Gransnet forums

AIBU

Rescuing standed Brits

(143 Posts)
Floradora9 Mon 30-Mar-20 18:40:09

The government is about to spend thousands on flight for Brits stranded abroad. I know some people have had no choice in this but some could have made arrangements weeks ago to come home. I heard Simon Calder on the radio say lots of these are young people back packing now wanting to come home . Why should we pay for them to do so ? If I was a parent of one of these young people I would willingly stump up to bring them home .

Blinko Wed 01-Apr-20 22:51:00

Except I think HMG would have had insider/advance information, so not hindsight for them... They chose to let February slide by when they could have been gearing up.

Lizbethann55 Wed 01-Apr-20 15:05:45

Blinko as you say, with hindsight. Wouldn't we all have done a million things differently in our lives if hed had the gift of hindsight.

Bellasnana Wed 01-Apr-20 14:32:41

Yes, GrannyGravy, I’m beside myself worrying about it. It seems things are going to get a lot worse here in the US before they get better, so heaven knows if and when I will get back to Malta.

Also very worried about DD1 who is a radiographer at a hospital in Washington DC as she is working without the proper protective equipment.

Nansnet, I am very happy for you that you managed to get back home.

Katek Wed 01-Apr-20 10:57:07

We have a young family member who is currently in Georgia (country not the US state) and his plan is to just stay put. At last contact with him he said there were only around 50 cases and no deaths, so he was probably as well staying where he is.

notanan2 Wed 01-Apr-20 10:49:06

Yes I dont think that people who chose to follow official advice Vs what was at the time rumour and speculation are necessarily un-sensible types.

That is USUALLY the sensible thing to do.

Blinko Wed 01-Apr-20 10:37:45

Part of the reason people are abroad at this time is down to the Government's initial reluctance to be clear from the start about the potential risks. HMG was at first erring on the side of protecting the economy. With hindsight, it's clear they should have banned travel abroad around two weeks before they actually did. None of this 'advisory' stuff, either. They should have clamped down. Then there would have been less of an issue now.

So certainly people should be brought back.

GrannyLaine Wed 01-Apr-20 08:48:30

My personal view in response to the OP Why should we pay for them to do so ? would be that we can't turn back the clock, people don't always make good decisions. Compassion is the one thing that will get us through this crisis. How could we not pay for them to get home?

GrannyGravy13 Wed 01-Apr-20 06:51:41

Bellasnonna you must be very worried, I do hope you get home before your 90 days are up.

As I said upthread, we are in unprecedented worrying times and wherever possible these U.K. Citizens should be brought home.

Nansnet Wed 01-Apr-20 05:56:29

Three weeks ago, after much deliberation, lots of research, and taking advice from medics, we decided to go ahead with our 'dream holiday' to a country which, at that time, had single digit cases of the virus, and was not on an 'at risk' list of places to travel to. We live, and flew, from a country which seemingly had things well under control, at that time.

Within a few short days of us arriving at our destination, things rapidly changed, and the country went into complete lockdown. No real advanced warning, little time to rearrange flights home, etc. Our return flights would not be operating (although, we had no notification from the airline), and all of our hotels cancelled on us! Thankfully, we were one of the lucky ones who managed to get on one of the last flights out operated by our airline (at our own expense). Tens of thousands of other visitors to that country were not so lucky, and were left stranded, told they had to be in isolation, but had nowhere to stay!

On the day that we flew out, there were many passengers checking in for our flight, who were transit passengers flying back to UK/Europe, only to be told that they could no longer transit, and are basically stuck there! These people tried, and failed, to secure flights home, at the very short notice that was given to them, and at their own expense.

