Gransnet forums

Sponsored discussions

   Please note: This topic is for discussions paid for by Gransnet clients. If you'd like to have your own paid for discussion thread, please feel free to mail us at [email protected]. If you are a journalist, start-up or student and you want to request feedback from gransnetters, please post in Media Requests.

Talk to CQC about the health and/or social care you receive and you could win a £300 Love2Shop voucher *NOW CLOSED*

(57 Posts)
LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Tue 29-Mar-16 10:21:40

We've been asked by the Care Quality Commission (CQC) to find out why gransnetters do – or don't – share their feedback about health and/or social care.

CQC say, "Although many older people are accessing health and/or social care regularly, they tend to be hesitant about sharing their experiences of care – both good and bad. We know that many gransnetters are accessing care regularly on behalf of a loved one or for themselves.

"It's become commonplace for us to feed back about our experiences after a meal, holiday, or hotel stay; however we're still hesitant when it comes to feeding back about life's most important services – health and social care – this would include your GP surgery, dentist, local hospital or care home.

"We want to know what your experiences have been, and why you do – or don't – tend to share feedback about your or your loved one's care."

Everyone who posts on this thread with their experiences of their health and social care treatment and why they do/do not feed back on them will be entered into a prize draw where one lucky gransnetter will win a £300 Love2Shop voucher.

Thanks and good luck with the prize draw.

GNHQ.

*Regarding complaints*

If you have experienced or seen poor care, you have a right to feed back or complain to the organisation that provided or paid for the care. We cannot make these complaints for you or take them up on your behalf. This is because we do not have powers to investigate or resolve them.

If you do give feedback or make a complaint to an organisation that provided or paid for care, please tell CQC too. They want to know about your complaint because it will help them to form a picture of how well a particular service cares for all the people who use it.

If you would like to share your experience with CQC confidentially, visit www.cqc.org.uk/share-your-experience-finder.

AnnGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 05-May-16 10:43:40

dirgni is the lucky winner. Thanks

LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Fri 29-Apr-16 14:30:32

Hi everyone, thanks for all your responses on this thread. We're in the process of sending them over to CQC and the voucher winner will be announced soon!

cruisegal Tue 26-Apr-16 15:22:52

I made complaints about the care sorry lack of care that my late daughter received
whenshe first became ill it was excellent but different providers gave less and less care then when she died it was so bad you would not treat a dog like that.The reply from the CQC was that I had morphine in my house and they knew it for a fact.I do not know how they knew it they did not ask me it is a controlled drug and as I am allergic it to it I would not have it .
The reason they say that a carer not a Doctor refused my daughter her morphine and she died in agony ,so perhaps that is why we do not get in touch with the CQC.

Liz46 Sat 23-Apr-16 16:31:23

In general more help and advice is needed for carers. I asked our social services for help when my mother had Alzheimer's but wanted to stay in her own home. They were worse than useless. For instance, when her illness was quite advanced, she had a fall and was in hospital. She wanted to go home but we thought that she was not safe. She was taken home to be assessed to see if she could make a cup of tea and a piece of toast. She was struggling so the assessor helped her and then said it was o.k. for her to go home.

The only real help I got was from an EMI nurse sent by the GP. Whenever there was a crisis and I didn't know what to do I would phone him. He was wonderful. In the end he helped me to get her into a home (I sold her house to pay for it).

Social Services were still being obstructive.

chrismse1 Tue 19-Apr-16 13:41:21

I have two family members working in nursing homes.

crun Sun 17-Apr-16 14:36:54

"CQC just wanted to address the issue of confidentiality ................We will treat all the information you give us in confidence."

I'm not letting that go unchallenged.

I returned a questionnaire with a remark about refusing to answer reasonable questions because the NHS has refused to explain their reasons for a diagnosis for nearly two decades. Next time at the hospital, a doctor stuffed a voice recorder in my face and said "Have I answered all your questions?" Confidential my arse. Three years later, that same doctor denied that I had ever been taken to A&E and diagnosed with heart arrhythmia, then discharged me untreated.

JOHN19488 Sun 17-Apr-16 13:52:13

YES THEY BE A FEW I THANK

NotSpaghetti Fri 15-Apr-16 15:04:14

I once suspected I had breast cancer and had a very bad experience with my profoundly patronising, humiliating and unhelpful GP.
When I complained to the practice, even the reception staff clearly knew about my issue.

