Gransnet forums

AIBU

To want /need an edit function

(33 Posts)
Grandmagrim Mon 10-Jan-22 09:31:50

Argh my proof reading always fails me until after I hit the post button. Would it really be too much to ask for an edit function.

Jane43 Mon 10-Jan-22 22:44:42

I agree, I do proof read but mistakes get through and I get frustrated because I can’t correct them. An edit function would be good.

Ali08 Mon 10-Jan-22 22:40:16

Isn't that what 'preview' is for?
Although, I do agree that an edit button would be handy!

Kim19 Mon 10-Jan-22 16:29:32

Thing is, most of us read through the errors and do understand what was intended. Unless my intention was completely skewed, I would not attempt to correct. I certainly would not correct any spelling errors. Too much like hard work. If pedants want to assume I can't spell, then so be it.

LovelyCuppa Mon 10-Jan-22 12:42:18

A different site, but 139 laughing emojis on a post made me realise that I had asked about 'winter panties' and not 'winter pansies'. An edit button would have been great, once I'd realised the mistake! ??

BlueBelle Mon 10-Jan-22 12:42:11

Don’t worry about phone kali need new brain
No we will never get one
I ve never ever had a problem on any other forums 99% of the time it’s used to correct spelling or wrong words and not having one doesn’t stop rudeness at all I was called a wicked witch by one ‘circus acrobat’ who shall not be name and it sat there for days

Kali2 Mon 10-Jan-22 12:37:21

Can't stand typing on phone- always use tablet and proper keyboard!

Doodledog Mon 10-Jan-22 12:34:18

We should all disable autocorrect - that would get rid of 90% of my mistakes at a stroke.

Doodledog Mon 10-Jan-22 12:33:19

AAHHGH!

Doodledog Mon 10-Jan-22 12:33:08

goody, not goodie - see! We need an edit button (and I did look on Preview before posting grin

NanTheWiser Mon 10-Jan-22 12:33:00

It’ll never happen. Mumsnet doesn’t have one, despite MANY requests for it, and it is open to abuse. I always use preview, so that’s good enough for me.

Doodledog Mon 10-Jan-22 12:32:28

A five-minute button would pretty much eradicate the possibility of offensive posts being altered. As BlueBelle says, there are plenty of 'goody or downright offensive' ones anyway, and one poster's straight talking is another's bullying in any case - what constitutes 'offensive' is often in the eye of the beholder.

Admin can see the edits, so if someone did post 'Doodledog is a big fat meanie' then change it 4 minutes later to 'I beg to differ, old girl', and anyone reported it, the culprit would be bang to rights.

BlueBelle Mon 10-Jan-22 12:26:05

See I need an edit button my capitols didn’t work out

BlueBelle Mon 10-Jan-22 12:25:06

A five minute edit button works on every other forum I ve ever been on
Abuse can be imagined just by posting
Are you presuming there are never any * goady or downright unpleasant posts* on here anyway …dream away ilovecheese
There are many and they often stay on for days and days cloud cuckoo land

Ilovecheese Mon 10-Jan-22 12:21:18

I don't agree with having an edit button. There is already a preview button which can easily be used to check for typos. There is also a function to ask for one's own post to be deleted.
An edit button would be open to abuse, goady or downright unpleasant posts could be altered later so that the perpetrator could claim "that's not what I said. Look! "

Beswitched Mon 10-Jan-22 11:57:16

Yes a 5 minute edit button would not be open to abuse but would be very helpful, particularly to those of us typing on our phones! But mumsnet and gransnet seem stubbornly resistant to the idea.

Nannagarra Mon 10-Jan-22 11:44:37

I’m another who would like an edit button and to be given five minutes in which to use it. More often than not I find mistakes having just pressed ‘Post’. If editing is limited to the person writing the post I cannot see the problem.

Oldnproud Mon 10-Jan-22 11:42:41

Told you! wink

Elizabeth27 Mon 10-Jan-22 11:32:48

Use the preview, an edit button is open to misuse.

BlueBelle Mon 10-Jan-22 11:16:27

There was NEVER any feedback muse we all have asked and asked for a few simple changes but we never get anything and that time not even an acknowledgement

Kali2 Mon 10-Jan-22 10:40:46

Must say it would be great- I type very fast and do make typos- sometimes mistakes too as English is not my MT. I should always 'preview message' before posting though. But an 'edit' button would be great. It could time out after a couple of minutes though.

muse Mon 10-Jan-22 10:37:10

Many moons ago someone at GNHQ asked what we would like to be changed or added to GN. An edit button was in the top three suggestions.

I can't recall seeing any feed back from GNHQ about the suggestions made ??

Doodledog Mon 10-Jan-22 10:22:41

Another vote for an edit button, please.

DillytheGardener Mon 10-Jan-22 10:15:37

Juliet27 that is hilarious ?

ExDancer Mon 10-Jan-22 10:14:08

I didn't know there was one on Facebook Jackiest - is it for messages or just public chat? Where is it please?

Sarnia Mon 10-Jan-22 10:08:11

I agree with you and a few choices such as 'like' 'laugh' 'cross' etc to respond to comments would be good.