Gransnet forums

Relationships

My Dad remarried the worse spouse!

(209 Posts)
marn1186 Fri 17-Nov-23 17:49:01

Hey, I’m looking for some other ears and eyeballs on a difficult situation with my 70-year-old dad.

My mom divorced my dad after almost 30 years of being married. At his time, all 5 of his kids were leaving for college or getting a job/career (kids ages around 19-27). So, my dad goes from being married and 5 kids to being quite lonely. I know he was down on himself and in the dumps between everything that goes with divorce and children leaving the house. Anyways, not too long after the divorce, he meets another lady(eHarmony) and goes from being in the dumps to happily dating. During the dating phase, I would regularly stay with my dad, where sometimes his new girlfriend would be present. I quickly read this lady for 6-12 months during the dating phase and KNEW she was full of red flags, but I didn’t say much because my dad was enjoying dating/life and could tell it was good for him after such a life change of his divorce and kids leaving the house. To be clear, he and my mother parted ways because they grew far apart and became complete opposites.

Fast forward to my dad remarrying in 2011 (his new spouses 2nd marriage too), and he's been re-married for over 12 years (kids are now married and ages 31, 33, 37, 39). There are now 6 grandchildren in the picture. There is no bitterness from me or my siblings over my dad re-marrying, but IMMEDIATELY, his new spouse started jeopardizing my relationship with my dad, and the same for my 4 other siblings. The root cause of our degrading relationship with our father all links directly to my dad's spouse. To put it clearly, she is one of the most sour and unpleasant people I know. She is the “Karen of Karens” and can ruin just about any father gathering. Most of what she does is make nasty comments, passive-aggressive comments, or just demonstrate insane behavior. Unfortunately, my dad is unbelievably oblivious to how egregious his spouse's behavior is, or he plays intentional ignorance (easily a combination of both). At the same time, he’s made comments recognizing his spouse “has problems”.

I truly believe any other normal human would divorce a spouse that hurts relationships with kids or grandkids. I’m not asking my dad to do this, but I have told him since he won’t correct the situation with his spouse that, he will need to visit with us without her. Please know we have tried and tried to accommodate him and his spouse for 12 years even though she’s treated us and my dad terribly for over a decade.

Over the years, examples of my dad's spouse:

-When they were first dating, she attempted to make nasty comments about me moving (they maybe had been dating 3 months) home with dad after I was laid off from my first corporate job in 2009 and also severely suffering from a disease Ulcerative colitis (really tough). I let these comments go to not rock the boat as my dad was happy. Essentially, she was calling me a mooch for moving back home for a short time do get back on my feet getting a new job, and get my health figured out (22-23 years old at the time).
-After my dad's divorce, my dad was struggling financially, and she would criticize him for this. She would brag they had a prenuptial agreement but now she’s mad about it because my dad his now doing much better financially shes now she wants to know all about his money.
-Dozens of examples of bashing our family members, my mom, and even my mother's grandmother. She bashes my aunts and uncles on both my dad’s and my mother's side. My dad’s new spouse gets very jealous of anyone that people like, and her automatic behavior is to bash anyone that is well liked.
-She is often very mean to my dad and does this in front of all his kids.
-To be clear, I married in 2011, and she had just started dating dad. She stopped my dad from coming to my wedding because I told my dad your “new date” wasn’t sitting up front in the wedding with my mother. So yes, you could say I wasn’t willing to let my dad “bring his new date” to my wedding and jeopardize the day for my mom. Anyway, my dad missed my wedding over this, and I let this go quickly. The remedy was I would throw a celebratory party with family (I had a small destination wedding), and my dad thought this was a replacement for attending my wedding. I really did question my dad at this point in my life.
-Almost all family parties/holidays end with some kind of verbal incident with my dad’s spouse and one of my siblings. Usually ruining the gathering.
-Things are starting to get ugly because now my dad’s spouse is saying nasty things to my wife and my other sibling's spouses. Oh boy, this is where gatherings get ugly.
-She does NOT like young children. She doesn’t like the kids to play in the house, to loud, to dirty/messy.
-She has no interest in spending any time with grandchildren and really doesn’t let my dad spend time with his grandchildren.
-She won’t let him visit his kids alone/without her.
-She gets very drunk at most family parties to the point where she passes out on the couch or chair in the room (this has happened more than I can count).
-My spouse can barely tolerate being in the same room with her or traveling to see my dad whatsoever because dad's spouse.
-She is unhappy and mad at the world over her childhood.
-I’ve seen her throw/push a toddler to the ground because toddler was having a typical toddler meltdown (it was my daughter, who was only 20 months old).
-Recently, she got drunk and told my wife that our kids are terrible, don’t listen, and are very messy + we keep our kids from her and my dad (you can imagine how well this went over). My wife put her in her place (verbally), and even my dad, who witnessed all of it, fully supported everything my wife said to his own spouse.
-She won’t let us visit her house with our dogs but will allow her friends to stay at her house with their dogs and stay for weeks at a time.
-During family parties at their house, you will see her throwing objects across the kitchen (plates, forks, spoons) because she can't handle how dirty/unorganized a kitchen can get during a large family party (20+ people). She is out of touch with reality and thinks every minute of a family party should look like the Ritz-Carlton.
-She is nasty, and I’ve seen her comment on young children’s body and appearance (even her own grand daughter). She’s called kids fat, and I’ve seen her not let her own granddaughter have a snack because she thinks they’re getting too fat.
-when we lived out of state, she visited with my dad for Thanksgiving, and immediately upon arrival, she demanded cleaning supplies from my wife to disinfect her room (we had just had the house professionally cleaned). She also started to aggressively clean anything in the house in front of my wife (pans/backsplash During this same visit, she couldn’t stop trash-talking my sister and my grandmother, and suddenly, the gathering was ruined because my sister-in-law decided to stick up for us and loudly told my dad’s spouse to STFU! Many things like this have happened over the years.
-My dad has 5 kids in the Midwest, and she attempted to get my dad to move away to California so she could be closer to her kids and better weather. My dad stated from the beginning that he will never leave home.
-She really has no genuine interest in visiting with my dad’s kids or grandchildren. It is 100% for show so she can tell other people that she visits with us (it's all so disingenuous).

