Gransnet forums

Relationships

Cut off from family since mother in laws death

(20 Posts)
NanaEm Sun 08-Apr-18 16:41:41

My first husband died in tragic circumstances when we were in our thirties leaving me with young children. I always had a great relationship with his parents and maintained this over the following years. When my youngest went away to university I eventually got round to developing a social life and during that time I met my second partner and now husband. My mother in law was happy for me and loved my new husband, she would introduce us as "my daughter and son in law". I loved her, she was a second mother to me in every way.

Anyway I retired early and we bought a second home abroad where my husband had lived before we met. I didn't want to cut all ties with my home and neither did he with his so we agreed to spend half our time here and half there. My mother in law lived independently and initially had good health during this time but eventually she needed more assistance and had a great team of carers to help her out. She had loads of friends who called to see her, her house was never empty, and her son and his wife who lived an hours drive away would spend the weekend with her every few weeks as would her other son who is unmarried. We also continued to see her during the 6 months we spent at home.

Unfortunately the time came when she took ill and had to go into hospital. It became clear she would no longer be able to live by herself. At this time we were on our 6 months away. Her son telephoned me to say he and his wife had decided to move her to a care home 70 miles away from her home to be closer to them for visiting. I expressed my concern as she had lived in her home for 70 years and would be leaving all her friends and connections behind and asked what her other son thought and was told "we will just have to fall out about it if he doesn't agree". My biggest regret is that I didn't fly home right away to see what my mother in law felt about this as I'm sure she would have been upset and scared and I could have fought for her. It breaks my heart that I let her down. She never left hospital and passed away two weeks later. My only consolation is that he never got to move her away.

Since then I have been cut off from her family. They didn't include me or my children in any of the decisions about her funeral, we were made to feel like outsiders. Nor was I included in any of the decisions around the sale of her house even though I was left an equal share of it in her will. She also left me money which they made difficult for me to recover and I would have loved to have chosen a few tokens of her possessions for myself and my children but they spent a month clearing her house and the opportunity was never offered nor was my offer of help taken up even though I lived nearby and they didn't. My brother in law even tried to make me pay a bigger share of the expenses associated with the sale, his rationale being that he and his wife and brother had to do all the work even though I had offered to help, but relented when his brother agreed with me that the bills should be evenly split.

We never see them now. For 40 years I thought they were my family but I was clearly deluded. I'm left to speculate why they froze me out. Did they think I didn't do my share of caring for her, it's true that I didn't because I was away so much and I feel very guilty about that. Or did they think I shouldn't have been included in her will. I never expected to be. Years ago she tried to talk to me about it but I couldn't think about it and suggested whatever she would have left her son, my first husband, she could leave to our children. I told her all I wanted after she died was a tea set I loved (she arrived with it all boxed up a week later!!). She was such a great friend, mother and grandmother and I miss her so much.

It's been 4 years now since she died and I go over and over it but still can't find peace with it all. I know none of you can give me any answers I was just hoping that in writing it all down it might not look as bad as it feels. But it still does. Thanks for reading my story if you've got this far.

Sent from my iPad

M0nica Sun 08-Apr-18 16:51:07

NanEm I feel so sorry for you, It is difficult to understand how relationships breakdown on someone's death.

One can think of all sorts of reasons why this might have happened - and I am sure you have but you will never ever know and, sadly, I think that you need to accept this. Remember the good times, look at the tea set and remember all the happy times and now you have written this post, put it all behind you and when these thoughts come to you, deliberately push them behind you and think of something else.

If things get really difficult, why not see a counsellor who can help you talk and resolve these issues.

MissAdventure Sun 08-Apr-18 16:54:46

I think this kind of thing can happen, once a pivotal person is no longer around.
I have known it happen in a few families, they just seem to drift apart.

