To wish my DD's 'friend' had just kept her mouth shut?

AshTree I hope your DD feels reassured after she's seen the obstetrician. I think the 'Conspiracy of Silence' is apt for many young new mums whose friends and family see no need to dwell on what can go wrong or how much pain to expect. I renember the midwives reassuring me that it's a feeling of intense pressure and that's a good sign labour is progressing, which my niece-in-law, a busy midwife, maintains today. I still maintain it f*****g hurts!! But anyway, there's pain relief. Inductions for all my children went well and I found (and others have said, too) my thinking changed as labour began and I was preoccupied with having my babies delivered quickly and safely. We'll look forward to hearing your good news when the baby is born.

I totally agree with you about people telling horror stories to scare an already vulnerable woman, pregnant with hormones all over the place.

She doesn't need to hear that.

You are spot on.

Oh Lord, Stansgran, what a horrible story you had to hear from your MiL! No, don't worry, I will keep this thread from my DD!

Update: she managed to get in touch with her obstetrician today and has an appointment to see her first thing on Wednesday to discuss her worries. So I shall be up at the crack of dawn again to take her to the hospital . But I'm pleased she'll get the chance to either a) have her fears allayed, or b) change her birthing plan to c-section. I'll be happy with whatever she feels happiest about.

All my DM would ever say about childbirth was "it's like a bad do on the toilet". We had taken my MIL to Edinburgh to see my DH get his degree and she felt the need to tell me unasked in graphic detail about her third child whose birth was thoroughly mismanaged with crushed skull etc etc. there is always someone who revels in horror stories. Don't let DD see this thread.

That was very thoughtless of the friend to say all that to someone awaiting a birth.
The medics do need to honest about all the risks and possibilities but to create more anxiety in someone is not helpful.
All I got with my first baby was that the head hadn't engaged and looking at the results of an xray it was possible that I probably would require a C section. You just need to know the facts not other peoples "horror stories".

Even planned c sections can go wrong so they're not always the best choice either. DIL had planned section (for medical reasons) in February but epidural didn't seem to be working too well despite a top up, so she unexpectedly ended up with a general anaesthetic. It's also major abdominal surgery so not something to undergo if you can avoid it..

As we all know there's no rhyme or reason to childbirth, no idea how each labour will progress. I hope your Dd's anxieties can be lessened and that all goes well for her AshTree.

Maybe the friend was trying to point out that it's better to have a planned c section rather than an emergency one and not to leave it too late if that appears to be happening? I was relieved to hear that my DIL agreed to have a c section when things weren't happening as planned rather than carry on trying when she was exhausted.

I was induced twice and had no problems at all. Both babies born fine and well no forceps and no trauma. Hope all goes well for your DD.

Oh and thanks for sharing your positive experiences of induction. I will tell her

Yes janea I will definitely be gently encouraging her to make the phone calls tomorrow. I don't want her worrying about this all by herself. She said today that she should stop being so neurotic, that she should 'man up'. Brave words, but inside I know she'll be anxious

ashtree your DD should definitely seek reassurance from her midwife or obstetrician - I'm assuming that for an induction, an obstetrician would be involved. That's what the professionals are there for, and they would much rather deal with someone who was confident and relaxed than someone who was tense and anxious because some spiteful person had wound them up.

You can tell your DD that two of my three deliveries were induced, and were very straightforward.
The one I went into labour with naturally had to be delivered with forceps.

I do hope all goes well for your DD.

I'm not sure about any 'conspiracy of silence' AshTree, I think it was more the case that women just got on with it and didn't feel the need to tell all and sundry about their delivery problems.

These days it seems to be compulsory to share the most intimate details, if not in person then on FB - it's a sort of one-upmanship.
(or should that be one-upwomanship? )

She does need to talk to her midwife - that is what they are there for.

Isn't there always someone around who loves to spread alarm and despondency? Sigh. Poor lass.

By 'only these two ways', I meant a vaginal birth or caesarian section. Induction isn't standard, though it leads to a vaginal birth.

FarNorth, fair point, but then what if she had another friend whose c-section had gone horribly wrong? Forewarned may be forearmed, but you can't change your mind about childbirth - it has to come out one way or the other. And there are only those two ways. Two friends forewarning her about each of these methods isn't exactly going to help!

Yes, Lilygran I think she should, mainly to get some reassurance. Unfortunately her midwife is very difficult to get hold of, so this may not be a solution. I did suggest she speak to her GP if she can't get hold of her midwife.
When we were having our babies, all those years ago, we didn't have Google, we didn't have One Born Every Minute, and we didn't talk so openly and in such gory detail, not even to our friends. There seemed to be a sort of compassionate 'conspiracy of silence' where the pain of childbirth was concerned - a sisterhood who cared enough about each other not to frighten the uninitiated half to death. How things have changed

To be fair to the friend, she may have felt she needed to warn your DD. After all, if she said nothing and then your DD had the same problems, how would that be?

Unfortunately the world is full of people who love to spread alarm, Ashtree. You have my sympathy. Do you think the best thing would be for your DD to contact her midwife and tell her what she's worried about?