Feel the surveys change nothing. Purely a "tick box" exercise.
Sad but true.

pamhill4 Fri 15-Apr-16 01:15:20

Why haven't we done surveys? Usually because we aren't asked! My Dad, 90 and living with us with advanced dementia, went into respite for us to go to France on holiday for 2 weeks last summer. We visited the care home and it seemed fine, if the building being a bit unfit for purpose with lots of odd, confusing corridors and stairs here and there. My dad reported good food whilst there but I can't be sure. All I know is that they lost his personal wheelchair, taken from his room and taken to another home. Although they admitted liability immediately it took 4 months to get the cash back from buying a replacement. They lost half his name-labelled clothes and 2 other visits to collect them resulted in us refusing to take other peoples labelled clothing or odd stuff! We just wanted what we'd sent him with! Unfortunately we gave up and have never heard since f they've been found. It didn't seem to bother them that the residents wore each others clothes or used their toiletries but to me that meant a loss of human dignity! We told the social worker on the phone but she never said she'd do/inform anyone and it felt like we were being petty. 2 months later Dad passed away so we never had to get into a position of deciding a new respite place, but it wouldn't have been there and quite possibly we wouldn't have bothered. Did anyone ask us to do a survey or comment on his visit formally? No! Would I have done so, yes I would!
Additionally I have my own disabilities and have a care package from the local council. Initially I had a care agency in; staff turned up when they wanted, routes meant girls had no time to do anything as travel wasn't included but they were sent from one side of the city through busy traffic to the other without a thought of travel times, one "girl" even turned up with shorts on so short her arse-cheeks were visible and when she bent over I saw more boobs than she saw on me naked! Was I ever asked for feedback? No. Did I complain, yes but it made no difference. So I changed to hiring my own Personal Assistants (PAs), although I only found about this scheme accidentally. This was much better as I had control over who came and when. However the agency who does the payroll is worse than useless and yet the contract is only with them. Does anyone ask, occasionally, but nothing changes, just shoulders shrugged and "yeah Ive heard that"!
I know care giving is difficult- I was a paid carer for a local authority for 4 1/2 years, but treating people with care and respect, obligatory and regular training to increase standards and support and information for carers all needs much improvement. But will anyone listen and make any changes? Doubtful!

IHaveAFabulousDIL Wed 13-Apr-16 10:54:38

I went to a conference right at the beginning of the CQC 's remit to inspect GP surgeries. They were asking US what needed to be checked, because they had no idea what we did.
I'm not sure that has changed much, frankly. It was a solution to a non problem. There has now been total function creep and inspections are a farce.
No, I wouldn't give feedback. I do not believe that anyone would listen unless it fulfilled at pre existing prejudice. Sorry.

Grannymoz Wed 13-Apr-16 10:07:57

My elderly father has dementia and it took me some time to find the right home for him. The first one was awful, he went missing more than once, always looked scruffy and whatever I bought him disappeared after one wash despite having his name in. At one point they were responsible for taking their own washing to the laundry room - hello,he is old and can't remember anything! The last straw was when the bone idle 'carers' replaced all his underwear with an.old ladies knickers. Unfortunately I was scared to complain too much in case it impacted further on him which I think bothers many people. Thankfully the new home is much nicer

ZaneGransnet (GNHQ) Tue 12-Apr-16 13:13:52

Hi all,
CQC just wanted to address the issue of confidentiality which some posters have mentioned. Here's their response below:

We will treat all the information you give us in confidence.
There may be times when we need to share it with others, such as when:

· we believe someone is at risk of harm

· a crime has been committed

· another organisation needs to take action to ensure the safety and quality of care.

To read more about our privacy statement: www.cqc.org.uk/sites/default/files/documents/20121105_code_of_practice_on_cpi.pdf

grannyactivist Sun 10-Apr-16 22:52:11

My mother is in End of Life care and has received very good care in her home from a team comprised of her GP; community nurses; Macmillan nurse; social worker and care workers. I have written to her team to thank them and also left a message on the 'feedback' portal on the GP's website.

When mum was in hospital she was a very difficult patient and most of the team dealt with her with patience and good humour, but there were many times when she felt very isolated and alone. With limited resources I don't see what good complaining about the latter would do.

TRACYLC Sun 10-Apr-16 18:43:41

My Dad was in hospital for two months at the end of his life. I found his care was as good as the staff that were working on that day. There was one nurse in particular who treated him like a person, he spoke to Dad and they had regular banter. He didnt mind how many times my Dad needed help and always spoke to us when we went to visit. He even came to Dads funeral, bless him. Some nurses, especially the night nurses, gave medication without speaking to Dad properly. He unfortunately got confused and the staff didnt have the time or patience to help him. I find it strange that prisoners in jail are force fed, if they refuse to eat, but no one would help my Dad eat or drink in hospital. Then he had to be placed on a drip because he got dehydrated.

