Topics ,star ratings, a good idea ?

You make huge assumptions Bridgeit or do you have a list of everyone's academic achievements?

So, lightheartedly, I would see the OP to this thread and give it 3 stars. I would do that not from knowledge but from experience on here. As you posted it I imagine you would not see it that way. Whose view were you intending to use for your system?

There is so much I don't know about but I assume I will always be able to learn more from others and, where I can, offer anything that I do know. (I have a nice little video I made on how do crocheted loop stitch if anyone needs it).

I also like the fact that others reference people who are more knowledgeable in certain fields than any of us. I wonder why you set out expecting to know everything before the discussion takes place?

What did you miss about ‘slightly tongue in cheek’your replies are exactly the reason I ‘ lightheartedly ‘ suggested it?

I’m really about this thread. GN isn’t just an opinions forum - there are some threads where facts and knowledge actually matter a great deal and others where experience is what counts. Then others where posts are based on opinion. Not all opinions are going to be subject to criticism but if they are, then it’s on the content not the style of delivery surely?

One would hope so,but sadly that is not the case, they know who they are & assumedly must enjoy doing it!

What did you miss about ‘slightly tongue in cheek’your replies are exactly the reason I ‘ lightheartedly ‘ suggested it

I didn't miss anything Bridgeit. I just can't see anything lighthearted in it. Take that out and what do we have?

We would not have the original post !

Just like to say I won’t be posting any more views on this topic , as I have been reported to GN.

I honestly thought this was a lighthearted thread. A bit of fun
I remember others suggesting thumbs up and thumbs downs, likes and dislikes .... what’s the difference? I can’t believe anyone has reported the OP .... and what for? I really can’t understand it.

Thanks Gillybob, so did I , you don’t need to look far to know who,perhaps she would like to openly confirm this.

Quite agree, gillybob

A lighthearted, tongue-in-cheek opener by Bridgeit has, unwittingly, caused some serious input, to the extent of reporting.

Gosh! God forbid a bit of fun on GN. ?

?Thankyou

Oh dear. A little while ago I (non-seriously) suggested markings for
Be kind only
Open to opinion
Give it to me straight

And was totally ignored.
Think I got off lightly now

The heavy hand of censorship has fallen.
Gransnet used to be a place for laughter and warmth, but they are being gradually squeezed out by humourless gloom.

Perhaps one could even star responses

PLEASE STOP THIS

Oh for goodness sake - there’s plenty of laughter and warmth on GN and daily example of support and kindness. There’s also robust political deabate where people are disagreed with - just grow up some of you. I think there are some posters who won’t be happy unless all political discussion is banned - it’s not a private club, it’s a forum where anyone can post within the guidelines.

Gosh. I read the opening thread and assumed it was meant to be joky (is that a word?) It's obviously taken a very serious downward turn. You never can tell with some threads (except the political ones she said bravely)

Well I read it and thought it was goady - you never can tell can you? ?

I thought it was meant to be joky too, Jane Heaven knows most social media could have similar stars.

Well there you go - a difference of opinion which is allowed.

Bridgeit of courseit is (was!) a light hearted thread, but some have no sense of humour whatsoever!
I like the 4th gillybob and I suggest a 5th ‘tin hats at the ready*

And a 6th....’to be read only with a large G&T in hand’

If you say so lemon you are always right aren’t you? ?

Think I’ll leave the snowflakes to melt now

We certainly need more light hearted threads on GN.