Gransnet forums

AIBU

Updating will

(60 Posts)
Chookcook Wed 07-Apr-21 18:43:46

Hi, I just want to know AIBU. I don't think I am because things change over the years but I'd appreciate others views. This is a very long post I do apologise

My dh and I met in our teens and were on and off until we got into our 40s.
He was a very troubled man and very violent towards me, not the best dad to our two daughters and abused hard drugs and alcohol. I made sure my dd's did not notice this and I protected them throughout our many breakups, marriage, divorce and marriage again.

Fast forward until we were in our 40s my dd1 had a dd of her own who I doted on. DH who had been gone for a few years came back when dd was pregnant and informed me his mother had added him as a sole beneficiary to her will. We decided to stay together and got married as we'd been divorced. I did this because I thought my dd's and gd would benefit from the money in the future.

My dh and dd's just could not rub along together and in the end, because oh DH heavy drinking and aggressive behaviour both dds left our lives I was devastated not to see my gd and missed her terribly.

When dd2 came to collect her stuff there was an awful row dh said that anybody would have thought he'd sexually abused her the way she was behaving and then he said perhaps he should have done. She blew this out of all proportion as he didn't mean it like that and my friend who was there also said he didn't mean it like that.

I never saw either dd or GC again and that was 20 years ago. I kept them in my will and stayed in an unhappy relationship with a drunk waiting for the day his mother died so we could get money to help my dd's if needed.

I have s large family and when they were in contact with my dd's they would come back and give news and photos to me. I gave them gifts to hand to gd with secret letters inside she could read without her mum knowing but these started coming back and soon my dd's lost contact with all of their aunts uncles and cousins. Our family grew closer than they ever were and my gd has missed out on this.
Dd2 got married and had children and I wasn't involved. I haven't even seen my gc from her. Despite this I stayed with DH for them.

When DH mum died he died shortly after and I now have all of the money, although I've lived on most if it and now work in a lovely job that I really enjoy.

Sadly my brother and his wife died in 2019 within a few weeks of eachother and left their two dd's and 4 GC with no parents/grandparents.

I have become very close to my nieces and their children. I am closer to them than I ever was to my own dd's and I have plenty of wonderful contact with their children, I feel like their real gran.

As my two dd's have got on with their lives and won't have any contact with me would it be unreasonable to take them out of the will and put my nieces in their place.

My other siblings say it is lovely that I am now being given the opportunity to be a real gp just like them after missing out all those years. They say I shouldn't begrudge myself a little bit of happiness after all I've been through.

I put up with an awful life and an unloving marriage for my dd's but they have moved on should I move on too?

Esspee Thu 08-Apr-21 10:54:40

Surely this isn’t for real?

hazel93 Thu 08-Apr-21 10:48:52

Being a mother is not a financial contract . End of.

I find your attitude totally bizarre. Teenagers being belligerent who would have thought ? !!
At 18 no more support , get out, what is that about ?
All very strange if true.

Daisymae Thu 08-Apr-21 10:42:17

Giving the benefit of the doubt - your daughters had an awful childhood and quite honestly they deserve every penny you can leave them. Your nieces are kind to you as they did not experience a deeply troubled upbringing. You can't turn the clock back but you can attempt to make amends.

Smileless2012 Thu 08-Apr-21 10:40:25

I wonder if you've considered the possibility that your D's wouldn't want to be left anything in your will Chookcook. Maybe if you look at this in terms of what is the right thing for your D's, you'll conclude that leaving them nothing is the right thing to do.

I certainly wouldn't welcome such an inheritance.

"I'll tell my nieces that they are getting my property when I die. They will appreciate it and stick around". This for me demonstrates that you are driven by money, see nothing wrong in that and feel that your nieces are the same.

Won't they "stick around" anyway regardless of whether or not they know you're leaving them your house when you die?

Bibbity Thu 08-Apr-21 10:33:26

Of course they weren’t angels. You were an awful mother and they had to deal with an abusive father. They were a product of their environment.

You’re getting to enjoy the result of actual parenting when you failed as one yourself.

I can’t believe this is real anymore. You failed as a mother. You were not a good one and they deserved better.

Chookcook Thu 08-Apr-21 10:29:07

I have a very big and close family not one of them has anything to do with my dd's yet we always meet and have family gatherings. That tells you what my dd's are like if so many people have nothing to do with them

Chookcook Thu 08-Apr-21 10:23:10

I think some of you haven't understood. I don't want a relationship with my dd's now they have been gone over 20 years and if I had them back now it would disrupt what I have with my brother's girls and grandchildren and that is so precious to me.

My dd's were not Angels when they were younger, I was always called into school for their bad behaviour and they used to spend most of their time in their room because they refused to tidy it properly. If they were in the lounge they would sit In front of the TV so nobody else could see. My friends children were not like this. When they were 18 and it was time for them to move out they dragged their heels. One said she would pay rent but as she signed on, she never had enough to give me and the second was so cold and callous towards me. She wasn't thankful when I moved her stuff into a flat for her and didn't understand that at 18 the money for their upkeep stops so I couldn't keep her, it was like having a lodger in my home for free. I couldn't do it.

They were not loving and kind daughter's and all my friends knew that at times they could be right prats but still I did everything for them and stayed in a loveless marriage just for them to abandon me.
The more I go back over this the more I know they don't deserve a mother like me and they didn't deserve what I did for them. I don't think it's unreasonable to write them out. There isn't much anyway.

I'll tell my nieces that they are getting my property when I die. They will appreciate it and stick around.

