Gransnet forums

News & politics

Macron's state visit.

(184 Posts)
escaped Tue 08-Jul-25 07:32:53

Seeing as he's probably about to board his plane, and road closures are now being put in place around Windsor, I thought I'd start a thread on Macron's state visit.
There's an awful lot riding on it.
Nice to see the younger royals getting involved too.

Allira Tue 08-Jul-25 21:00:18

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Hi everybody! It’s lovely to be back. Thank you for the welcome. I’ve missed you all. 😁

Welcome back!

We've missed you too 😀

escaped Tue 08-Jul-25 20:58:57

On paper yes, Whitewavemark2. But I was thinking of covid because it was mentioned above. Every country did their own thing with no agreement. What I'm thinking is, that if the chips were seriously down, would every nation come together for the benefit of all? I hope it's never put to the test.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Jul-25 20:54:48

escaped

True, but Europe, hardly shows itself to think in a joined up way at all.

I wouldn’t entirely agree, there are areas of strength such as agreement over the rule of law, security, intelligence, single market, human rights and other stuff. There is far more that unites them than divides them. However, I think that populist governments are by their nature less likely to cooperate, and tend to bring discord rather than peace.

escaped Tue 08-Jul-25 20:50:53

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Hi everybody! It’s lovely to be back. Thank you for the welcome. I’ve missed you all. 😁

😂
We missed you too! Take care!

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Tue 08-Jul-25 20:49:05

Hi everybody! It’s lovely to be back. Thank you for the welcome. I’ve missed you all. 😁

escaped Tue 08-Jul-25 20:47:15

escaped

True, but Europe, hardly shows itself to think in a joined up way at all.

Sorry, that was to Whitewavemark2 .

growstuff Tue 08-Jul-25 20:44:36

LizzieDrip

FriedGreenTomatoes2

And Starmer wanted us to lock down for longer. I remember that …

Hello FGTsmile

It wasn’t the length of lockdowns per se, as far as I was concerned. It was the not feeling like we were in safe hands - as the French seemed to feel with Macron.

You were fine if you squashed your sombrero and sang happy birthday while you washed your hands.

escaped Tue 08-Jul-25 20:43:46

lafergar

Maybe we could play a sort of GN Bingo......Slagging off Starmer, small boats,Mms Macron's outfits.
One point each.

Anything more substantive 2 points?

????

escaped Tue 08-Jul-25 20:43:25

True, but Europe, hardly shows itself to think in a joined up way at all.

lafergar Tue 08-Jul-25 20:42:29

Maybe we could play a sort of GN Bingo......Slagging off Starmer, small boats,Mms Macron's outfits.
One point each.

Anything more substantive 2 points?

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Jul-25 20:41:30

I really meant European culture as a whole , not individual countries.

We have a shared history and development.

escaped Tue 08-Jul-25 20:40:26

We can never trust the USA as we did in the past
I think that was hinted at too in the speech. Tarrifs??

escaped Tue 08-Jul-25 20:38:56

We may be the country nearest to France, but culturally not so. I'd put Ireland, The Netherlands and Scandinavian countries before France. Even Northern Italy is closer to us culturally than France is.
What we do have in common, however, and was alluded to in the speech, is that France and UK are the two superpowers in Europe in many ways.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Jul-25 20:31:30

It has got to be better to cooperate rather than divide.

History has told us time and again that division never benefits anyone, but cooperate and you end up so much stronger.

This really isn’t about leaders, but about the future of our countries. Focusing just on leaders is a tad parochial. We have a choice - work with those countries nearest to us both geographically and culturally, as well as countries like Canada and Australasia etc. or take our chance on our own, which given the state of the world is almost suicidal. We can never trust the USA as we did in the past, and an arms length relationship seems sensible at present.

valdavi Tue 08-Jul-25 20:25:17

It's a good time to try to get closer ties with france, we do have so much in common with them.
I thik the relationship's been loaded with jealousy for the last 100 years, going both ways. But both countries have lost a lot in the last 100 years, global power-wise and yet both are still countries that many people want to come to and many states aspire to emulate. I'd rather have a "special relationship" with France then with the USA, that's for sure.

REKA Tue 08-Jul-25 20:19:24

Never been a big fan of Macron but I'd swap him for Starmer in a heartbeat

MayBee70 Tue 08-Jul-25 20:17:20

Primrose53

I would like him to explain what he has done with the £700 million we gave France to deal with the boat people.

Starmer is such a fool for giving all that money away to them for doing nothing at all. He is so wet.

We also gave away our right to return people to France because of brexit. So maybe brexit voters were a bit wet too....

escaped Tue 08-Jul-25 20:12:51

Primrose53

I would like him to explain what he has done with the £700 million we gave France to deal with the boat people.

Starmer is such a fool for giving all that money away to them for doing nothing at all. He is so wet.

I think it was Sunak who gave the money to France?? But you're right, from what I see, the French have done next to nothing to deal with the problem.

escaped Tue 08-Jul-25 20:09:28

I think you're all right to an extent, and it comes about because the French and British mentalities are so different. You simply wouldn't get a Macron in the UK, there's no point wishing it. Likewise you wouldn't find a Boris, Blair or Thatcher in France. Look how Churchill and De Gaulle were not compatible. What worked for one was the antithesis of the other.

I think this is because the French are more analytical. This stems from their education where certain attitudes are formed, and indeed taught, in the classroom. You could say creativity is actually stifled during the formative years in France.

We will never achieve total unity with the French people as both our make ups are quite different. Its fascinating how close we are geographically, but how far apart we are sometimes in the way our brains work.

Primrose53 Tue 08-Jul-25 20:09:10

I would like him to explain what he has done with the £700 million we gave France to deal with the boat people.

Starmer is such a fool for giving all that money away to them for doing nothing at all. He is so wet.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Jul-25 19:40:57

LizzieDrip

FriedGreenTomatoes2

And Starmer wanted us to lock down for longer. I remember that …

Hello FGTsmile

It wasn’t the length of lockdowns per se, as far as I was concerned. It was the not feeling like we were in safe hands - as the French seemed to feel with Macron.

Yes that is spot on. It was chaotic and misinformed.

MayBee70 Tue 08-Jul-25 19:37:57

Regarding hands I don't think Macron would have boasted about shaking peoples hands that possibly had covid either...

LizzieDrip Tue 08-Jul-25 19:29:29

FriedGreenTomatoes2

And Starmer wanted us to lock down for longer. I remember that …

Hello FGTsmile

It wasn’t the length of lockdowns per se, as far as I was concerned. It was the not feeling like we were in safe hands - as the French seemed to feel with Macron.

MayBee70 Tue 08-Jul-25 19:11:41

I've only just seen the pictures. They all looked as if they were thoroughly enjoying themselves and liking each others company.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 08-Jul-25 19:11:41

I think it is inevitable that the two powerful European nuclear countries recognise that they must cooperate to build a unified Europe.

Getting along with our nearest neighbours is both desirable and sensible.

The madness appears to at last have disappeared.