If my Dad was staying in our local hospital (which is still standing and quite new, but shut down) then his family could have spent much more time with him, which would ultimately have helped the staff too.

I would just like to add that most of the staff did exceptionally well under very difficult circumstances.

weather Sun 10-Apr-16 11:57:49

my mum is in a home has been for a great many years.
Since it was taken over from the council years ago things deteriorated and I have too many complaints to list.
I am constantly bringing these to the attention of the home and social services who pay for her care.
Some times I prove these complaints but I don't feel enough was done.
At one review I challenged what was being said by another care person only minutes before on my entering the home ...in the end I asked for the person to come to answer my questions...the care worker at the review did go off to find him never to return, only a message to say he was in a meeting...So the review was never finished we were left in my mother's room waiting until the social worker left!!!!
At the moment social services seem to be doing something to help and a very pleasant person is dealing with it all and ringing me to keep me informed.
I went up in December to sort it out, and it is now April, but I do believe they are over loaded with work and with few other places to put their clients and under great pressure trying to please their client and relatives within the law, so I do try to understand.
I would like my 95 year old mother moved to a home nearby so that I can visit her often and keep an eye on her care.... she says she wants to die there and doesn't want to move ..although I do tell her its a residendial home not a nursing home which she needs ...but there is the county border to consider as well as higher home care fees along with legal restrictions, no power of attorney, and "has she got capacity" which is proving to be a nightmare.
I feel so guilty about not visiting her often as she asks me too when I do go the 60 miles, but I am now older than she was when she went into the home. It is so frustrating.
I did put a message into the CQC many years ago, not an official complaint as I was worried it might backfire on my mum and her care.

mimicat1 Sun 10-Apr-16 02:47:26

Personally I would never give feedback because it will and is held against you and is thus a very dangerous thing to do. In the case of my mother I can only hope that alzheimers has rendered her sufficiently immune. There is a saying "It's a grand life if you don't weaken" never a truer word.
The word care appears to have disappeared from the vocabulary of this country services are being deliberately run down, but anyone who believes private care is any better is deluding themselves all it does is deplete your assets and take the home you managed to secure in your working life.
Suffice to say don't get ill and if you do make your own arrangements for a dignified end.

Annie29 Sat 09-Apr-16 20:48:29

Would think one reason for people not sharing on social media is the fact it's a very personal subject.
Confess I have not given any feedback, would not know the correct official place to do so.Think official place to leave feedback could be publicised more widely.

sammyislost Sat 09-Apr-16 20:42:27

I've been lucky enough only to have positive experiences that I am ready to gush about on social media. I think people do tend to appreciate feedback, whether good or bad, and from friends or those well trusted is important.

williamsgwynfa Sat 09-Apr-16 16:44:45

After Christmas, my Aunt who is suffering from Alzheimer's became a resident of a very reputable care home. The home had been recommended to us by other members in the parish of my Aunt's local Church, and has proved to have been an excellent choice.
The staff at the home are well trained and the care given is consistently of a high standard. My Aunt is looked after, and is cared for with respect, gentleness, kindness, understanding and compassion.
For me it is very hard to criticize the care givers, because when anyone leaves their loved one in a vulnerable place or environment, it is because they need the extra time and help which because of work commitments or other reasons we as a family could not give my Aunt.
What other options are available to them?
The staff at the care home that my Aunt resides at do an extremely difficult job and take a pride in their work. I do believe however, that they are not paid enough for the job that they do in my humble opinion.
Thank you

Direne3 Sat 09-Apr-16 16:20:03

We are an older couple who attempt to be as independent as possible and try to keep out of our doctor's surgery if we can only seeking treatment when really necessary (apart that is from annual nurse reviews that are required for a couple of chronic conditions of mine).
With our surgery's system one can no longer ring and book an appointment. However, a call to reception will trigger a response from our own doctor (usually) within a couple of hours, who then either offers advice or in most cases has fit us in later that same day. When the system first came into effect we were somewhat apprehensive but now find that the days of sitting in a crowded waiting room with those troubled by coughs, colds, infections, etc. seem to have been all but eliminated (must be healthier for the staff too). We really hope that we will have the good fortune for this situation to continue and that we can care for ourselves in future years.
There have been odd occasions when something relatively minor occurs when we don't feel that things have been dealt with quite as we would have wished or deemed wise but are reluctant to sour relations between us and the surgery staff - I think this is the case with many older people.

