Gransnet forums

News & politics

New asylum rules

(222 Posts)
Mollygo Mon 17-Nov-25 13:46:28

^Under the plans, asylum seekers will be returned home if their country is deemed safe, most will have to wait 20 years to apply to settle permanently, with deportations sped up when claims are rejected.
I’d like to know,
Who decides when and if a country is safe?
What do you think.

Casdon Tue 18-Nov-25 20:05:54

Primrose53

StripeyGran

Primrose53

Mollygo

Casdon I don’t know whether KB would have anything to bring to the table, but I think the offer of working with is good.

Your translation of KB’s name fits in well with Shabana Madmood. 🤗🤗

I agree. They could at least TRY working together. Wouldn’t that be a refreshing change?

As for Casdon making up silly names - that is totally juvenile and one would think she would know better.

What? Like the silly names you enjoy using?

I never do that! If you can’t provide evidence of that claim then you should apologise.

I remember who started the Angela Rayner Ghastly Trouser Suit, so that’s pretty rich I must say.

Allira Tue 18-Nov-25 19:53:29

StripeyGran

Over and over again I have shared what I have seen with my own eyes. Re the discussion of fireworks at the Cresta Court, I contacted the Police as suggested and Hope not Hate.

Neither has replied as yet.

So that's my reality.

As you wish.

Were you outside Cresta Court when the fireworks were set off, StripeyGran? Did you take photographs because there seems to be little evidence of what happened.
Perhaps the police might be interested if you had taken photos.

Lathyrus3 Tue 18-Nov-25 19:51:02

Oh. My post doesn’t make much sense now.

Lathyrus3 Tue 18-Nov-25 19:49:35

Ha, ha that means there’s no evidence

StripeyGran Tue 18-Nov-25 19:42:50

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Primrose53 Tue 18-Nov-25 19:01:03

StripeyGran

Primrose53

Mollygo

Casdon I don’t know whether KB would have anything to bring to the table, but I think the offer of working with is good.

Your translation of KB’s name fits in well with Shabana Madmood. 🤗🤗

I agree. They could at least TRY working together. Wouldn’t that be a refreshing change?

As for Casdon making up silly names - that is totally juvenile and one would think she would know better.

What? Like the silly names you enjoy using?

I never do that! If you can’t provide evidence of that claim then you should apologise.

Aveline Tue 18-Nov-25 19:00:47

Oh. Are we back in the playground?

StripeyGran Tue 18-Nov-25 18:58:42

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Primrose53 Tue 18-Nov-25 18:45:28

Mollygo

Casdon I don’t know whether KB would have anything to bring to the table, but I think the offer of working with is good.

Your translation of KB’s name fits in well with Shabana Madmood. 🤗🤗

I agree. They could at least TRY working together. Wouldn’t that be a refreshing change?

As for Casdon making up silly names - that is totally juvenile and one would think she would know better.

rafichagran Tue 18-Nov-25 18:40:14

Kandinsky

I admire her for trying to tackle this problem, but too many snowflakes in this country who’ll try and stop her at every turn.
Happens all the time.

I am no snowflake, bit I think taking peoples personal possessions is not right.
Some of their possesions eg a piece of jewelery may be the only link to their country and this should not be taken from them. That's just common decency.

StripeyGran Tue 18-Nov-25 18:18:21

Over and over again I have shared what I have seen with my own eyes. Re the discussion of fireworks at the Cresta Court, I contacted the Police as suggested and Hope not Hate.

Neither has replied as yet.

So that's my reality.

As you wish.

Aveline Tue 18-Nov-25 17:49:22

But whose reality?

StripeyGran Tue 18-Nov-25 17:48:57

Aveline

I wish there was more working together rather than the current adversarial approach.

I wish people weren't insular and scared and easily manipulated.
I wish we had independent journalism reporting on the reality.

LemonJam Tue 18-Nov-25 16:42:35

Previous post: "66% of refugees are claiming Universal Credit??

I guess that's not entirely surprising due to not being able to work whilst they wait for their claims to be considered. Overall only 1.5% of claims are from those with refugee status. 76.4% of the overall UC claims were from the White ethnic group ( White British percentage of population in 2021 census = 74.4%)”.

GOV.UK UC statistics- "there were 7.9 million people on Universal Credit in June 2025, up from 6.8 million people on Universal Credit in June 2024

Of people on Universal Credit in June 2025, 76.4% were from the white ethnic group. The Asian/Asian British ethnicity group accounts for 10.3%. The Black/African/Caribbean/Black British ethnicity group accounts for 6.0%. The Mixed/Multiple Ethnic groups accounts for 2.9%, while the Other ethnic group accounts for 4.4%

The proportion of people in the ‘no work requirements’ conditionality regime (42%) continues to increase

In June 2025, 83.6% of people on UC belonged to the immigration status group “CTA – UK, Ireland, Right of Abode”

In June 2025, 9.7% of people on UC were in the “EU Settlement Scheme” group. 2.7% of people on UC were in the “Indefinite Leave to Remain (not EU Settlement Scheme)” group. 1.5% of people on UC were in the “Refugee” group. 1.0% of people on UC were in the “Limited Leave to Remain (not EU Settlement Scheme) including family reunion” group. 0.7% of people on UC were in the “Humanitarian” group. 0.4% of people on UC were in the “Other” group

There were, on average, 52,000 claims and 44,000 starts per week in May 2025, slightly lower than at the same point in May 2024

There were 6.4 million households on Universal Credit in March 2025, of which 5.9 million (92%) had a Universal Credit payment

Universal Credit households with children accounted for half (50%) of all households with a payment in March 2025".

