Gransnet forums

AIBU

AIBU to find this halloe’en display’ offensive?

(93 Posts)
Midnightblue Tue 22-Oct-24 17:10:04

Actually I don’t think I am being.
I am pretty relaxed about Hallo’e’en generally, and I am not easily shocked, but I have noticed it’s become more and more focused on violence these past few years, not only by teenagers, but by some parents of young children.

I’ve just walked past a house where the owners have put a ‘scarecrow’, dressed in full hazmat suit, performing a ‘post mortem’ on another scarecrow lying on a table, which is covered by a blood stained sheet. The owners of the property have taken up some flags from their garden and dug a ‘grave’.

Hanging upside down either side of their front door are 2 full size human shaped objects, tightly wrapped in black plastic.

I know it’s on their property, but it is put up for public consumption, otherwise they’d have set it up in their own living room.

TBH, I feel a bit upset, (to my own surprise) that anyone would think it’s ok to think up, find it funny, and display this. If I had children to care for, I wouldn’t walk them past.

Just interested to see what other grans think

Oreo Tue 22-Oct-24 17:19:24

I think the same as you do, it’s totally horrible 🤬
It was in the news the other day that a soft play area for tots somewhere had the same human shaped objects tightly wrapped in black plastic hanging within the area, hung by the neck or the ankles.Parents complained so they were removed.

merlotgran Tue 22-Oct-24 17:19:25

It sounds awful. What is wrong with people?

MissInterpreted Tue 22-Oct-24 17:21:13

It wouldn't bother me at all, to be honest - but I can see why some people would get offended by it.

Oreo Tue 22-Oct-24 17:24:47

I see Mums with very young kids browsing the Halloween stuff
Such as blood stained axes, full size skeletons and grotesque masks.
I would keep all young ones away from these displays, enough to give them nightmares.
The best Halloween displays are pumpkins and Autumn leaves and black cats.
I really do think that violent scenes desensitise.

NotSpaghetti Tue 22-Oct-24 17:26:21

Not sure it would bother me either to be honest - might have to see it though.

Shelflife Tue 22-Oct-24 17:26:26

I agree completely! It is very bad taste indeed. I am not keen on Halloween but tolerate it within reason. Your neighbours display is distasteful. There is more than enough violence in our society without promoting it at Halloween! Ghosts , spiders and and witches are just about acceptable. I find it shocking to see such distasteful displays at Halloween.

DamaskRose Tue 22-Oct-24 17:30:40

Shelflife

I agree completely! It is very bad taste indeed. I am not keen on Halloween but tolerate it within reason. Your neighbours display is distasteful. There is more than enough violence in our society without promoting it at Halloween! Ghosts , spiders and and witches are just about acceptable. I find it shocking to see such distasteful displays at Halloween.

This.

AreWeThereYet Tue 22-Oct-24 17:35:03

Our local coffee shop always has a lot of Halloween decorations including skeletons and huge spiders. I watched some young girls a few days ago shrieking with laughter prodding the skeletons. They obviously have no idea what a skeleton actually is. They also enjoyed the spiders and making the blood spattered Herman Munster wave his arms around and shout.

Oreo I totally agree that we get de-sensitised by violence but unfortunately I think that ship sailed back in the 70s.

BlueBelle Tue 22-Oct-24 17:39:41

Yes I agree I ve got a house near me with the tightly packed black plastic covered body hanging by the ankles out the window, truly gruesome and nasty
It might not bother you some but surely it’s not a very good message for young impressionable children to see plastic encased heads and bodies, tied up in submissive roles not only gruesome but what if a small kid tries to tie their sibling in a black plastic bag !!!!

Oreo Tue 22-Oct-24 17:46:45

Not sure if that ship sailed in the 70’s AreWeThereYet as I was only a young child then and Halloween was quite low key, and no kids I knew were allowed to watch anything violent on tv.

Oreo Tue 22-Oct-24 17:47:57

That’s a good point BlueBelle about kids and bin bags😲

DiamondLily Tue 22-Oct-24 17:49:31

Halloween is an American9 thing. I can’t be bothered with any of it.🙄

karmalady Tue 22-Oct-24 17:50:09

I would hate to see any of that, around here it is cobwebs and a light in squash. No blood, axes or gore

AreWeThereYet Tue 22-Oct-24 18:01:54

Oreo

Not sure if that ship sailed in the 70’s AreWeThereYet as I was only a young child then and Halloween was quite low key, and no kids I knew were allowed to watch anything violent on tv.

Oreo We watched violence on TV in the 70s - even in cartoons, western films, war films, crime films. None of them as violent as the films are now, of course, and not so much gore.

The first computer games aimed at the public were released in the 70s - nearly all of them involved shooting things and killing things to increase your score. Even then I remember discussions on whether children were affected by violent films and games. I would have been in my teens then.

GrannyGravy13 Tue 22-Oct-24 18:09:52

DiamondLily

Halloween is an American9 thing. I can’t be bothered with any of it.🙄

Halloween originated here as All Hallows Eve. It was a Pagen Festival.

Mexicans have Day of the Dead.

The USA have taken elements of both.

Oreo Tue 22-Oct-24 18:10:07

I wasn’t allowed anything violent as a child and wasn’t even aware of it.
Cartoons were fine, Tom and Jerry, didn’t see it as real.The only game I remember was space invaders.

Oreo Tue 22-Oct-24 18:11:36

I love the velvet pumpkins I bought a few years ago and a lovely Autumn wreath.❤️

MissInterpreted Tue 22-Oct-24 18:39:59

I knew a woman who was an educational psychologist and she was determined that her son (who was the same age as my daughter) would not be allowed anything violent, no toy guns, nothing like that. Imagine her horror when she saw him running around my friend's garden chasing her daughter and mine with a stick and pretending to shoot them with it!

Tizliz Tue 22-Oct-24 18:52:12

This was posted on our local FB page, not sure about it 🤫

Witzend Tue 22-Oct-24 19:01:45

It does sound particularly gruesome, OP. Whatever happened to good old ghosts, bats and witches?

M0nica Tue 22-Oct-24 19:08:32

It sounds horrible and distasteful. I hate horror, I cannot watch horror films. I think, like porn, this extreme violence comes form the availability of really vile torture and horror films online.

But what has amazed me this year is Hallowe'en decorations going up on the outside of houses and on fences and walls, weeks before halloween. Some have been up for a week or more.

I went past one house this week where the outside decorations, entirely decorous, spiders webs, big enough to be made from rope and extend from bedroom windows to garden, pumpkins and lights, must have cost £00s and up a good two weeks in advance. They will no doubt come down and be immediately replaced by Christmas decorations - which will also have cost £00s.

M0nica Tue 22-Oct-24 19:08:58

Tizliz

This was posted on our local FB page, not sure about it 🤫

I think this is hilarious, as long as no one takes it seriously!!

Witzend Tue 22-Oct-24 19:10:23

Tizliz

This was posted on our local FB page, not sure about it 🤫

Surely just a joke of the ‘black comedy’ variety?
I was guilty last year of buying a plastic skeleton - an enormous ‘spider’ one, which is daft anyway, since spiders don’t have skeletons.
The Gdcs loved it, anyway. I dare say it’ll be decorating their front garden again this year.

AreWeThereYet Tue 22-Oct-24 19:12:30

Tizliz

This was posted on our local FB page, not sure about it 🤫

I think it's funny too. As M0nica says, so long as no one takes it seriously. There was a time when I wouldn't even have considered that anyone would take it seriously...