Gransnet forums

AIBU

My grandson Harry

(30 Posts)
Aka Mon 30-Jun-14 16:36:27

Tanith is correct. Harry is old enough for his views and wishes to be taken into consideration.

rosequartz Mon 30-Jun-14 16:34:12

You say your DD has recently met her partner and is to be married soon. He will not have had time to build up a relationship with Harry, added to which Harry would have to change schools presumably part way through his GCSE years.

Why does this man think it would be better? I would be somewhat wary if he started making demands and trying to control other people's lives; after all he can scarcely know any of you well enough to judge. (But then I have never been any good at being told what I should or should not do, so other people may look at this completely differently.)

tanith Mon 30-Jun-14 16:29:19

Harry is old enough for his own views to be considered , how does he feel about the situation? I don't think he could be forced to do something he doesn't want to do, have they even asked him?

Elegran Mon 30-Jun-14 16:27:35

There is nothing intrinsicly wonderful about living with a parent, when he has spent most of his life so far mostly with grandparents, and his sisters are living with you.

Are you officially the guardians of these grandchildren or is it an unofficial arrangement?

And does he seem a man with whom Harry could form a father-son relationship? Does he want to see more of Harry's sisters too, or is it just Harry?

I wonder why the new partner says Harry "should live with a parent" and not that he would like to have Harry to live with him and your daughter? That would be a more direct way of suggesting it.

It sounds very negative - as thought he does not think that Harry should live with you. How do you get on with him in general?

susie2907 Mon 30-Jun-14 16:12:28

Harry has lived with us, his grandparents, on and off for most of his 14 soon to be 15yrs. His mum and dad divorced, acrimoniously, almost 10yrs ago. His mother has recently met her new partner and is to be married in Aug this year.His dad remarried almost 7yrs ago and has had little contact. My daughters new partner has persuauded my daughter that Harry should live with a parent, and it is to be Harry's choice, except.....he can only choose between his mum or his dad. which will mean a school change either way, his older sisters live with us, they are both over 18. I dont want to upset his mum, but feel this is unreasonable. HELP I NEED SOME FEEDBACK, thanks x