If I could turn the clock back, and knew what I know now, of course I wouldn't have gone. We're home now, doing our required home isolation, and are very thankful that we are safe. We all learn by our mistakes. But there are many thousands of travellers out there who do need help to be repatriated to their home countries, through no fault of their own.

grannybuy Wed 01-Apr-20 01:08:24

I booked flights to NY for October last year with an online travel agent ( via Skyscanner ). Since then, I have received regular emails from them advertising flights and holidays. Just last week they had holidays and flights from as soon as next week. I can't understand how this is possible, seeing as people can't get home, and so many airports and borders closed. I heard through the media that they may still take bookings, then cancel, and offer to conserve the holiday for later, therefore they are not losing the money they have been paid.

Abuelamia Tue 31-Mar-20 19:32:27

Four weeks ago and 24 hours before we were due to fly, we cancelled our trip to Asia. This was our decision and cost us a great deal of money as there was no Government warning in place and the tour company was still going ahead with the tour, so we could not claim on our insurance. But the writing was on the wall, the virus was spreading, we had been looking at the World Health Organisation data and felt it to be the right decision. So glad we did.

jocork Tue 31-Mar-20 18:26:13

Two weeks ago a friend of mine got on a plane at Heathrow but after talking to the stewardess about the situation she decided maybe it was a mistake to go and got off. Back in the airport she got a call to say her trip was being cancelled so just as well she turned back when she did! The rest of the tour group were flying from Gatwick and they were meeting in Germany before going on to Morocco. She had a narrow escape! Lots of people will have made errors of judgement and part of the problem was down to the government delaying so long before locking us down so they do need to give more assistance if people set off based on foreign office advice. People cancelling trips before they were prevented from going ahead have not been able to claim on insurance so many will have gone ahead as they didn't want to lose the cost of their holiday. Now we are seeing the seriousness of the situation, but hindsight is a wonderful thing.

Bellasnana Tue 31-Mar-20 18:06:58

Three weeks ago I came over to the US for my once yearly visit to my two daughters and only granddaughter. At that time nobody advised me not to travel, but soon after I arrived things here in the US started to kick off.

I am now at my daughter’s in Florida. I should be returning to Malta tomorrow, but my flight is cancelled and Malta airport is closed. I contacted the embassy and was told I could get a repatriation flight from Frankfurt tomorrow, but that would mean buying a new ticket from Miami, which I cannot afford, plus risking being in contact with the infection so I will not be taking that option.

My biggest concern now is whether the crisis in the US will extend beyond the beginning of June when my 90 days are up. I have been told in no uncertain terms that should I overstay I will incur a ten year ban from travel to the US. No exceptions.

With hindsight do I wish I hadn’t travelled? Of course I do. If only I had had a crystal ball. I do not expect the government to fork out for my return, just hope I can re-book my flight if and when the airline starts flying again. Very worried indeed.☹️

ALANaV Tue 31-Mar-20 17:48:10

Its a difficult and very different situation to most …...whilst I think it is unreasonable for holiday makers and second home owners to moan about the UK government not repatriating them ..even those who WERE willing to pay for themselves to come back to the UK were unable to due to airports being locked down and no flights available and the host country wanting them out ! If there is a situation of danger or unrest in a foreign country, airlines or Governments act quickly to withdraw British citizens which is fair enough . However, some people who have provided for their own transport etc are suddenly caught up in an unexpected situation which occurred after their arrival, and are then left in limbo. It is easy for us all to say Serves you right, or Why did you go ? but in a lot of cases it is, I am afraid 'There but for fortune' but they do need to pay back the air fares that is only right

notanan2 Tue 31-Mar-20 17:12:05

Other countries are putting those returning into quarantine are we??

Not since our community transmission became a bigger risk than transmission from people who have travelled, no. No point any more. We are one of the risky countries. People coming in from elsewhere no longer pose a greater risk than our own communities

BoBo53 Tue 31-Mar-20 17:06:14

So agree about quarantine for travellers as it seems everyone has been allowed to simply go home since the initial Wuhan flights. Other countries are putting those returning into quarantine are we??

CleoPanda Tue 31-Mar-20 16:42:34

From January the writing was on the wall. Nobody knew when a pandemic was going to be “declared” but it was obvious it was going spread around the world. We decided we didn’t want to be stranded in a foreign country and that losing money on a holiday was preferable to being at risk abroad. We didn’t wait for an airline or holiday company to decide, we looked at the risks and made our own decision. Beats me how people could enjoy travelling so far from home whilst knowing it was so risky. How essential is a holiday compared to being stranded or sick abroad?