I could write for pages and pages…

Anyways, I know my dad has made the mistake of a lifetime. My siblings and I have made our best attempt to work around my dad and his deranged spouse for over a decade. I feel like I’ve lost 13 years of good times with my dad because of her and how difficult she is… and may only have 10 years left with my dad. My wife and I can no longer tolerate her toxic/negative attitude to the point of barely speaking with my dad or seeing him (he knows this). My siblings feel the same way along with their spouses and are upset with him over enabling and allowing his spouses toxicity over his own kids and grandchildren. My dad has not seen his 5 kids or grand children for 6 months because of his toxic spouse.

I do want to hear other comments feedback on this bizarre situation. As a father, I do feel an obligation to keep toxic people like this away from my life and my young kids. We have dozens other people who care about us and genuinely want to spend time with us.

I feel like my dad needs to hear how wrong he is from a counselor/professional. I fear he is in cognitive decline, intentionally ignorant, or playing intentional head in the clouds. He is a very traditional human, and he finds doing anything without his wife to be an embarrassment or looks bad from an image standpoint…. and a divorce is just outrageous to him because of his image and pride. Again, I’ve simply told him do what you want but you need to visit with us without your toxic spouse. Unfortunately, it’s nearly impossible for his spouse to treat anyone with genuine respect and dignity anytime we see here. EVERYONE has had it and is at their wits end!!!!!

My dad wants to continue to force-feed us his toxic spouse and just make us all "deal with her".

We are all angryangry

Again, what do you all think of this? I'm happy to clarify in the comments as needed.

marn1186 Fri 17-Nov-23 21:17:48

Thanks, VioletSky, for reading and providing a rational response. As you read, an adult woman throwing her grandchild to the floor is immediate grounds for being banned for life.... believe it or not, we still attempted to work with her for 5-6 years following that event to work with my dad and his baggage.

Callistemon21 Fri 17-Nov-23 21:35:46

The fact that this woman would physically throw a toddler to the ground was enough for me

You believe that, Violetsky?
🤔

growstuff Fri 17-Nov-23 21:58:24

marn1186

Thanks, VioletSky, for reading and providing a rational response. As you read, an adult woman throwing her grandchild to the floor is immediate grounds for being banned for life.... believe it or not, we still attempted to work with her for 5-6 years following that event to work with my dad and his baggage.

Does your father know that you refer to his spouse as his "baggage"?

VioletSky Sat 18-Nov-23 00:53:41

Callistemon21

^The fact that this woman would physically throw a toddler to the ground was enough for me^

You believe that, Violetsky?
🤔

I have no reason not to

Either every post on this forum is treated like a potential lie or none of them

Choose one

VioletSky Sat 18-Nov-23 00:57:54

I take every scenario at face value and give advice based on who is potentially right or wrong...

