Gransnet forums

AIBU

To tell in-laws about divorce

(41 Posts)
Deepem Wed 22-May-24 23:54:43

My daughter told her husband she wanted a divorce over 6 months ago and they started the process in January. Things are progressing slowly partly because he is invested in maintaining the status quo. He has been financially dependent on her. They are still living together as they have two young children and want to keep things stable until they have sorted out the details. All my family know what is happening and are very supportive. He has not told his parents yet. From my perspective, I think this is because he does not want to be seen as "less than". He lost his job in the past and did not tell them.
I feel uncomfortable that they do not know and that it will be a shock for them when things are finalised. I also feel it's unfair on my daughter who has to pretend that things are normal when they visit, I don't think she should be involved in deceiving them. She won't discuss it with him as he is controlling and argumentative and she is trying to minimise any opportunities for argument or debate. He is intransigent anyway.
I have always had an amicable relationship with his parents although they are not nearby and I see them rarely. Would it be unreasonable to message them as if they already knew, in the spirit of supporting each other and maintaining a mature relationship moving forward? Or should I leave well alone and just continue to support my daughter as best I can?

Wyllow3 Thu 23-May-24 00:02:48

Leave well alone. It's up to your daughter. You're doing well with that.

Only she knows how much she can cope with and dealing with the MiL and FiL is the sons' problem.

NotSpaghetti Thu 23-May-24 00:54:17

But if he is controlling it will potentially take years...

She probably knows this...

Macadia Thu 23-May-24 01:01:03

I am sorry for this position you are in. You don't know when and if the divorce will be finalized. Some couples go back and forth with these disputes. It can even take years. Best to not publicize their quarrels with the in-laws and don't push your daughter either way even if you don't like the fellow. Don't encourage or discourage a divorce. Tell her you love her and cannot advise on such a thing. She's a grown woman and a mother. I am sure she will make a sensible choice about her family's future.

Macadia Thu 23-May-24 01:02:23

NotSpaghetti

But if he is controlling it will potentially take years...

She probably knows this...

So true !

Macadia Thu 23-May-24 01:09:18

Your daughter sounds like the mature adult in this relationship. Give her self-confidence and compliment her on her mothering skills. Being a mother is a tough job! It makes me angry to hear that someone is "controlling" because he is only controlling her if she allows it.

Oopsadaisy1 Thu 23-May-24 05:16:51

Yes it would be unreasonable for you to contact them.

It’s up to your daughter and her ‘soon to be ex’ to tell anyone that they are divorcing/separating, not you.

BlueBelle Thu 23-May-24 05:43:25

No no no it’s not your business keep well out of it
If his pride won’t let him tell his parents it not your job to intervene
Leave the to sort their own stuff out

Anniebach Thu 23-May-24 05:46:53

Leave well alone

Esmay Thu 23-May-24 06:12:22

Please stay out of it .

Your daughter is doing her best coping with a divorce .
My sister in law's husband left her twice - once when she was eight months pregnant and she had the joy of her mother in law phoning her up at work and blaming her for her husband's infidelity .
He used to tell his parents all sorts of lies about every aspect of their lives omitting being dismissed from his job .

I wish your daughter a smooth divorce .

Just be there for her .

GrannyIvy Thu 23-May-24 07:34:41

Leave well alone and support your daughter. Living together in the house with this going on will be so difficult. Young children soon pick up on situations. Not an easy time for her.

M0nica Thu 23-May-24 08:17:44

Leave well alone. Just make sure that when they do finally find out, they fully realise that it was their son's decision not to tell them and that neither your DD nor any of her family had any sau in his decision.

Smileless2012 Thu 23-May-24 08:33:38

You will potentially make the situation even more difficult for your D if you say anything.

It's up to him when he tells his parents.

Shelflife Thu 23-May-24 08:44:38

I agree, it is up to your SIL to inform his parents. Just be there for your daughter and your GC. I wished them well.

Germanshepherdsmum Thu 23-May-24 08:54:56

It’s not for you to mention it to your daughter’s in laws. Just be there for your daughter and grandchildren. The financial arrangements are going to be particularly difficult if your daughter’s husband is not a reliable earner. I know that from experience - it’s the worst part and can take a very long time to finalise.

Cossy Thu 23-May-24 09:11:17

Difficult dilemma but it’s neither your call nor business to discuss this with anyone let alone in-laws, no- one truly knows what goes on between married couples. If you worried about control just stay close to your daughter and support her and the children.

eazybee Thu 23-May-24 09:11:31

Your daughter and your son-in-law have made the decision not to inform his parents of their impending divorce. It would have been better if your daughter had not informed you either, but kept her own counsel.
On no account should you take the decision to inform his parents, and you should not inform anyone else either.
It may be that your son-in-law does not wish to alarm his parents until they have reached a joint decision; it is up to your daughter to decide the right time, not you.

flappergirl Thu 23-May-24 09:49:31

I strongly urge you to leave well alone. Her husband may very well blame your daughter and make her situation even more difficult or even unsafe.

Deepem Thu 23-May-24 11:56:07

Thank you all for the advice which has clarified things for me, the consensus being to do nothing more than continue to support my daughter. I'm appreciative and will follow this advice. Thank you too for your well wishes for my daughter. It has been a shock to find out the level of psychological abuse and control that she has been subjected to but she is calm and strong and I'm so proud of her.

Theexwife Thu 23-May-24 12:39:41

I would stay out of it, they are adults, he doesn’t have to tell his parents anything.

madeleine45 Thu 23-May-24 14:33:21

The best thing you can do is support your daughter but for yourself it might be good to write down what you feel about the situation, and put down just what you think of him too and then rip it up. That lets you do something about how you feel and then can be very calm for your daughter.

Norah Thu 23-May-24 14:39:00

I have always had an amicable relationship with his parents although they are not nearby and I see them rarely. Would it be unreasonable to message them as if they already knew, in the spirit of supporting each other and maintaining a mature relationship moving forward? Or should I leave well alone and just continue to support my daughter as best I can?

No, leave his parents well out of your messages. Just support your daughter, whilst staying neutral - one never knows the end result in advance.

Davida1968 Thu 23-May-24 15:08:45

I agree with others here; keep quiet (as regards informing your SiL's parents) and carry on supporting your DD. From the sound of it, I'd guess that your DD needs to be away from this relationship ASAP, so you may well play a crucial role in helping her to move on with her life. SiL's parents are not your problem.

Deepem Thu 23-May-24 19:33:10

This is thoughtful advice, thank you.

LottieLouise Thu 23-May-24 19:57:02

I know your daughter think she is doing the right thing, but living with a controlling man must make the atmosphere in the house terrible for the children and if I were your daughter I would tell her husband to leave. Let him sort it out with his parents, why should your daughter have to live in such a terrible situation especially with a controlling man who could turn on her and their children at a moments notice.