Gransnet forums

AIBU

Grandparent Alienation

(22 Posts)
Anomaly Fri 24-Jan-25 08:32:00

Hi there all,

I am reaching out as I need useful tips on how I can navigate what appears to be the start of grandparent alienation. Please bear with me as I try to give as much detail as possible to give a clear picture.

I have two children. My daughter has had troublesome times as a teenager, but I've always been there, always been supporting her, probably admittedly too much. She has had a tendency to purposefully hurt me to get a reaction in the past, and unfortunately it works as I love her and would do anything for her. I do worry she may revel when I am sad as some of my friends have pointed out. But I truly hope not.

I try to make sure my children can always talk to me about anything. I have always wanted to be open as both my parents were reserved and strict and I never felt loved growing up.

My daughter has never liked anyone I have dated (2 in the last 20 years). After my last relationship, as she was an adult we had a discussion and I did say I don't feel she is ever going to like anyone I dated, which she agreed, and I explained that I deserved to be happy, which she acknowledged. I am pleased to say she really likes my partner whom I've been dating coming up two years.

She has had relationships in the past, and one in particular her partner did not treat her well and I was always there whenever he decided to throw her out again, but not interfering, always reminding her she will always have a home here to come to if she ever wanted to. She moved back in with me and dated her current partner, whom I adore and thought I had a good relationship with.

I've supported them both whenever they have needed me for a range of things like writing references and completing applications for her partner to gain ID, then a passport and then a provisional driving license. For her writing her CV and helping her through her level 3 diploma (unfortunately she did terribly in her GCSEs and she was distraught when she realised she had screwed up her chances of college so i battled her corner and she did get a place).

I've been really conscious not to overstep the mark and occasionally say I'm always here to listen or help, you only need to ask. And when my children do, I accommodate them, all three, now four of them. Her partner has said to her that we have a very different relationship to what he has with his family and that we are very close. We've both (daughter and I worked really hard on our relationship).

I have a 4 bed house and rented out a room to a lodger when I was single to cover the household bills. At one point my daughter moved back home and I vetted lodgers carefully being aware that she was a young adult. We had to get rid of one lodger as i became concerned he was inapproriate. She can be very hostile and her moods go up and down quite drastically unfortunately.

We use to clash a lot when she was a teenager, but as I've got older, I tend to walk away from conflict. As she's got older, our relationship has drastically improved and we are really close, we both keep a calm head and talk openly. Our communication and relationship is brilliant which i am really pleased about.

She always had an issue with whatever lodger I had, would become hostile, and they would leave. This was the same behaviour in my previous relationships also.

We were out one evening and she bumped into a childhood friend and she was looking for lodging which my daughter was excited about. I honestly thought it was a great idea as she had known this girl for years and they were friends. I thought she would be more comfortable. Once again after several months, my daughter became hostile and arguments over cleaning the bathroom and parking in the driveway became an issue (i have an ensuite and don't use their bathroom).

My daughter became pregnant with her partner and we were ecstatic for her. When her friend the lodger moved out (because of the hostility, in the end from both sides) I thought of an option that might make her more comfortable.

Her partner is from a different background/culture and has his own idea of how to live, including the role of a woman (to be clear, British but I don't want to give too much away). My daughter did not want this way of life, and to be fair to her, she reiterated her boundaries despite his culture trying to persuade her. I am proud of her for not wavering.

With rent costs extremely high, and my daughter not wanting to move into her partners mums I offered a solution.

She was paying a small amount of rent. And I gave her the option of her partner moving in, and them using the double room I rented as a nursery. All they needed to do was cover what I was renting the room for and her small rent would disappear. This covers all their bills.

Although it financially impacted me, I wanted to offer this to them as a way to save money and buy somewhere, with the hope I could also give them additional funds (I was intending on matching what they had saved). I was a single struggling mother for years and I did not want them to have to face the same struggles.

