Gransnet forums

Relationships

How to respond to toxic family member who makes demands of historical family items etc

(14 Posts)
Merry5 Sun 08-Sept-24 15:23:30

After many years of a poor relationship that caused me a lot of upset over many years, my sister started behaving very rudely and badly to me. I repeatedly asked her not to and did not respond in kind, though to maintain some sort of relationship I did sometimes end up doing what she wanted. We now have no direct contact (even cards etc) which is actually a huge relief and much better for me. I have some intermittent relationship with my adult nieces as she does with one of my adult children - not the other as she has cut off communication with them.
The current problem is she has now contacted me demanding something I happen to have from our family in the past, asking very rudely. I am not sure how best to respond - should I just ignore her as she is so toxic and I don’t think I should have to do as she says? Will this come back to bite me as she might spread more poison about me through the rest of the family? Or is the best ‘adult’ response to send her what she wants with a brief acknowledgement? That might be galling for me just now, but I’d have to get over that. Though also, what else might she then demand? I ideally want to be left alone without any contact with her, though somehow manage to maintain relationships with other family members - as much as possible. However I realise this may well be compromised.
I’d be grateful for others’s ideas and suggestions. Thanks

Oreo Sun 08-Sept-24 15:25:08

It depends what the item is and how much it means to you.

Barmeyoldbat Sun 08-Sept-24 15:46:43

I would just ignore her.

MissInterpreted Sun 08-Sept-24 15:47:51

Barmeyoldbat

I would just ignore her.

I would too. Unless the item which you have doesn't mean anything to you, then you might be as well giving to her.

Greenfinch Sun 08-Sept-24 15:53:13

Just let her have it but mention the other items you would like to keep.After all they are only “things”.We had this in our family and found we had more peace of mind just letting things go to someone who desperately seemed to want them.I am speaking as someone who doesn’t get sentimentally attached to historical family items. You may well be different.

Namsnanny Sun 08-Sept-24 16:02:08

Play her game to your advantage.

Wait a while and do nothing.

If the item means very little to you, give it to her explaining honey not vinegar would have resulted in you giving it to her sooner.

Then ask her to see this transaction as the last reason for her to trouble you again.

If the item is of sentimental or financial value. Decide whether to keep or do as above.

If you are entitled to the item and wish to keep it,
Ignore her until or unless she pesters, then send a written no.
Accompanied with a request to leave you alone (if it is appropriate, explain a cease and desist letter will be sent).

Good luck.

pascal30 Sun 08-Sept-24 16:05:19

If the item was left to you and you wish to keep it then I would ignore her. If she has some sort of claim to it, possibly give it to her DD to reduce contact.. She sounds like she might just be provoking you, don't respond if you don't want to.. good luck

CocoPops Mon 09-Sept-24 05:15:29

My immediate reaction would be not wanting to jump through her hoops because she's rude and demanding. So I'd ignore her.
Otherwise if you do not want the item you could send it but not if you fear she will make futher demands.
I would not care what she says about me. Family have probably got the measure of her.

Smileless2012 Wed 11-Sept-24 21:52:39

If you don't want her to have it then say no.

AuntyTrouble Fri 13-Sept-24 13:01:50

Send her message to the others in your family you have a relationship with, with an addition to the effect "I've received this rudely worded demand from ....name...the article she is demanding I give her has been in my possession for Xamount of years, she has no right to demand it and I will not be passing it on to her, in time, it being a family piece, it will be passed down to one of my children. She and I are not in contact anymore and I fail to see why she would think this communication is ok". Then ignore her altogether

mae13 Fri 13-Sept-24 13:07:25

If you give in on this then just where will it stop?

Fleurpepper Sun 01-Dec-24 19:45:45

How did you come in possession of said item is the question. Were you left it in a will, was it truly given to you personally?

Jaxjacky Sun 01-Dec-24 20:31:22

Three months ago, so hopefully sorted now

Fleurpepper Sun 01-Dec-24 20:55:08

ah well, it is always interesting to have update. So how did it go Merry5.