Babs03 Tue 18-Nov-25 16:08:19

Aveline

I wish there was more working together rather than the current adversarial approach.

I do too.
I also wish that governments didn’t have such short termist policies which they know will play well to the crowd and so win votes despite these policies being ill thought out.

Aveline Tue 18-Nov-25 15:48:18

I wish there was more working together rather than the current adversarial approach.

Casdon Tue 18-Nov-25 15:12:39

Mollygo

Casdon I don’t know whether KB would have anything to bring to the table, but I think the offer of working with is good.

Your translation of KB’s name fits in well with Shabana Madmood. 🤗🤗

She was definitely in one yesterday, so that is probably an apt nickname for her.

Babs03 Tue 18-Nov-25 14:46:19

winterwhite

I'm shaken to the core that these measures are being proposed by a Labour government.

Seems to me that the issue has been blown out of proportion by Farage purely as a weapon to attack and destabilise the Labour Party, and Starmer is falling for it. I'm disappointed in him.

Me too.
But sadly, as with the US, carrying out witch hunts on certain groups perceived as ‘the enemy’, are becoming a way to win votes.
A piece in The Times led with an article about migration figures being over egged in comparison with those leaving the UK every year. Couldn’t access it due to hitting a paywall.

winterwhite Tue 18-Nov-25 12:31:41

I'm shaken to the core that these measures are being proposed by a Labour government.

Seems to me that the issue has been blown out of proportion by Farage purely as a weapon to attack and destabilise the Labour Party, and Starmer is falling for it. I'm disappointed in him.

Mollygo Tue 18-Nov-25 12:26:49

Casdon I don’t know whether KB would have anything to bring to the table, but I think the offer of working with is good.

Your translation of KB’s name fits in well with Shabana Madmood. 🤗🤗

Allira Tue 18-Nov-25 11:25:43

Casdon I wasn't reporting your post but one of those dubious ones from a spammer which appeared on several threads. GNHQ has deleted them very swiftly, thank you.

Kandinsky Tue 18-Nov-25 11:19:00

Well when it comes to what Westminster is doing wrong I would have a very long list
Asylum seekers probably wouldn’t even figure at the top of it seeing as I believe there are a myriad of burning political issues apart from small boats

Well you’re completely out of touch with the country’s mood. Which is why people like you shouldn’t be anywhere near politics.
You can’t see a problem - and even if there is one it’s someone else’s fault.

Allira Tue 18-Nov-25 11:14:06

Reported.

Casdon Tue 18-Nov-25 11:07:40

Allira

Casdon

Primrose53

Not sure why everybody is going on about taking jewellery etc. Labour MP Barry Gardiner was on TV last night saying although it was a suggestion in Denmark, they never actually went through with it.

It will never happen here! 17 Labour backbenchers have now said they are against the plans SM outlined yesterday. Some very vocally.

I noticed Kemi Badendoch offered to work with SM to sort out this issue but SM was very curt in her reply. It would have been a good idea I thought.

What is it that you think Kemi Badenough could bring to the table, what knowledge or skills does she have that would be of benefit?

On the gold issue, I think if a family fleeing from a war zone or oppressive regime enters the UK with gold, it probably is theirs legitimately. I’d be more suspicious as to the provenance if a single man brought in a large amount because surely if it did belong to his family, it would be the only form of security for the family left behind?

On the gold issue, I think if a family fleeing from a war zone or oppressive regime enters the UK with gold, it probably is theirs legitimately.

Yes, it might well be.
However, if it is very valuable, above a certain amount, I can see the point that UK citizens, including pensioners, are means-tested before they can receive certain benefits, so should asylum seekers be subject to the same rules as UK citizens or exempt from those rules?

That is an academic question, btw, not that I have a particular opinion on the matter.

I think so, once their asylum claim is accepted, as that is what insurance policies are for, and effectively that’s what their gold is.

Allira Tue 18-Nov-25 10:59:42

Rachel Millward on X:

Let me make it clear: refugees are welcome here. Using an army camp isn't the way to do it, and the dysfunctional Home Office must do better than their total lack of communication with local communities.

It is beyond me why unused Army camps are not suitable for asylum seekers and refugees.
Why?

We had refugees living in an Army camp a few miles away not long ago, they have moved elsewhere now, hopefully to settle, and now the Army is back occupying those same premises.
Army camps are not just for single men, there are family homes too.

They're not Nissen huts.