Solid Trump rejection. So what happened in the U.K.?

Freya, you would trust Farage over Starmer? Why?

A responsible paper would have given the actual figures we'll gain in the trade deal, and allude to the reciprocal arrangements as regards NI/health care that apply in these situations.

But no - across the board red top style shock horror.

BTW, the EU is also working on the same Trade deal with India"
Both India and the EU have said they aim to finalise this by the end of 2025" Beneficial to us as tariff blocks lessen cross borders.

Hear, hear Wyllow 👏👏👏

J52

Freya5

Well many of you trusted Starmer, look what he's doing to the country. Always putting other countries re money at top of the list, now he's handed a free pass to Indians to come and work here without having to pay NI, to support the NHS, which they will use, whilst increaing what our employers pay. How is that putting a Britain first. Do you wonder why people are sick and tired of them.

I think you’ll find it applies to Indians who are only on secondment from Indian companies to Britain and only applies for 3 years. It does not apply to Indians just apply for jobs in Britain. They will not be able to get benefits. We already have these arrangements in place with other countries. British people working abroad for British companies have reciprocal arrangements.

“Migrants who are posted to the UK from a country outside of the EEA and Switzerland and with which the UK does not have a social security agreement, may not have to pay UK NIC for up to 52 weeks, provided they meet certain conditions. From 1 January 2021, these rules also apply to Liechtenstein. Broadly speaking you need to be employed overseas and then, as part of that overseas employment, you are seconded by your employer to work in the UK.
“Migrants who do not meet the conditions will pay UK NIC from the start of their employment in the UK. This will include those who are locally employed in the UK.
For more information, go to HM Revenue & Customs’ (HMRC) guidance, RDR1, paragraphs 11.21 onwards. You can find this on GOV.UK.”

Another big thank you for the facts, J52

I know this would come up Freya looking at headlines from what the papers said as they are available on I player the night before.

They utterly ignored the benefits of the trade deal - its massive for our country

They made it sound like every Indian would suddenly not have to pay NI, not the extremely limited number for a very limited period of time. And *British people working abroad for British companies have reciprocal arrangements

I am disgusted and sick with those right wing press headlines that ignored the benefits and handed out lies to readership then get parroted on social media

No wonder anything good Starmer does is minimised = people are subject to propaganda like this morning.

Most people who say they deserve to be here are hypocrits as they don't want them in their own spare room, street or town

Sazz1 you must have incredible access to the views of most people who support asylum seekers & immigrants, in order to make this claim and accuse us of hypocrisy.

I wonder how you know this?

Speaking for myself (which is all any of us can really do) I live in a town alongside many immigrants. They are welcomed in my street and my town. Indeed, their culture is celebrated and we now have two new Asian / Caribbean supermarkets. Brilliant! No hypocrisy here

sazz1

I don't trust Starmer and I'm right not to trust him. He's done nothing about the illegal immigrants, and broken every promise in his manifesto.
It's time to change from the 2 main parties and if that's Reform so be it.
The illegal immigrants are draining our economy, and some are criminals running from their own country's justice system. Most people who say they deserve to be here are hypocrits as they don't want them in their own spare room, street or town. But will stand in protests favouring them not being deported. And won't like paying extra income tax to keep them housed in hotels which is bound to happen soon. They also have priority hospital, doctor and dental treatment infront of UK citizens as they are classed as vulnerable.

According to Statista the projected UK budget for 2025/26 is £1,335 billion.

The figure for the maintenance of irregular migrants is hard to find but if it is in the region of £5billion pa and the money spent all enters the UK economy how do you work out that this relatively small sum is 'draining the economy'?

I don't trust Starmer and I'm right not to trust him. He's done nothing about the illegal immigrants, and broken every promise in his manifesto.
It's time to change from the 2 main parties and if that's Reform so be it.
The illegal immigrants are draining our economy, and some are criminals running from their own country's justice system. Most people who say they deserve to be here are hypocrits as they don't want them in their own spare room, street or town. But will stand in protests favouring them not being deported. And won't like paying extra income tax to keep them housed in hotels which is bound to happen soon. They also have priority hospital, doctor and dental treatment infront of UK citizens as they are classed as vulnerable.