Easy enough as a DIL and MIL

I can't magine being the sort of person whom, if they can't directly agree with the MIL simply brands a poster a liar instead

OldFrill Sat 18-Nov-23 01:08:52

No wonder she drinks at family gatherings. Your dad probably pours them both a couple before they arrive.

V3ra Sat 18-Nov-23 01:22:05

Why on earth would he choose to spend one minute with an angry, resentful, embittered daughter who makes no secret of the fact that she detests his loving and supportive wife?

marn1186 is the son, not the daughter:

My wife and I can no longer tolerate her toxic/negative attitude to the point of barely speaking with my dad or seeing him

As a father, I do feel an obligation to keep toxic people like this away from my life and my young kids.

NotSpaghetti Sat 18-Nov-23 06:38:38

I think this whole scenario is very sad.

Maybe initially this person was feeling excluded and vulnerable as she had no "history" with your family. It's sometimes hard to be just tagging along with a bunch of people with a shared past. You, your dad and your siblings had that and she has set off on the wrong foot with all of you.

Maybe she feels insignificant and is therefore rude and domineering. What is her relationship really like with her own family I wonder?

What can you do?
Well, your dad has chosen to live his life with this woman - and was happy one with her. You don't really know what goes on when you aren't there - so he may be happy still.

I think we'd all be irritated if a visitor felt they had to clean our home. I would be very angry if they pushed (?) (I assume she pushed) a toddler... but if she's an alcoholic she is not going to be safe.

I'd certainly not want them to stay - or want to visit them - but maybe the answer is to have a weekend away so you have separate space but can meet for dinner (say)?

Short visits will keep you in touch but not allow things to escalate.
Meeting for lunch if you are close enough? For brunch occasionally? Usually alcohol isn't involved in the morning...

You can't change anyone else - only how you respond to them.

If it was my dad I'd probably want to keep in touch and would try the very short visits (not at anyone's home). I think family lunch or breakfast where nobody has ownership of the space will definitely be better than what you have.

I feel sorry for all of you but you cannot make anyone else change. Only yourself.

Good luck.

NotSpaghetti Sat 18-Nov-23 06:39:12

Does your dad have any hobbies?

Juliet27 Sat 18-Nov-23 08:24:55

A kind response NotSpaghetti

Scat you may not have read the OP’s message thoroughly enough to realise it was written by the son, not a daughter!

Elegran Sat 18-Nov-23 08:52:31

RosiesMaw

There seems to be a habit if looooooong complicated dysfunctional family sagas emanating from the other side of the Atlantic doesn’t there?
hmmhmmhmm

Indeed. Followed by incandescent indignation at the honest advice in almost all replies. Symptomatic.

Katie59 Sat 18-Nov-23 09:45:43

We often get one side of a story where a relationship has spiraled out of control and the Step Mother situation is often very tense. I’m a step mother, luckily the relationship with OHs daughters is very good, I count them as friends, they are a very close family and I’m thankful that I fit in well.

However I have known situations where a second marriage has caused chaos and the new wife has turned out to be a money grabbing witch, intent on disinheriting all his family. Very often these situations boil down to uncertainty of inheritance issues but of course nobody is willing to admit that.

JosieGc Sat 18-Nov-23 09:55:29

I get it and I understand your pain. My father did this too, the difference being his wife was around me as a child and caused us unending harm and upset to my brother and I with her bile. As adults I wanted to maintain a relationship with them, but wasn’t prepared to let my children feel her hatred and abuse so I spoke up against it. As a result my Dad and his wife never met my children. Their choice, not mine. All because I asked for human decency. Needless to say my children have no relationship with them now and nor do I. She has isolated my father from his children, grandchildren, his siblings and his friends and he willingly went along with it - possibly for an easy life? I’ll never really know . I think for what its worth, you are better off away from them, as are your children. Toxicity is toxicity and love is supposed to be unconditional not painful and fraught and insulting. Your father doesn’t seem to have boundaries around acceptable behaviour from his spouse. I know it is painful but I discovered many years ago that I was sad because I was dreaming about a happy family that didnt exist. Now I see it that myself and my children avoided all that pain and toxic behaviour and when I look at my happy healthy confident family that are loving and respectful to one another I am glad they didn’t have her nasty influence around them. Hope my story helps. Sending you strength. You deserve better.

eazybee Sat 18-Nov-23 10:35:22

Ah. The Ultimate Threat.

Do as I say or you won't see your grandchildren.
Not trying to break the marriage up, obviously.

