Gransnet forums

AIBU

A and E admissions

(178 Posts)
NanKate Sun 28-Dec-14 21:30:24

I am worried that if any of my family needed A and E especially at a weekend that they could be held up with the medical staff dealing with binge drinkers.

Do you agree that anyone being treated for alcohol abuse should be penalised in some way ?

What suggestions do you have?

crun Mon 12-Jan-15 14:01:02

"Crun, you are basing what you say on a theory stated in 1954 and repeated by the same man in 1984. Slightly out of date, I would have thought. In 1984 I do not think any sort of triage existed."

Out of date? Myers was published in 2004, with more references than just Meehl. What are you suggesting has happened in the last 60 (30) years? The human brain hasn't suddenly developed the ability to memorise and retrieve the whole of medical science on demand, complete with associated probabilities. As far as I can see, the obvious development is that computers will now process in a fraction of a second statistics that would have then taken an age to compute manually, and do it without bias. The point at issue is not whether triage existed in 1984, but that statistical prediction has been shown to outperform expert opinion about 95% of the time.

Eloethan Mon 12-Jan-15 14:50:22

absent Do people generally have some sort of insurance scheme? Is it compulsory to have health insurance? What happens when people are unemployed or retired?