Thank you for the facts J52

”Jonathan Reynolds said the exemption, called a double contributions convention, is something the UK already has with plenty of other countries and blocs - including the EU” (Sky News online)

Of course, some folk will never allow facts to get in the way of their outrage!

Freya5

Well many of you trusted Starmer, look what he's doing to the country. Always putting other countries re money at top of the list, now he's handed a free pass to Indians to come and work here without having to pay NI, to support the NHS, which they will use, whilst increaing what our employers pay. How is that putting a Britain first. Do you wonder why people are sick and tired of them.

I think you’ll find it applies to Indians who are only on secondment from Indian companies to Britain and only applies for 3 years. It does not apply to Indians just apply for jobs in Britain. They will not be able to get benefits. We already have these arrangements in place with other countries. British people working abroad for British companies have reciprocal arrangements.

“Migrants who are posted to the UK from a country outside of the EEA and Switzerland and with which the UK does not have a social security agreement, may not have to pay UK NIC for up to 52 weeks, provided they meet certain conditions. From 1 January 2021, these rules also apply to Liechtenstein. Broadly speaking you need to be employed overseas and then, as part of that overseas employment, you are seconded by your employer to work in the UK.
“Migrants who do not meet the conditions will pay UK NIC from the start of their employment in the UK. This will include those who are locally employed in the UK.
For more information, go to HM Revenue & Customs’ (HMRC) guidance, RDR1, paragraphs 11.21 onwards. You can find this on GOV.UK.”

Whitewavemark2

Good grief it is like Chinese whispers on this thread.

So my daft comment (a mild criticism). Has gone from daft to stupid to idiots.

But how would anyone explain why people are willing to vote for a Trump supporting political party, rather than an alternative, like the greens, Liberals etc.

What is Farage offering that you are so sure will benefit you?

Voters in other countries are clear about what a trump supporting political party will offer and soundly rejected it, even though they looked as if they would be a shoe-in at one time, but they had the intelligence to swiftly reject this future and returned to vote for a liberal democratic political party.

So protest vote all you need - but please don’t vote for a xenophobic racist political party whose leader admires Trump and Putin, and who led the country down the dead end of Brexit.

How can you trust his judgement?

Well said. That's my feelings too. Reform tells you what you want to hear but can they deliver? I think not. How is Brexit working out? My term for Farage "a snake oil salesman" says it all.

Freya5

Well many of you trusted Starmer, look what he's doing to the country. Always putting other countries re money at top of the list, now he's handed a free pass to Indians to come and work here without having to pay NI, to support the NHS, which they will use, whilst increaing what our employers pay. How is that putting a Britain first. Do you wonder why people are sick and tired of them.

Well the India deal was necessary because Brexit meant that we were losing our biggest and closest trading partners. So what are we supposed to do? We have to trade with someone. Trade with the EU and the government are accused of ignoring the referendum. If you agree with Brexit you have to agree with the trade deals that we were told Brexit would enable us to do. No deal is going to come without clauses. And it’s only the end result of a trade deal that was initiated by the Conservatives. So who do you think we should be trading with? Obama told us that a trade deal with America wasn’t a given, and it certainly isn’t now that Trump is back in power.

Freya5

Well many of you trusted Starmer, look what he's doing to the country. Always putting other countries re money at top of the list, now he's handed a free pass to Indians to come and work here without having to pay NI, to support the NHS, which they will use, whilst increaing what our employers pay. How is that putting a Britain first. Do you wonder why people are sick and tired of them.

Ah well, at least you are consistent Freya.

Put Britain First....I couldn't care less where Britain is.

I want public services that work, people supported and thriving and to enjoy all that living in a multicultural place offers.

Well many of you trusted Starmer, look what he's doing to the country. Always putting other countries re money at top of the list, now he's handed a free pass to Indians to come and work here without having to pay NI, to support the NHS, which they will use, whilst increaing what our employers pay. How is that putting a Britain first. Do you wonder why people are sick and tired of them.

Grandmabatty

Yet again, this is not a UK problem but an England problem. Reform does not figure much in Scotland at all. Trump is disliked by many in Scotland for his high handed treatment over his golf course plans. Regardless of where his mother was born, he is looked at with scorn and distaste, the same way we look at Farage.

No you just have the dysfunctional SNP.