My bedroom is in a downstairs annexe and there are three rooms and a bathroom upstairs all for themselves. Two large double rooms for their sole use, and a single box room which we store things in/when my son comes back from uni briefly.
Its bigger than a 1 bedroom flat they would have got through the council/HA which is another reason she wanted to stay. We also have an extremely large kitchen/diner and I tend to have tv dinners and they have their family meals times in the separate diner to give them space. I do try to cook at different times to make sure we aren't in each other's way.

They loved the idea, and her partner moved in. I made him feel welcome and would occasionally say this is his home too to make sure he was comfortable. Admittedly he didnt want to leave his mums, but it was always eventually going to happen, as they will eventually get their own place.

My daughter asked me to help decorate the nursery, and drive to buy nursery furniture as her partner did not want to. My family gave her a cot, pushchair, car seat, clothes etc.

My daughter wanted me to organise a baby shower and I made sure to message her partners mum to help with ideas and his sister also to help decorate to make sure they felt included. She is really lovely as is his sister and we get along well.

My daughter and now fiance had a beautiful baby. My daughter wanted me to be at the birth as a second birthing partner, which i asked her to make sure her partner was comfortable with, and again at the hospital when the baby wasn't well. Her partner wanted to get some sleep so we switched posts. I bought her food as she didn't like the food in the hospital, washed out breast pumps for sterilising and provided emotional support and cuddles so she could sleep.

They came home and we enjoyed cuddles, but I made sure I helped anyway I could. We did their washing, washed up their dishes, changed light switches in the rooms to dimmers as the lights were too bright for the baby, draft proofed the windows, washed and sterilised bottles, helped them work out how the pushchair works, descaled the steriliser etc. Just any support they asked of us, including a shoulder to cry on. I was conscious not to just want to cuddle the baby, but also do practical things to help.

She said she was so glad she was here at home, and that she didn't think she could do this without being here. I made sure she understood that she was more than capable and doing a fantastic job, but extra support is just an extra pair of hands. Help I didn't have when they were born I wish I'd had. I regularly told her what a fantastic job she was doing and that I was so proud of them both.

When my daughters partners family came to visit, I made sure I said my hellos, made them teas and stayed out of the way to give them space as I was conscious I would see the baby every day and they couldn't. When they came again I went out for the day to give them space again.

A couple of weeks ago my daughter wanted to go to a beauty appointment, but I was unavailable and suggested my partner could watch the baby if she wanted. She said yes. My partner was looking forward to it (he has no children of his own and is infertile, but amazing with children, looks after his nieces and nephews regularly).

The night before, she text and said her partner was not happy leaving the baby just yet. I could tell my partner was hurt and I messaged back saying no problem. I then offered that I could do it the following week myself if she was more comfortable, but no pressure. I just wanted to make sure she had her me time.

She said yes and in the morning face to face she said it was not personal with my partner, it's just that the baby is young, and they were worried he would not be able to cope with a newborn. I responded that she didn't need to justify herself and that it was their baby and we respect their decisions. I also reassured my partner.

So I watched the baby, fed the baby and changed their nappy for the 1.5 hours my daughter was gone. When her partner came home I could hear them arguing upstairs. Unfortunately they have been arguing a lot, but I'm not surprised as having a newborn can be stressful.

Since this day, I have barely seen my grandchild. I have asked for cuddles on three occassions and been told no. It's made me extremely upset and I have no idea what I have done wrong.

So I spoke to my daughter when she was alone and asked if I had upset her as I had not seen the baby since the beauty appointment. She reassured me that I hadn't. I asked if her partner was upset I had watched the baby and she said he was not (I know he was as I could hear the argument. I wasn't eaves dropping, but the walls are paper thin and I could unwittingly hear bits over the tv even with the doors closed).

A few more days pass and my long term friend whom has known my daughter since a small child came over to see her and the baby. Whilst alone, I confided in her in tears how I am no longer allowed to cuddle the baby. How the baby is kept upstairs all day, then snuck down so we can't see the baby. I have even noticed they turn the car seat away so I can't see the baby when they come in, and have turned the moses basket around also so I can't see the baby in the dining room.