Anniebach Sun 08-Apr-18 16:58:27

No one can take away those memories and it is memories which are so precious x

silverlining48 Sun 08-Apr-18 17:15:28

Have you tried writing a letter, Perhaos to the more amenable brother saying how sad you and your children feel. After all your children’s father was their brother. Are the two brothers still in touch? The wives?
It may not work, but only you can decide whether it’s worth a try. You may have already done this of course.
It is true as miss A said, when a pivotal person dies the family can fragment. It has happened in mine and to many others too I would imagine.
Remember the good times, it’s lovely that you and your mother in law were clearly so close.

Violetfloss Sun 08-Apr-18 17:17:04

I've been through all this with nan.
Very similar.
We looked into care homes for her.
Even with careers going in 3 times a day she still relied on me to do things for her.
3 times a day wasn't enough and she needed 24 hour care.
I was on call 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, luckily we lived very close, so I'm betting her son wanted her near so he could help her and spend time with her without being her career.

If it's any consolation she would of had a say. She would of had a choice in where she was going and what happened to her. The only way she would have no say is if she wasn't of sane mind. Everything still would of been HER choice and she wouldn't of been moved around like an old boot with no say.

Tegan2 Sun 08-Apr-18 17:55:52

It's what happens when people die, I'm afraid. You've done nothing wrong and have no need to feel guilty about anything sad. The S.O. and his brother haven't spoken since their mum died; so much bitterness and resentment just rose to the surface

janeainsworth Sun 08-Apr-18 18:20:33

I can't really add to the good advice you've had from MOnica and Silverlining, NanaEm, but it strikes me that even if you had been in this country when your MiL was admitted to hospital, the outcome would have been the same - i.e, brother-in-law 1 falling out with brother-in-law 2. You were just collateral damage.
Your mother-in-law sounds a lovely person and very fair-minded and clearly loved you and your children. Hold on to that thought.
Decide whether you would like to see either of your brothers-in-law again. Think about how you would feel if you approached them, only to be rebuffed. If you could cope with that, by all means write to, or phone, the more reasonable one.
I hope things work out for you flowers

Hm999 Sun 08-Apr-18 18:23:16

Any point in one of your children writing a letter to one of them, after all they are your children's blood relatives?

mumofmadboys Sun 08-Apr-18 18:28:52

Could you send birthday cards and Chistmas cards with friendly notes and see what happens. You have obviously been a great DIL and shouldn't beat yourself up at all.

Telly Sun 08-Apr-18 18:33:21

This is not unusual, the lynch pin has gone and the rest of the family have no intention of taking her place. I imagine that there is some resentment about the money too, but you maintained an excellent relationship and you will always have that to remember. Could be that there is a bit of jealously too about the closeness of your relationship. But it has been 4 years I don't think a letter is going to change their view. You do need to come to terms with it though, it does feel like unfinished business. How about social media - worth pinging them a quick 'how are you on FB??' Just a thought, but you will need to be prepared to be ignored. Someone else has suggested counselling that might be a way forward. Alternatively write the letter and then burn it. Get on with the rest of your life and be happy.

FarNorth Sun 08-Apr-18 19:07:55

Did you keep in touch with these relatives at Xmas & birthdays, before this happened?
If so, has that now stopped?

I have had no contact with any of my cousins or their parents since I was a teenager.
No falling-out, just not in touch with them.

Eglantine21 Sun 08-Apr-18 20:33:47

NanEm, you say you wish you had flown home and fought for your MIL. Can I ask whether having secured her place in her own home and prevented her move to a place closer to her son you would then have given up your lifestyle to support her. Or would you have then gone back home and left her son to make the frequent 70 mile journeys.

I'm sure you were thinking of her but you were not giving any thought to what life was like for him. Sometimes those of us who are actually doing the caring can't do what absent relatives think we should. It's easy for people to say what they think should happen when they don't have to do it.

It was an upsetting time for him too and perhaps he could have done with support rather than criticism. After all you didn't fly back to help did you?
If that criticism upsets you, just think for a minute how your criticism and disapproval could have upset him and led to his not wanting you to have any more input.

