefire deal, and accused the Russian leader of "trying to delay" an agreement
The aim of the summit is for Europe to persuade the US to "guarantee Ukraine's security in the future", write's the BBC's diplomatic correspondent

Earlier this week, Putin set out conditions for a ceasefire in Ukraine, but *Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky called his response "manipulative

Also this week, US President Donald Trump said he held "good and productive" discussions with Putin during talks in Moscow

eazybee Sat 15-Mar-25 11:13:10

Yes, i agree.
BBC has apologised for a Today presenter referring to Eddie Izzard as a man, which he is, because apparently it is 'a highly controversial area'.

Whitewavemark2 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:09:39

A lot of people do

AGAA4 Sat 15-Mar-25 11:04:26

I watched BBC Points of View this morning and people had complained about reporters saying President Trump and Mr Zelensky.
They were demeaning Zelensky by not giving him his title of President.
I do get irritated by the BBC quite a lot lately.