thanks for that all, it has been such a help. the dogs rarely occupy all the beds, they're either on the sofa with us or or on our bed, they are much loved and have plenty of places for sleep & cuddles. It was very rude and insensitive of hubby, especially since I had suggested putting it in the garage. It was a fabric like a glorious old Sanderson style, and for the fabric addicts like myself, you can make something out of the tiniest scraps! Hubby will find himself presented with a large bill when I find a replacement, & if he does it again I will be moving out, I don't want to live with someone who cannot respect my space. He's just as bad with clutter and we have had a half finished kitchen floor tiling job, living with each others half finished jobs is just one of those things in a busy household I reckon. Thanks so much all!! 