HAZBEEN Mon 09-Apr-18 08:34:11

My recent experience has been totally different. I hadnt spoken to my brother for almost 20 years after a silly falling out. I tried a few times but was rebuffed and as I was living abroad for some of that time then 300 mile away back in the UK it wasnt very often I got to try. Then my father was diagnosed with a terminal illness at Christmas and I went to visit for a few weeks. The contact was minimal but there was contact. When Dad died last month my brother and I had to speak about arrangements etc and in conversation worked a few things out. We are now in contact and can ring or text each other about all sorts of things. I dont know if we will ever be as close as we were when we were younger but its a start!

BlueBelle Mon 09-Apr-18 09:22:37

I think all you can do is remember your good caring times with her concentrate on the positive things you did for and with her and chase the negative thoughts out your head otherwise when these nasty thoughts arrive they will eventually over ride all those good times and become the major contributed to your memories which you don’t want

I m afraid I wouldn’t keep writing or sending cards they have made their choice and it doesn’t sound as if they want to include you so don’t bang your head against a brick wall
If you know where her remains are take flowers when you are around but basically I think we all have regrets about some things we ve done or not done but need to accept our frailties as it won’t help her or you

GrandmaMoira Mon 09-Apr-18 09:55:47

I'm sorry for the loss of your lovely mother-in-law. I think it is common for step families to cut off after a death. When my second husband was alive we saw his family regularly and I often babysat his DGC. His youngest DD lived with us for some years. But, they just cut me off after he died.
I have since heard of this happening regularly, especially with second marriages.

MargaretX Mon 09-Apr-18 10:40:43

I come from a family which fell out regularly over wills etc although there was so little to leave. There was so much bitterness and my favourite cousin who I was friends with as a teenager, cut me in the street for something I had done ( which I had not done!) and I have never seen her since.

In your case I agree with Eglantine 21. If you are the main carer you have to pick a care home nearby.
Your Mil had a good life and the end was perhaps a Good luckdisappointment for her but I'm afraid it will be for us as well when the time comes. We won't be looked after like the Queen.

Think of the good times. It seems you are still grieving and a counsellor or bereavement group might help.
She was like a mother to you and its normal to out live a mother and get on with your life. I'm sure having put it down on paper will help you.

MargaretX Mon 09-Apr-18 10:42:50

Sorry I wanted to wish you Good luck and the curser put it in where it is now. !!

luluaugust Mon 09-Apr-18 13:33:19

I am sorry this has caused you so much upset, I guess when the son phoned you he expected to be supported in trying to do his best for his mother, when you didn't at such a difficult time for the carer he decided that was it. Such innocent things are often the cause of a family break, we've had a slightly different version in our family, when emotions are high offence is easily taken and hard to repair. I would let it be and remember your MIL as she was.

NanaEm Mon 09-Apr-18 13:57:57

Thank you everyone for your comments it has helped to know that my situation is not unusual after a death as many of you have said. I know my mother in law wouldn't have wanted to move away from her home town as her oldest son had asked her to move closer to them on several occasions in the years after my father in law died but she didn't want to and always dismissed the idea as this was her home. I am consoled that she never had to move as it all happened so quickly but wish I'd been quicker off the mark to think to fly home to talk it through with her as she must have been feeling very upset.

Eglantine21 I know what you're saying and agree up to a point. It is hard being the main carer, I have been there with my own parents and was the only family member who took responsibility for them both before and after their deaths but I was happy to do so and didn't fall out with my brothers and sisters over it. But we are all different.

Anyway writing it down has helped as has all of your different perspectives. I am blessed with a lovely husband, children and grandchildren of my own so that's were my focus will stay from now on. I have so many good memories of my lovely mother in law to talk about with them against a few bad ones which were not of her making so that's how I'll move on. Thanks again for all the good advice x