Gransnet forums

AIBU

I still get irritated by this - AIBU to hate being referred to as a 'girl'...

(280 Posts)
Carolghill Sun 30-Apr-17 17:35:35

Okay. At church today a rather nice chap came up to a friend of mine to say hi. Nice. But he said 'Hi Girls'. My friend is 50 and I'm coming up to 65. I just said nicely - X,,, I am not a girl - I am a woman. He looks nonplussed. He says he means it as a compliment that we look good still!

Hmm.

I pointed out that at almost 65 I am NOT a girl. I am a woman.

He is nice. He just looked surprised. But to me being referred to as 'girl' infantises me, makes me less of an adult, puts me at a lower status ... Yukkity yuk yuk. Have we not achieved anything?!

Sorry. Rant over.

Caro1954 Mon 01-May-17 22:23:57

Really sorry but what does AIBU stand for? confused

chickenlegs Mon 01-May-17 22:16:17

A man I was with referred to TV newsreaders and said, "They're nearly all girls now". I objected and told him they are women not girls. He doesn't like the word "women", they must be called girls or ladies. He is patronising, there's no other word for it.

BonnieBlooming Mon 01-May-17 21:16:22

Honestly some people on this forum must get up especially early to get as much annoyed as possible into the day. The things people object too! Sounds like grumpy old women to me.

Ana Mon 01-May-17 21:04:35

The word 'chap' is simply not a term I've ever been familiar with. I'm not objecting to it, it just seems rather an olden-day word.

Suzisue Mon 01-May-17 21:03:27

I don't personally mind being referred to as a 'girl' but what annoys me is when I get letters referring to me as Ms. My marital status is no business of anyone else's but mine. My thoughts are if you don't know don't put anything!

Ana Mon 01-May-17 21:00:50

Someone further back did mention 'madam', but it was included in the list of names she didn't mind at all being called smile

Jalima1108 Mon 01-May-17 20:59:33

Mesdames?
or they could be mesdemoiselles
Who knows?
The OP doesn't say

Marmark1 Mon 01-May-17 20:58:09

As someone said,we are all different,so it's impossible to win isn't it,your bound to upset somebody.
I say to hell with it,as long as you know in your heart of hearts you meant no offence,and you know you are being polite if a person wants to be offended that's their problem,sad little things.

Christinefrance Mon 01-May-17 20:57:51

One of my secret wishes was to be a ' Madam ' naughty I know but such fun ! ! smile

Indigoblue Mon 01-May-17 20:47:29

Has anyone suggested using the term "madam"? If they haven't it might be because, like me, they'd been called a "proper little madam" when they were a child. And I have to admit that I frequently was a "proper little madam"!

thatbags Mon 01-May-17 20:32:41

Dude is good too.

thatbags Mon 01-May-17 20:32:06

I love the word chap. There's a chippiness (beef fat fried, natch) about it and, like guys nowadays, one can use it of chappesses as well.

And there's chapping in dominoes
and chapping on doors,
chapped lips (not good)
or knees! believe it or not
in my first year at uni
cos my 'duffer' coat wasn't long enough
and Dundee's a darn sight chillier
than the Fylde.

Ana Mon 01-May-17 20:06:52

I agree about 'chap' Maggie.

rosesarered Mon 01-May-17 19:55:48

Yes, it's all about the context isn't it? It seems to me that in this case the man thought he was being friendly and that's all.

Maggiemaybe Mon 01-May-17 19:29:43

Well, if "ladies" sounds like something from the 50s, what on earth is "chap" about? grin Where I come from, people are still sometimes addressed as pet. In some languages, you'd just be addressed as auntie or grandma. Frankly, if someone's being friendly and not meaning to offend, I couldn't care less.

Christinefrance Mon 01-May-17 19:27:29

I dislike being labelled elderly too kitty, 60 is young for that. Seems like we all have different levels of tolerance.

annodomini Mon 01-May-17 19:17:07

I prefer 'girls' to 'ladies' but the gentleman (is that patronising?) in question should be advised in future to stick to gender-neutral greeting - 'Hello everyone', for example. I once had a boyfriend (long long ago) who called me 'babe', which I loathed but made allowances for his being American.

123kitty Mon 01-May-17 18:44:56

Haha- called a girl's fine, but I hate reading in the newspaper: "elderly 60 year old pensioner...." why does paper need to use the word elderly?

magwis Mon 01-May-17 18:34:18

Speaking to a senior at work I used the term "new boy" of a new colleague. Was asked not to call him that by senior. As a group of receptionists we were called "the girls". Two sets of rules??

Bluegayn58 Mon 01-May-17 18:33:37

We are all different, and therefore have different feelings. Sometimes, however, it might be best to just let it go over your head.

LadyGaGa Mon 01-May-17 18:25:17

Makes my blood boil too! The doctor at work will say ' the girls will do it for you' meaning the group of mature nurses, with years of experience between us. How belittling. Call us what we are - nurses, family, ladies! Anything but girls!

kittylester Mon 01-May-17 18:18:23

I think I have just managed to read most of this thread and I am more offended by the women who think they can tell me that the way I think is wrong. How dare they. angry

Ana Mon 01-May-17 18:05:42

Sorry, Lewlew, missed the OP's second post.

Jalima1108 Mon 01-May-17 17:59:13

forgot

Jalima1108 Mon 01-May-17 17:58:25

ps I foregot to say he gave me a hug as he said 'stout girl'

did that make it better?