I never said ‘what a brat’ did I? So those who think I did need to look again.
And where did I say anything ‘dogmatic’ mcen I think you will find I use the words ‘some’ and ‘certain younger people’ which is actually the opposite. Your post reminded me of a little Jack Russell I know, snappy and ready to bite at the least provocation that’s what was amusing.
There are two opposite poles of opinions on here. Those who think the child isn’t to blame and those who think him a ‘brat’.
What I’ve bern saying all along is that the child will never learn manners if he is not shown that his behaviour is not acceptable. And there are ways of doing that which are appropriate for his age and personality and, if need be, take account of any behavioural issues he might be exhibiting.
For instance had I said to GS1 at that age ‘how rude!’ that would have been enough to pull him up and make him think. And I’d have then explained to him how upsetting his behaviour was and asked him to apologise. Taking the same tactic with GS2 might not have been as effective and, when he did something very similar, I requisitioned the gift for myself. These are only examples and possibly not very good ones at that!
If it was my rather sensitive GD (who actually wouldn’t have done that) I’d have taken an entirely different approach.
So the point is, manners do matter, but there are ways of teaching them dependent on the child. Simply ignoring bad behaviour is often condoning it, unless there is a very good reason for doing so (and sometimes there are).