Gransnet forums

AIBU

to be asked to contribute?

(85 Posts)
granoffour Thu 08-Feb-18 12:01:45

I have recently joined a local bookclub - only one meet-up so far . Everyone seems very nice (there are about 8-10 of us). All new faces to me even though I've been in the area for a few years now. The one lady is moving to Spain next week so I got an email from one of the women asking to contribute £15 towards her leaving gift. I've only met her once and haven't had more than a brief chat. I rely on my pension and I don't have a lot of spare cash. I wouldn't object if she was a friend of course but I don't want to cause bad feeling though as I've just joined the group. It's a bit awkward. Any ideas on how I should handle this?

albertina Fri 09-Feb-18 10:57:59

I feel sorry for you in this predicament. I'm with the folk who suggest ignoring it.

I had to leave a book group I joined because they were all very wealthy people. Each meeting was in someone's home and the hostess had to provide food and good quality drinks for up to 16 people. I just couldn't afford to do that. It's a shame as I did enjoy it.

lemongrove Fri 09-Feb-18 10:54:42

If a round robin, just ignore it.If a personal note to you, say you don’t know this lady but will contribute something (£5.) for the goodwill, and sign her card.

Barmeyoldbat Fri 09-Feb-18 10:51:43

I would neither give a penny or explain myself

Kim19 Fri 09-Feb-18 10:41:36

I'm in the fortunate position of actually being able to afford £15 but I would not give a penny. You've met this lady once and had the merest of conversations? No brainer. My verbal best wishes and nothing else. If for any reason I had to re-address the matter (and I sincerely hope not) with the gift organiser I would simply say 'sorry, but I've already decided on my gift but thank you for including me'. Blimey!

Craftycat Fri 09-Feb-18 10:41:04

I expect it was a 'round robin'- no-one would expect you to contribute after only one session.

seacliff Fri 09-Feb-18 10:34:22

I would ignore it too. I would not mention it all unless someone asks you directly.

jangeo44 Fri 09-Feb-18 10:30:29

That is a ridiculous amount to contribute to someone you have only met once. Don't be put under pressure and do what you feel comfortable with - especially if the others have known her for much longer - even so you should feel free to do what you want.

W11girl Fri 09-Feb-18 10:22:41

Oh dear! No way would I give £15 for a leaving gift for someone I don't know regardless of my income. Politely tell them your pension won't stretch that far rather than get into other difficulties. If they don't like it and they ask you to leave, I hope they will each be just as generous with you and proffer £15 per head towards your leaving gift!

Witzend Fri 09-Feb-18 10:12:53

£15 is IMO ridiculous.
There were several leaving- collections at work before I retired not all that long ago, and a fiver was considered plenty, even for people we knew quite well. Anyone particularly friendly with them might give more - IF they could afford it. But it was never expected, still less demanded.

Butterflykisses Fri 09-Feb-18 10:08:45

I would imagine the email was a round-robin one for all the members of the group. I'm sure none of them would expect you to contribute so much after such a short acquaintance. A carefully chosen bookmark or a couple of pounds would be fair in my view. Explain if you feel you should, but please don't feel under pressure. x

Nanny123 Fri 09-Feb-18 09:54:29

I hate it when collections do the rounds and you are asked to give a certain amount. Peoples financial situations can vary so much - you should be asked to contribute what you feel is appropriate for you

Fran0251 Fri 09-Feb-18 09:51:55

Was it a "round robin" request, just sent to the whole group without much thought? In which case the advice above is right and appropriate and you wouldn't be expected to contibute much, if any.

Sparklefairydust Fri 09-Feb-18 09:49:34

I would expect it's an email that just got sent to everyone, I would either just ignore it or reply saying you've only just joined and so don't feel able to contribute, I think anyone would understand that. It is a lot of money though even if you had been there a while.

harrysgran Fri 09-Feb-18 09:47:03

I know how you feel where I work we are often asked to contribute to presents for those I hardly know .I am on a small income compared to other colleagues so I either just give what I can afford or if it's someone I know well I buy my own small gift .Don't stress about it if these people don't accept this then maybe it says a lot about the type of people they are.

maur59 Fri 09-Feb-18 09:39:40

I would just give a card

BlueBelle Thu 08-Feb-18 14:18:30

I totally agree Hurdygurdy my feelings also

HurdyGurdy Thu 08-Feb-18 14:14:26

And I don't think you should be justifying why you can't/won't donate or if you do choose to donate, justifying the amount you give.

HurdyGurdy Thu 08-Feb-18 14:12:50

Blimey - I must be tighter than tight. If I'd only met her once, and had no more than a brief chat with her, I wouldn't be contributing anything at all.

Not wishing to sound unkind, but she would mean nothing to me, and wouldn't leave any kind of a gap by not being there.

It would be different if I'd known her for a long time. But even then I think £15 for a leaving present is a lot. Donations should be voluntary and only what the donor wishes to give.

BlueBelle Thu 08-Feb-18 14:00:40

Even in an established group I wouldn’t give £15 and for someone I d only met once for a brief chat I m afraid I would ignore it totally surely with most ‘group buys’ it’s either left to you to put what you can in or given a small token amount like £2 or £5 at the most
I certainly wouldn’t give her a personal card and/or gift as you don’t know her at all

OldMeg Thu 08-Feb-18 13:55:06

Just ignore the request.

Nonnie Thu 08-Feb-18 13:46:04

I agree. Either ignore it and they can assume what they like or explain why you don't feel you can contribute so much.

If you ignore it and someone chases you then simply explain why you don't feel £15 is appropriate and that you would rather do a small thing yourself than contribute less than the others as that would be unfair to those who had contributed the full amount. No one could object to that but they might to you giving less than everyone else.

I'll bet you are not alone.

Luckygirl Thu 08-Feb-18 13:27:24

I agree that £15 is a lot, even if you knew her better and had been in the group for a while. It would have been better to just ask for contributions rather than setting a figure.

I do think you should just say that you are happy to give £x as finances are tight and leave it at that.

What a peculiar position for you to find yourself in.

Squiffy Thu 08-Feb-18 13:23:26

I'm really shock at the amount requested, even if you'd been a member for a longer time! It would be far more diplomatic and sensitive to have a collection bag/box/whatever and let people donate the amount they wish. Even long-term members may feel rather ambushed!

ninny Thu 08-Feb-18 13:12:50

Perhaps the email went out to all the members of the book club automatically. Just ignore it.

Charleygirl Thu 08-Feb-18 13:03:59

That is a ridiculous sum of money requested even if you had known her a while. I do not see why you contribute anything other than maybe a card especially as you have never had any dealings with her.