Gransnet forums

AIBU

Easter has been hijacked

(91 Posts)
Floradora9 Sun 01-Apr-18 11:01:30

When I was a child the only thing making it different was decorating eggs and rolling them . If I was lucky it was in a park if not at home . I cannot even remember getting an Easter egg . Now I see mothers making large boxes of different gifts plus loads of chocolate. Lamb seems to be the meal you have to eat and the nation is going mad having just got over Christmas and Mother's day .
The postcode lottery had a post on Facebook asking people what they would be doing this Easter including things like eating chocolate , shopping etc. I replied asking why they had not included going to church . They replied that there were so many options they could have chosen. Do they not know why we celebrate Easter ? How many children know why we roll our eggs or buy chocolate eggs ? You do not have to be a Christian to know what this celebration is all about .

MissAdventure Sun 01-Apr-18 23:02:52

I was wondering that.

grumppa Sun 01-Apr-18 22:58:39

Why are the atheists being lumped together with pagans?

Alexa Sun 01-Apr-18 22:50:00

GracesGran is there something impolite about identifying as an atheist? I sometimes do as it's simpler than explaining complex theology.

I thought that the main theme of Casualty last night was a gloss on the Resurrection.

Alexa Sun 01-Apr-18 22:44:50

Yggdrasil wrote:
"Still we do get a public holiday for Beltane, only one month away :-)" I know I little Borders town where there is a Beltane festival.

Bridgeit Sun 01-Apr-18 22:28:16

I agree wholeheartedly with your post Blugal.

Bridgeit Sun 01-Apr-18 22:16:04

Ohh Monica you have just added another date & celebration I wasn’t aware of . I need to get reading.

Esspee Sun 01-Apr-18 22:09:26

The term for this is syncretism.

Bluegal Sun 01-Apr-18 22:08:58

I agree everyone should celebrate any festival any way they wish, but I think the OP was really getting at is the COMMERCIALISM of it all. There is so much bordering on glutony that the simple pleasures that I, for one, experienced at not only Easter but Christmas are being lost. I used to love waking up to chocolate eggs on Easter Sunday and going to church and my grandchildren still do. The only difference now is that THEY get chocolate eggs (kinder, Cadbury's cream eggs) any day of the week all year.

Similarly Christmas is not the same now as they get toys throughout the year. Whereas WE only got toys on birthdays and Christmas. Yes they still enjoy it in their own way but sometimes I cringe at the amount of presents they get. I feel sad for people who have nothing in other parts of the world.. Last year I didn't give any of my children/grandchildren presents - instead I donated to a school in India. Nobody even noticed t.b.h. They still had an abundance of presents, but I think the kids in India would have appreciated a few books and pencils more.

I took two of my grandchildren to church this morning and it was beautiful, so colourful with lots of singing and all the children were given an Easter egg, with beautifully decorated cakes for all with teas/coffees.

Times are changing and I guess we just have to accept it and do what WE want to do Floradora9.

Iam64 Sun 01-Apr-18 22:08:51

Come on folks, it isn’t a competition is it? My faith/athienism/paganism is better than yours.
Easter, spring time - it all symbolises new beginnings, surely an opportunity to love and let live ?

Esspee Sun 01-Apr-18 22:08:11

Happened the other way round M0nica. The Christians took over the Celebration and moved it to the Passover in time.

Bridgeit Sun 01-Apr-18 22:06:28

Thanks for your post Esspee, another interesting element of Easter I was not aware of.

M0nica Sun 01-Apr-18 22:02:04

I assume that all the pagans/ atheists here who wish to return to the pagan festival will start celebrating it on 21 March and not piggybacking on the popular Christian festival that just happens to share the same name.

Esspee Sun 01-Apr-18 21:55:14

I have been delighted to see Easter return to it's original pagan roots over the years. It was a celebration of the reawakening of Spring, Fertility and new life (The name says it all) long before Judaism with it's Passover and Christianity with it's Resurrection ever existed.
The Christian church simply welded it's mythology onto pre existing practices. Easter has much deeper roots.

Bridgeit Sun 01-Apr-18 21:46:38

I have observed that sometimes GG you tie yourself in a complete knot of nonsense.

Anniebach Sun 01-Apr-18 21:46:15

Who on earth has called people names GG?

GracesGranMK2 Sun 01-Apr-18 21:38:25

Because I think that what is happening here is exactly what happens on the political threads Annie. Here, people's beliefs are not known and there their political view is ignored. There they end up being called Corbynistas and here it's atheists.

I don't know about you but I think calling people names just because they don't share someone else's point of view is very in-Christian.

Bridgeit Sun 01-Apr-18 21:38:11

Happily I have just discovered that the origins of Easter Eggs originated as representing the empty tomb of Jesus.

Anniebach Sun 01-Apr-18 21:36:43

here we go again ?

GracesGranMK2 Sun 01-Apr-18 21:32:31

I'm all for live and let live - just as annie is saying. The word "hijacked" in the thread title is a value judgement that seems inappropriate.

Exactly LG, but there are other posts on this thread that are jumping on the "value judgement" bandwagon too. Every time a holiday with some attachment to Christianity comes up we have a particular type of "Christian" who see it as their job to tell everyone what they should be doing. It will happen again, I have no doubt.

Anniebach Sun 01-Apr-18 21:30:58

But why ask who they are GG? You wanted names? Why ?

GracesGranMK2 Sun 01-Apr-18 21:24:40

I just wondered why you were taking a pop at poor old atheists for no apparent reason - very Christian hmm

grumppa Sun 01-Apr-18 21:24:35

Thank you for the interesting link, MiceElf. The notable omission from the list of renditions of Easter in European languages is German: Ostern. This has the same root as our Easter, and according to one respected German authority, Duden, comes from the Old German Auströ, meaning sunrise, which as I see it can symbolise the resurrection or the dawn of a new religion, or just Spring. No gods or goddesses involved

And as an atheist (I feel that the phrase confirmed atheist suggests some sort of ceremony conducted by a kind of Dawkinsian bishop) I have no desire to convert anyone to or from anything. Each to his/her own.

Luckygirl Sun 01-Apr-18 21:19:31

I'm all for live and let live - just as annie is saying. The word "hijacked" in the thread title is a value judgement that seems inappropriate.

Anniebach Sun 01-Apr-18 21:01:01

Why GG?

GracesGranMK2 Sun 01-Apr-18 20:55:29

Who are these atheists Annie?