Direne3 Sat 09-Apr-16 16:09:18

We are an older couple who attempt to be as independent as possible and try to keep out of our doctor's surgery if we can only seeking treatment when really necessary (apart that is from annual nurse reviews that are required for a couple of chronic conditions of mine).
With our surgery's system one can no longer ring and book an appointment. However, a call to reception will trigger a response from our own doctor (usually) within a couple of hours, who then either offers advice or in most cases has fit us in later that same day. When the system first came into effect we were somewhat apprehensive but now find that the days of sitting in a crowded waiting room with those troubled by coughs, colds, infections, etc. seem to have been all but eliminated (must be healthier for the staff too). We really hope that we will have the good fortune for this situation to continue and that we can care for ourselves in future years.

paulinecnd Sat 09-Apr-16 14:17:52

My father died in 2010 . He was in a EMI nursing home outside of Dorking (village name begins with the letter W) for some time suffering from Alzheimer's . Having worked as a registered nurse in a care home elsewhere, I was probably more able than my family to see this home's bad points. I didn't complain because I knew my Mother would be unhappy about me doing so.
One of the nurses said right in front of Dad that he was incapable of knowing or understanding anything and did not know what food was anymore. I was really cross but again said nothing.
The lounge area was very uninviting and no effort seemed to be made to engage the clients in activities or conversation.
Yes, I should have complained but didn't.

crun Sat 09-Apr-16 14:09:51

The Patients Association haven’t described the complaint system as dishonest for no reason, it’s because that’s the way it was designed from the outset. Hansard spills the beans: when the Parliamentary & Health Service Ombudsman was first set up in 1967 Parliament decided that a fair and honest system would make the government a hostage to fortune, so instead they opted for a system that was described as a “fraud” in order to con the public into thinking that their complaints would get a fair hearing. The reality is that by their own admission the PHSO rejects 99% of all complaints, 98% of them without even investigating.

“The Bill was always drafted to be a swiz, and now it is spelt into the Bill…………Anyone who contemplates an office of this kind is faced with the dilemma of making it either a Frankenstein or a nonentity—a Frankenstein if it has effective powers and a nonentity if it has not. The Government, quite rightly, has opted for its being a nonentity, and in that sense it is a fraud……… I congratulate the Government on its being a nonentity. A Frankenstein would, I think, have undermined the power of Ministers......”

Hansard, 24th January 1967

savvynanny Sat 09-Apr-16 13:38:55

The CQC simply doesn't work , A few years ago I was working in a Nursing home, unknown to me it wasn't even registered neither was the owner , she had no qualifications at all . I worked days and one day after a long weekend I went back to work , to find one of the old residents tied to a radiator she had burns all down her side where she had been held by bindings against it ( apparently she was making too much trouble and wandering out of her room ) . I rang for an ambulance and only after the lady had been taken from the building did I leave . I wrote down everything I had seen , made some observations about the way the home was run and then took everything to the CQC . I then gave them a verbal statement . I resigned from my job the CQC didn't actually find the owner guilty of anything The result ..The old lady died in hospital as a result of her injuries . The owner of the Home turned it into a Bed and Breakfast , all the remaining residents moved to accredited Nursing homes . I was unable to get a job in the next nursing home I applied in , not because I didn't have the necessary qualifications , but because I had been a Whistle Blower .

Lorelei Sat 09-Apr-16 12:44:24

I will often leave feedback when given the option to do so, but, sad to say, this is rarely positive feedback on great services as nearly every time I try to access a service there are problems. I often feel filling out feedback forms is just a waste of time as nothing changes and if anything I fear that my next appointment will be even worse if I have left negative comments and/or complaints. Everything from being messed about with appointment times, turning up to be told it is cancelled/running late, or doctors/consultants that just don't listen, don't act, don't seem to care. For example, my two most recent visits to hospital were just a waste of my days. I was kept waiting for hours on both. The first of these two appointments and the doctor left me in a chair for 20 minutes, ignoring me, checking his computer and discussing on the phone another patient, then dismissing me like a naugthy schoolchild! The second appointment I got about 60 seconds to voice my case, was totally ignored and ushered out of the door with the comment "well, you seem to be OK as maintaining weight" (I weighed 5 stone give or take a pound or two) - I look awful, feel worse and just wanted to cry that any doctor thinks a woman my age at this weight is 'OK' - I'm not - I'm seriously concerned about my health - I do not have an eating disorder (another terrible assumption that is thrown at me like an accusation). No action is ever taken, no letters receive a reply, and I am still ill but at a loss of how to get any help. This is just a small example - every time is a horror story - it is hard enough for me to get to a hospital or the doctor and long-term limbo is a bad place to be - very depressing.