Gransnet forums

News & politics

ā€œStarmer to rent homes for migrants." No, no. The taxpayer is renting them!

(109 Posts)
FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sat 26-Apr-25 09:26:07

He’s asking landlords to house migrants and giving them a 5 year guarantee of income. So, putting them (in the north probably as we’re a bit cheaper up here) in the middle of communities. Lads we know nothing about. What could possibly go wrong? šŸ¤·ā€ā™€ļø

I’m not sure this is the answer to the migration problem we have. What do you think?

MaizieD Sat 26-Apr-25 11:16:38

The 'taxpayer' isn't funding this, the State is.

It is only 'our' money in the sense that the money the state creates can be regarded as a public good, even though it is one that we have elected a government to spend and administer on our behalf.

I'll point out, once again, that no-one (apart from the mega rich who have huge reserves of it) would have any money if the state didn't continually create it.

Bu, then, hanging on to the 'taxpayers' money' myth is a great excuse for venting bile on any government action that one disapproves of..

Wyllow3 Sat 26-Apr-25 11:12:30

You have a point there.

LizzieDrip Sat 26-Apr-25 11:06:39

Oh the irony of this OP starting, yet another, ā€˜let’s hate asylum seekers’ post at the very same time as the funeral of Pope Francis.

May the peace of human kindness be in your heart OP.

Iam64 Sat 26-Apr-25 10:52:17

Thanks Wyllow for putting it right. The majority of asylum seekers are granted right to stay. Landlords know how easy it is to buy cheap terraced housing in deprived areas. They rent through Serco and others, to asylum seekers. The dispersal scheme leads to some families being isolated from community supports. Eg African Angolan moved from the Liverpool area with a community with similar faith/experience into areas with few/no people ā€˜like them’

We need to rapidly move to allowing asylum seekers to work. No one can manage on the money they get. Many have good skills to contribute. A friend who had two carers, 4 times a day was so well cared for by women who’d been given settled status. He learned about the perils they faced in their part of Africa, and on their journey here. 4 came to his funeral

Anniebach Sat 26-Apr-25 10:49:00

My daughter was asked last year if she would rent a barn she
had converted into a bungalow

Wyllow3 Sat 26-Apr-25 10:46:02

This is what SERCO says it does
www.serco.com/uk/sector-expertise/immigration/asylum-accommodation-support-services

Wyllow3 Sat 26-Apr-25 10:41:17

It's actually been happening already. Not new

From the O/P

"Serco, one of three private contractors working for the Home Office, is offering landlords five-year guaranteed full rent deals to house asylum seekers at the taxpayer’s expense.

In promotional literature, the firm boasts that it is already responsible for more than 30,000 asylum seekers in an ā€œever growingā€ portfolio of more than 7,000 properties

These big firms like SERCO are making a huge profit and controversy around using them versus funding local authorities.

rosie1959 Sat 26-Apr-25 10:36:27

I fail to understand where all these homes are going to come from as we already have problems finding accommodation for those that live in the UK.
They certainly should not be free, once the person has been cleared to stay in the UK and has found employment they should repay the cost of the accommodation.

woodenspoon Sat 26-Apr-25 10:34:13

I expect the rental income will be more favourable than the normal market rent to induce landlords to sign up. Others will see it as a business opportunity and buy up properties in poorer areas to rent out.
No help for British people though. Two tier Keir.

RosieandherMaw Sat 26-Apr-25 10:29:20

Generous of him !

Wyllow3 Sat 26-Apr-25 10:27:11

karmalady

escaped

Is that 5 years with the same tenant? 😲
He can't have much faith in his "processing" system then.

multiple occupants I should think

No, its a 5 years deal for the landlord not occupants.

Mollygo Sat 26-Apr-25 10:16:04

Jaberwok

Oh FGS, It has nothing to do with hatred for migrants, but everything to do with the acute lack of accommodation for people who live in this country, have been searching, and/or on waiting lists for months/years, and are actually homeless, ie living on the streets. Perhaps those advocating this latest government solution has a spare room to offer for a homeless person in these times of crisis? Ummmm!!

It’s difficult if you’re in the suffering from the acute lack of accommodation group.

Are we saying only those (I’m not including myself, but can currently include my DGC)
who are in that group should be allowed to comment without being accused of hate?

merlotgran Sat 26-Apr-25 10:15:05

I am fed up with people talking rubbish and giving the wrong impression due to their own agenda and racist views.

Surely it’s not talking rubbish or racist to express concern over taxpayer funded rentals for migrants when so many people cannot afford a home of their own. There is no five year guarantee for them and many live with the fear of being made homeless should they struggle with sky high rents.

Concern is not hatred.

lafergar Sat 26-Apr-25 10:10:53

Oh dear, are we very bored today then?

Anniebach Sat 26-Apr-25 10:10:25

How to stop the boats , blow them up ?

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sat 26-Apr-25 10:09:01

I didn’t type the word ā€˜softhearted*! Goodness knows where that word popped up from! I only said ā€˜by’. šŸ¤·ā€ā™€ļø strange….

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sat 26-Apr-25 10:06:43

^ He was a migrant with all the correct paperwork^

Different story altogether then rafichagran! He’d be very welcome today in my book. We’d know who he was a whence he came from his correct paperwork! I’d have no issue with legal migration. Individuals can be traced. Very sensible.

But ā€˜irregular migration’ via rubber boats carrying in so many men to our shores? I’ve had enough of this. it could be a family, single women ect.. It could be - but mostly it just isn’t! Have you watched the docking softhearted Border Force boats??

rafichagran Sat 26-Apr-25 09:59:06

Whitewavemark2

Here comes the we hate migrants thread again. Hasn’t been talked/hated about for at least 10secs.

Yes, this, by the same poster quoting from the press. The title in the OP said migrants, not illegal migrants and why are we talking about lads it could be a family, single women ect.
My partner came over here in the 70's, always worked, paid taxes, and done a job in the end where he managed a team doing a job that benefitted people who needed alot of help. He was a migrant with all the correct paperwork, paid alot of tax and NI.
I am fed up with people talking rubbish and giving the wrong impression due to their own agenda and racist views.

Churchview Sat 26-Apr-25 09:53:44

Freudian slip Jackob?

Jaberwok Sat 26-Apr-25 09:48:06

Oh FGS, It has nothing to do with hatred for migrants, but everything to do with the acute lack of accommodation for people who live in this country, have been searching, and/or on waiting lists for months/years, and are actually homeless, ie living on the streets. Perhaps those advocating this latest government solution has a spare room to offer for a homeless person in these times of crisis? Ummmm!!

Jackob Sat 26-Apr-25 09:45:40

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Churchview Sat 26-Apr-25 09:41:53

Meanwhile -
www.ft.com/content/b133a72a-902a-40fc-aa53-76a7c2833cc3

escaped Sat 26-Apr-25 09:40:53

Whitewavemark2

Oh ā€œup to date descriptionā€. That’s a new one😔

Well some readers are interested. You don't have to read. The word was "observation"! Through my own eyes!

Churchview Sat 26-Apr-25 09:40:15

The only reports of this I can find are in the Telegraph, Daily Mail and GB News hmm

Whitewavemark2 Sat 26-Apr-25 09:36:55

Oh ā€œup to date descriptionā€. That’s a new one😔