Callistemon Tue 31-Mar-20 16:40:39

Autocorrect changed 'trips' to groups
Sorry.

Callistemon Tue 31-Mar-20 16:39:42

Passengers were allowed off a huge cruise ship, the Ruby Princess, in Sydney Harbour and allowed to go off on their interstate flights, onward journeys etc.

I think that was only on the 19th March.
This ship had been cruising between Sydney and New Zealand on several groups, despite several passengers falling ill.

Many have since been diagnosed with the CV19 virus.

Eloethan Tue 31-Mar-20 16:19:49

Oldwoman I can see the appeal of a cruise, especially for older people who have food, entertainment, trips ashore, etc, laid on and have no worries about organising anything.

However, the huge and increasing number of floating towns - with onboard casinos, swimming pools, entertainment centres - one even with a helter skelter I think I read - traversing the globe now has serious implications for the oceanic environment and for the ports at which they dock, and the surrounding areas.

Some people maybe have not thought of this but for those who have but don't care, that's selfish.

Having said that, I think anybody who is stuck abroad and is having great difficulty getting home should be be given assistance to get home. As has been said, the travel agents were as aware as anybody that there were problems in China and the surrounding areas - and so was the government. My understanding is it was only on 23 March that the government advised against travelling abroad.

It is also my understanding that where there are commercial flights available, the government does not intend to step in. I may be wrong but I think the government only charters flights if there is no chance of people having access to a relatively affordable commercial flights.

I am starting to think that on Gransnet there are many people who positively enjoy sitting in judgment of others while they smugly polish their halos.

Lioness68 Tue 31-Mar-20 16:02:32

Well this selfish person has been on two cruises over the years and we were about to book another with Tui in May for our 50th anniversary. That went out of the window within days. We will go away at a later date and probably in this country now.

polnan Tue 31-Mar-20 15:54:52

can`t see that anyone is wondering about all the other foreign nationals not going to their home countries..??just me then?

Labaik Tue 31-Mar-20 15:38:38

Rant accepted. Don't blame you for feeling angry Daisy.

ExD Tue 31-Mar-20 15:38:07

My son was working abroad on a short job and due to return home last week. So yes, I naturally do think he should be repatriated - but that's personal.
I do think people who went on holiday after the virus was obviously going global should have known better, but so should their travel agent - but what do we do? leave them where they are and let them rely on the health service in that country?
Whatever the govt decides to do, its damned if it does and damed if it doesn't.

Daisyboots Tue 31-Mar-20 15:32:34

Can I just put this from another point of view. I agree about many people who were doing a gap year or visiting family in Australia or New Zealand. But this is different.
Portugal were more proactive in closing schools and starting a shut down than the UK. They kept certain flights coming in to allow Portuguese citizens to return home but people mainly in the UK had booked flights and thought it was their right to come for their holiday despite people on the forums telling them to stay at home because everything was closed so they wouldnt have a holiday as they would be self isolating instead. But some still came and it shows in the figures of people bring the virus with them. As at the 28th of March 41 people from the UK have brought the virus into Portugal.
Yet still we have people with flights booked for April which have not yet been cancelled asking the same thing.
Then you have the campervanners who drive south for the winter. Legally they should spend no more than 90 days here just like the people who own holiday homes here. Instead of heading back to the UK or other home country they are looking for places to park up because all camping parks have been closed by the government. They are allowed to drive back to their home country and only need to download a form to drive through France to get to Eurotunnel. But they dont want to do that. They feel they are entitled to stay although, in many cases, are here illegally. The government has told anyone who is not a citizen or resident to leave but they choose to ignore it. Portugal has the lowest number of ICU beds 4.9 per capita in Europe but they would expect to be treated if they fell ill.
Sorry but rant over .