Gransnet forums

AIBU

Beware the Nanny State is here!

(91 Posts)
petra Wed 18-Sept-24 20:18:40

Was the number ( of the caller) withheld?
If yes, then I would phone your social services dept and ask if someone did phone you.

Allira Wed 18-Sept-24 20:09:39

Sago

There is an elderly couple on our street who have a home that is in awful state of disrepair, their garden is full of vermin and we suspect the house is too, they hedges are all overgrown and impinging on the path.
They are hoarders so heaven knows what state the house is in.

They always say they are fine when we ask, there is nothing we can do.

There are younger people who live like this too.

Lisaangel10 Wed 18-Sept-24 20:07:21

Shinamae

I think it very probably was kind and well intentioned..

My first thought too.

Sago Wed 18-Sept-24 20:06:23

There is an elderly couple on our street who have a home that is in awful state of disrepair, their garden is full of vermin and we suspect the house is too, they hedges are all overgrown and impinging on the path.
They are hoarders so heaven knows what state the house is in.

They always say they are fine when we ask, there is nothing we can do.

Allira Wed 18-Sept-24 20:01:10

It’s not about the nanny state but the way you’ve just described yourselves does sound as though you could do with support

In what way, exactly?

M0nica Wed 18-Sept-24 20:00:33

It is odd that you should get two calls from Social Services. That would make me uneasy, and wonder whether it was some kind of malicious prank.

Has anyone expressed concern abut how you are managing? It is very difficult. to mark the line between managing easily and happily and just 'managing'.

PaperMonster Wed 18-Sept-24 19:30:53

It’s not about the nanny state but the way you’ve just described yourselves does sound as though you could do with support. I reported a neighbour to social services but they wouldn’t contact her unless two others could corroborate my concerns. In the end, three other people did, including the GP. She refused help. She’s in a right old state.

Caleo Wed 18-Sept-24 19:03:20

I'd have been happy to receive an unsolicited offer of help from anyone. I wish I could look forward to such offers as I often worry about what I will do if I become more disabled and can no longer toilet myself as well as I do.

You and your husband do seem to be on the verge of needing help. I'd query the ability of my carer if she were obese.

nanaK54 Wed 18-Sept-24 18:58:05

Nothing but sympathy from me flowers I can imagine how upset you are feeling, if you are sure that you don't need any help, then please just put it all out of your mind.

Patsy70 Wed 18-Sept-24 18:52:05

I can imagine how you must feel after receiving such a call. I know I would have been livid. Firstly, are you certain that it was in fact from Social Services? Presumably, if it was, the person would have given you their name and contact details, should you require help in the future. Are you and your husband hoarders? In which case the anonymous caller may have been concerned about your safety, and therefore being kind and well intentioned, although rather insensitive to your feelings.

loopyloo Wed 18-Sept-24 18:35:48

I hope you didn't give any information to the caller.
Just a bit worried it might be a scam.
On balance, perhaps agree to a visit just to reassure them that you are in fact managing quite well.
I also have a very suspicious mind that someone might have a vested interest in your property
Stay very calm and courteous.
Also there may come a time when they might be able to arrange some help for you.

wildswan16 Wed 18-Sept-24 18:02:20

That must have been very shocking for you and I totally understand why you would feel upset and shaken by it. However, although done in a rather clumsy and insensitive way I can only imagine that "somebody" got it into their head that you were struggling with life in some way. Yes, they should have checked with you first. A simple "are things ok right now, anything you need help with?" would have let you reply appropriately. People often don't go about things in a sensible way do they?

Try not to dwell on it too much - it's not worth spoiling your peace of mind over. Just have a good moan about it and move on.

seadragon Wed 18-Sept-24 17:48:35

It would do no harm to agree to a visit surely? In 25 years working as a social worker my approach was only rejected twice, However I was able to outline the sort of professional help/support/advice I could offer to both indivduals. They agreed to further contact and I helped one to come to terms with an extremely traumatic childhood experience and the other by helping her and her husband to move to a new home that suited their changing needs and ensured they had all the benefits, services and equipment they were entitled to. I do recognise that it is upsetting to find you have been referred to Social Services without your knowledge, though..... and a personal question like that is not acceptable... We live in a muddle ourselves as I have never been very domesticated and things are beginning to get on top of us. I sometimes wish someone would come and see if they could do something to make things a bit easier for us as all my attempts to 'get sorted" seem to be undone by the next day!

Babs03 Wed 18-Sept-24 17:37:02

Oh dear, this doesn’t sound very nice at all, no wonder you are upset, tbh I would be livid. Do you have relatives who could have made this call? It must be someone you know. But is so underhand, I mean why didn’t this person approach you directly and ask if either of you needed any help?
When you say you are not tidy people does this extend to outside areas that neighbours might complain about?
If you fear it could be a friend or acquaintance why not just ask and get it out of the way. No point harbouring suspicions.
Wishing you well with this x

Shinamae Wed 18-Sept-24 17:34:18

I think it very probably was kind and well intentioned..

SingingRabbits Wed 18-Sept-24 17:30:00

We are not tidy people, my husband and I! In fact some people might consider our home somewhat shambolic! There are a number of reasons for this. My husband of nearly 90 years of age is a little stooped nowadays and I, twelve years his junior, am impeded by obesity so cannot walk as well as I could wish. We are otherwise in sound health Imagine my shock, therefore, to receive phone calls on two afternoons this week from Social Services stating that someone was "worried about us" and was I "able to wash myself?"! I was very annoyed and made quite clear that we had no need of social services and that if we want help we are perfectly capable of buying it in privately. I enquired of the caller how they got our contact details and was told that they didn't know as concerned individuals are allowed to remain anonymous. There are no vulnerable adults or children in our house, so this was not about Safeguarding. The whole experience has left me feeling humiliated, demoralised and suspicious of my friends and acquaintances as I don't know who has caused this situation. Being concerned about somebody is, no doubt, kindly and well-intentioned but to report them to the public authorities without their knowledge and agreement, is disrespectful, authoritarian and absolutely intolerable. It smacks of totalitarian countries where people are encouraged to snitch on their neighbours. shock