I do wonder if it is time to make voting compulsory for general elections? We would then really see what support political parties actually have. Could be interesting!!

Does anybody actually believe that Reform supporters have a new found empathy for young girls who were abused?

Really? Why does this kindness and care not extend to other groups?

Perhaps they are in fact The Kind Party .

Maremia

Allira, it's only 'inflammatory' if it is untrue. Let's have a look at some of there, well, I was going to say policies, but no-one has been able to pinpoint any. So let's start with the over emphasis on 'asian grooming gangs'. Yes, they are evil and yes they exist, but they are sadly not alone. I have yet to see a Reform candidate hit out about the all too numerous disgusting white grooming gangs. That ommision is racist. Don't you agree?

Yes!

Frenchgalisinpain, yes, shocking and cruel, and why do it?

Yes, Wyllow3, the Reform elected politicians now have 3 clear years to show the UK how good they are at working for the people. If they do a good job, then 'go them', and they will deserve the support they have garnered.

Whitewavemark2

Good grief it is like Chinese whispers on this thread.

So my daft comment (a mild criticism). Has gone from daft to stupid to idiots.

But how would anyone explain why people are willing to vote for a Trump supporting political party, rather than an alternative, like the greens, Liberals etc.

What is Farage offering that you are so sure will benefit you?

Voters in other countries are clear about what a trump supporting political party will offer and soundly rejected it, even though they looked as if they would be a shoe-in at one time, but they had the intelligence to swiftly reject this future and returned to vote for a liberal democratic political party.

So protest vote all you need - but please don’t vote for a xenophobic racist political party whose leader admires Trump and Putin, and who led the country down the dead end of Brexit.

How can you trust his judgement?

Thank you White wave mark 2 ..

This is a delusional, cruel, un-empathetic, diabolical and narcissist Satanic man ..

I am sure you read about what he did to the poor little girl with Cancer and her parents. The child was born in The Usa and the parents had been waiting long term for green card residency cards a very long time.

There were other cases of ill children and babies as well.

Whitewavemark2

Allira

Whitewavemark2

Allira

Wyllow3

LauraNorderr

Of course it is the fault of the stupid, uneducated idiots.
They just don’t understand do they.
So busy concerning themselves with rising crime rates, falling educational standards, lack of housing, lack of job opportunities, failing NHS and poor social care.
What do they know? Idiots.

No one has said anything like this on here.

Straw man argument.

That is precisely the premise of the OP, Wyllow3!!
Or didn't you read that?

It certainly isn’t!

The premise was

Two huge western powers rejected Trump leaning political parties.

We didn’t - why?

Does it mean that the voter is willing to be led by the nose as we see in the MAGA crowd?

What on earth is wrong with the voter in the. U.K.?

Are they as daft as the MAGA lot?

🤔

Why don’t people read what is written!!

Honestly.

My question was ‘is the U.K. voter as daft as MAGA”

It is not saying that they are! It merely poses the question in order to get to the reason as to why the U.K. voter appears to be going against the flow - re other large western powers.

I would say you are implying it.

And also, maybe trying to plant the idea.

Parsley3

BBC News - UK and India agree trade deal after three years of talks - BBC News
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5y6y90e5vzo
Meanwhile, the government is busy taking care of business.

This!

BBC News - UK and India agree trade deal after three years of talks - BBC News
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5y6y90e5vzo
Meanwhile, the government is busy taking care of business.

Maremia

Allira, it's only 'inflammatory' if it is untrue. Let's have a look at some of there, well, I was going to say policies, but no-one has been able to pinpoint any. So let's start with the over emphasis on 'asian grooming gangs'. Yes, they are evil and yes they exist, but they are sadly not alone. I have yet to see a Reform candidate hit out about the all too numerous disgusting white grooming gangs. That ommision is racist. Don't you agree?

Well Maremia councils now run by Reform (and the two Mayors) have the opportunity to put more resources social services and police to combat child sexual abuse of all kinds - and hit the resourcing realities. I genuinely think all councils want to do this, btw, the problem is that pressures of different social funding.

Very low turn out and hopefully when there's a general election voters will think more carefully about where they place their cross.
Imo one good thing has come out of this and that's that it has made the other parties particularly the govt sit up and take notice of what voters want especially regarding social care for the more vulnerable and immigration.