Rosie51: I don't think Labour is proposing these plans to degrade women. "No but they are failing to let women be a defined group based solely on sex. As Galaxy mentioned up thread Lisa Nandy is on video record saying that transwomen rapists ie men should serve their sentence in a "prison of their choosing" Too many in the Labour party put transwomen in pole position over women. That's not protecting 51% of the population"
Lisa Nandy made her comments 6 years ago, in February 2020 during the Labour Party leadership. What she actually said THEN " I believe very fundamentally in people's right to self identify..I think trans women are women and I think transmen are men, so I think they should be accommodated in a prison of their choosing". Mandy made her comments in 2020 while defending the "self identification" position for transgender rights, which she argued was important for ensuring trans people are not discriminated against.
Her leadership bid failed. She was NOT formally speaking on behalf of the Labour Party, she was speaking as an individual. She was not party leader or an official spokesperson- they were her personal views. It was Labour's position in 2023 that transgender women convicted of sexual crimes should NOT be housed in female prisons. Labour were not in government at the time. The world and the law has moved on since 2020.
Current 2026 Reform UK on position of women and transgender women:
1) advocates for a "common sense" (rather than legal) approach to gender focussing on protecting women's rights based on biological sex
2) key polices include banning transgender ideology in schools, restricting access for trans women to female only spaces and sports. Opposes "social transitioning" in schools for transgender pupils.
3) Pledges to replace the Equality Act 2010 arguing it currently facilitates "woke" ideology and positively discriminates in favour of minorities. Has not said what it will be replaced by.
Current 2026 Labour Party position on women and transgender women:
1) Aims to balance protecting women's sex based rights under the Equality Act with supporting trans inclusion, navigating a complex, legally evolving position.
2) Pledges to uphold singe sex spaces and has moved to exclude trans women from all women candidate lists and as from 2026 from voting in main Labour women's conference.
3) The Labour party HAS adopted position that a woman is defined by biological sex under the Equality Act.
4) Despite these restrictions, asserts that trans individuals remain protected from discrimination and harassment.
5) pledges to implement a "trans inclusive" ban on conversion practices, but not to simplify to a "self ID system, the gender recognition process.