JosieGc Sat 18-Nov-23 12:43:37

It wasn’t a do as I say, it was a please can you stop saying hurtful things about me, my mother, my grandmother, my siblings. It was met with a resounding no and outrage that I’d even dared to suggest I should be treated as a human being, not to mention the refusal to meet all of my beautiful children. They didn’t just cut me off, they cut off my Dads own mother, a wonderful woman who was totally heartbroken. We all lived for our families which is why we put so much time and effort in to my stepmother, walked on eggshells for years. I even asked my father whether she would like to be ‘Nanny’ or ‘Nana’ after my children were born. The answer was neither. Quite literally, that’s what my own father said to me.
So no eazybee, it was more of a ‘Let me abuse you as much as I want or we will cut you off.’ From them.
Nowadays, I’m grateful they came to that choice. My children are wonderful human beings, emotionally healthy , respectful, wonderful people. I have shown them pictures and told them all about their grandfather. We grieved together.
It is my father and stepmothets loss, we just wanted to be a family. She never wanted that, not when I was a child, nor an adult, nor when I had my own children. I wish them well now , but dont discount the pain and trauma you go through to get to that place. If you don’t know, I’m glad for you. It means you never had a parent do that to you.

Callistemon21 Sat 18-Nov-23 12:47:16

eazybee

Ah. The Ultimate Threat.

Do as I say or you won't see your grandchildren.
Not trying to break the marriage up, obviously.

I suppose if the wicked step-mother is liable to drop a grandchild on its head then preventing them from seeing the DGC might be a wise move.

pascal30 Sat 18-Nov-23 12:59:37

I'm not sure whether Marn is male or female from the post.. but I think they sent out a very strong signal of non-inclusivity by banning new MIL from their wedding.. I think your father probably prefers being with his wife to loneliness in his old age and will not take your side..

So you have two choices..sit down with your MIL and try to understand why you don't get on and try to reach a workable way forward.. or simply keep your distance from them both

Judy54 Sat 18-Nov-23 14:03:44

marn1186 you say there is no bitterness from me, as a reader of your post what comes across is a very disgruntled and discontented person. Derogatory Karen remarks do not help. You say this Lady is nasty but what I am picking up is a lot of unpleasantness and spite towards your Father's Wife. It is nearly impossible for his Spouse to treat anyone with genuine respect. Hard as it may sound we have to treat others with respect to gain respect ourselves. Try a little kindness and tenderness towards Her instead of vitriol hopefully it will help you both to have a better understanding of each other.

eazybee Sat 18-Nov-23 14:28:07

JosieGc, My response was to the OP, Marnll.

A little less haste in jumping to conclusions perhaps?

Summerlove Sat 18-Nov-23 14:44:00

eazybee

Ah. The Ultimate Threat.

Do as I say or you won't see your grandchildren.
Not trying to break the marriage up, obviously.

Also known as “don’t be a damaging jerk and we can have a lovely relationship”

Summerlove Sat 18-Nov-23 14:45:33

pascal30

I'm not sure whether Marn is male or female from the post.. but I think they sent out a very strong signal of non-inclusivity by banning new MIL from their wedding.. I think your father probably prefers being with his wife to loneliness in his old age and will not take your side..

So you have two choices..sit down with your MIL and try to understand why you don't get on and try to reach a workable way forward.. or simply keep your distance from them both

Very clearly states they are a man

New stepmother was just someone their father had been dating for a very short time at the wedding.

Reading really is difficult for some

VioletSky Sat 18-Nov-23 15:01:12

If I were the stepmother I would never imagine myself as belonging on the same table as the mother. I would have happily sat at a different table...

And easily avoided any drama on a wedding day

Smileless2012 Sat 18-Nov-23 15:16:12

"his new date"!!! She has a name, why didn't you use it instead of being rude and dismissive marn? Have you ever considered the possibility that she didn't stop your father from attending your wedding, but he chose not to go because of the way you spoke about his new partner?

pascal30 Sat 18-Nov-23 15:42:43

Summerlove

pascal30

I'm not sure whether Marn is male or female from the post.. but I think they sent out a very strong signal of non-inclusivity by banning new MIL from their wedding.. I think your father probably prefers being with his wife to loneliness in his old age and will not take your side..

So you have two choices..sit down with your MIL and try to understand why you don't get on and try to reach a workable way forward.. or simply keep your distance from them both

Very clearly states they are a man

New stepmother was just someone their father had been dating for a very short time at the wedding.

Reading really is difficult for some

what a crass comment.. you clearly aren't aware that a spouse could be male or female.. and could have children.

Scat Sat 18-Nov-23 16:28:46

New stepmother nope, the father and his 2nd wife have been married 13 years now so she's clearly in it for the long haul.

Very clearly states they are a man No they don't. marn refers to their wife. Same sex marriages, with children, do exist you know.