Nansnet Thu 08-Apr-21 08:02:30

Seriously? You stayed in an abusive relationship with a man who abused hard drugs, and alcohol, and treated you poorly?! And, you say you protected your daughters from the abuse, many break-ups, divorce, and re-marriage ... and you did it all for them? The fact that your daughters finally left because of his heavy drinking, and aggressive behaviour, shows that you didn't protect them from it at all, did you?

The best thing you could've done for your daughters, all those years ago, would've been to leave him, and protect your daughters the way that any good mother would! They have probably been scarred for life by what they have seen and heard. Frankly, I'm not in the least bit surprised that they have distanced themselves from you. I think they deserve to be left in your will ... not because money will ever repay the damage you have done to them, but you did after all say that you'd done it all for them! What a terrible thing, to write your daughters out of your will now, just because you can't have it the way that you want it. You probably put those girls through hell when they were growing up, and it certainly doesn't sound like you ever made them your priority, so you can't expect them to forgive and forget, and take you back into the fold.

Hithere Wed 07-Apr-21 21:39:38

"He was a very troubled man and very violent towards me, not the best dad to our two daughters and abused hard drugs and alcohol. I made sure my dd's did not notice this and I protected them throughout our many breakups, marriage, divorce and marriage again."

This is the beginning of the end.

For sure your daughters knew very well what was going on.

That protection was a delusion on OP's part

Chewbacca Wed 07-Apr-21 21:28:22

I need to hide this thread.....

geekesse Wed 07-Apr-21 21:21:03

This could be the plot of a Disney animated film or a Catherine Cookson mini-series. Have you ever thought of selling your story?

Chookcook Wed 07-Apr-21 21:13:45

Thank you @crazyH. Everything I did was for my dd's.

When they were young I had holes in my shoes and no winter coat. I never went for a night out for years and went without food so they could eat.

When my husband was being horrible to me with them present, I carried on like normal so they didn't notice I went cap in hand to my siblings to ask for money so they had good Christmas presents. Some siblings used to say they wouldn't give money if DH was still in my life so I hid him and risked my relationship with my family just so my dd's could have what they wanted.

I did this for them and everyone of my friends and family knows what I did for my dd's and they feel for me that despite this I lost them.

My nieces children love me and love coming to my house. They scream and cry when it's time to go home to their parents, they didn't even do that with their real grandparents. Everybody says how lovely it is and how my dd's have made their children miss out on family by having no contact with anybody.
It is sad but I can't live in the past. I did all I can selflessly for them, now it's my turn to be happy and those that make me happy should be rewarded not those who I've not seen in 20 years.

crazyH Wed 07-Apr-21 20:35:30

The one thing that absolutely floored me was the fact that you stayed with your DH , because you knew he was in line for a large inheritance and when he popped his clogs, you would get it all. The only redeeming factor is that you thought it would help your daughters. Anyway, it didn’t. .....you blew the lot!,,,
I wish you the best. As for writing them out of your will, that’s up to you. ....I am glad that you and your nieces have formed a great bond. I am really pleased for you. Ofcourse, you must leave your nieces something, but not everything. Good luck !!

Sago Wed 07-Apr-21 20:22:17

Full marks for honesty Chookcook.

Oopsadaisy1 Wed 07-Apr-21 20:22:07

TBH if this is a true story then you should leave everything you have to your children and Grandchildren.

Chookcook Wed 07-Apr-21 20:21:31

Oopsadaisy1 I have all the family I need my dd's and GC have gone I accept that. I have made up for it with my brother's family since he's died and want to leave the property to them instead.

Chookcook Wed 07-Apr-21 20:19:26

@flexiblefriend I had to live on something I couldn't claim benefits at that point as I had too much in savings and when I bought my property it needed work doing to make it livable and inturn this upped the value of it for when I am gone

Oopsadaisy1 Wed 07-Apr-21 20:16:00

You’ve done quite well for yourself then, stayed married to get the money, now spent most of it and wondering if you can get your family back in your old age.

You couldn’t make it up could you?

FlexibleFriend Wed 07-Apr-21 20:14:58

It seems to have been a very flawed plan then because if you stayed with your Husband to get your hands on his money for your Daughters as you claim, why the hell did you spend it?

Chookcook Wed 07-Apr-21 20:10:42

This is not a tale of woe I'm finally very happy and moving on which made me think I should include changing my will, there isn't that much left out of what was left to my husband I live in a small bungalow with no more savings and a minimum wage job and there wouldn't be enough to recognise my dd's and my nieces and their DC. My gd has forgotten me so I want to recognise those who are important now not past reasons

SueDonim Wed 07-Apr-21 20:02:56

I don’t often comment on these threads but have to say, I’m with smiless on this.

FlexibleFriend Wed 07-Apr-21 20:01:06

Shock, horror, your daughters are not interested, are you surprised. You put the possibility of money before their happiness. Which is crap actually because you'd already been in and out of this hideous relationship for years before the will was changed. Kids are not blind and you're deluding yourself if you think they didn't know what was going on. Assuming of course there is any truth in this tale of woe.

Smileless2012 Wed 07-Apr-21 19:55:07

Well it's very rare that I am lost for words, but I am.

It is also very rare for Bibbity and me to agree, but I agree with you Bibbity 100%.

Bibbity Wed 07-Apr-21 19:23:57

No. You stayed because you wanted money.
It was disgusting. Full stop.

What an absolute failure of a mother to even try to defend that.

Again do whatever you want. At least they are free of you.

Chookcook Wed 07-Apr-21 19:22:12

@bibity I stayed with him because we always had no money when the dd's were growing up I thought the money from his mother's will could give them a leg up in the future. It cost me a lot to live like this but I still did it for my dd's however they're not interested.

What he said is awful if not taken into context. DH did not abuse dd in this way but believed her rejection of him would have only been necessary had he of done so. My friend also agreed he was not putting it as best he should but understands what he meant.