My friend after a few pleasantries asked for a cuddle and it was no problem. They were talking about valentines day. My partner and I were supposed to be baby sitting so her and her partner could go for dinner and have some couples time. She then announced that they were dropping the baby at her partners mums. I was clearly sad and said but I thought we were baby sitting. She said that her partners mum is single and that my partner and I could go out. I said I was really looking forward to it. She didn't respond.

So my friend hands the baby back (once alone she admitted she thought of handing the baby to me, but didnt want to cause more issues), and my daughter goes to walk upstairs and I said, I'd love cuddles later if that's okay. She responded maybe, but it never happened.

I tried to talk to both of them and once again asked if I had upset them. She said she knew I was upset and that there was honestly nothing wrong. I said since the beauty appointment, something has clearly changed, and if I've done something wrong to please tell me. Her partner could hear the whole time, as I wanted to speak to them both this time and he did not respond. Once again, she reassured me there was nothing wrong, I was reading too much into it and that they wanted to find their own routine.

My issue is, it's only me and my partner that isn't allowed to cuddle the baby anymore, and she will literally say no in front of people, which is even more upsetting as it implies to everyone i am not trustworthy.

Prior to this I had raised concerns. Please don't get me wrong, I really really like her partner, but there were a few red flags. She made comments like, his family have bothered more than her family. I reminded her I had supported them both everyway I can. She did acknowledge this. She said her partner was furious that some of our family had not visited and that they were going to be cut off from any events in the baby's life. Even her best friend.

I did suggest this was a bit heavy handed, that the baby was only a couple of weeks old and that some people want to give new families a bit of space. I also reminded her the family she wanted to cut off had given a lot of things to them for the baby.

I also said, please be careful, from the things I've heard you say, it sound's as though your partner may be trying to alienate you from your family and friends as he has issues with your family only. She also went on to say that he had mentioned if they ever broke up due to her, he would take the baby. He also mentioned his sister would become the caregiver if anything happened to them.

She was upset recently that she was doing a lot of the hard work, and her partner said to drop the baby to his mums or sister so she could sleep. I responded to her that this was unusual as I work from home so I could help (they both live further away and she couldn't yet drive).

I want to tread gently. My friend who came over suggested I remind them I graciously opened up my home to all and that if they were unhappy, they were welcome to leave as its become a hostile environment. I am concerned if I do this, knowing the temperament of my daughter, I won't ever see my grandchild or her again.

I am distraught. I wonder if her partner feels his mum doesn't see the baby every day, so neither should I. I am not only concerned that my grandchild will become alienated from me, but also I from my daughter and my daughter from our family.

There is an atmosphere and neither my daughter or her partner speak to us. They just walk through the sitting room and don't even say hello. They do however respond if we speak to them. My partner recently had a very delicate area operation and he has been doubled over in pain and they don't even ask if he's okay. I've always had this little joke that I could be on fire and my kids would step over me. I don't know if that's necessarily because they don't care, it's more maybe the thought of your parents being invicible.

It's now got to the point I feel so uncomfortable in our home and don't even know how I should act around them, whether I am even allowed to look or talk to the baby. And I even worry now that everyone else will pick up on this and think I am disinterested.

I've asked my partner and my friend advice as I've been careful to make sure I haven't overstepped the mark, and have been supportive, but questioned myself. They have assured me I have not.

Please please help me, I am so distraught.

Smileless2012 Fri 24-Jan-25 09:01:09

This is a very difficult, upsetting and stressful situation you find yourself in Anomaly and despite your D saying otherwise, there is clearly an issue here.

No longer allowing you to have physical contact with your GC, while allowing a non family member to do so while you're there is I'm sorry to say, extremely unkind as is ensuring that the baby is positioned so you can't even see him/her.

Being estranged from our youngest son and only GC, I completely understand your very real concerns about following your friend's advice, but I agree with her.

A conversation with your D and her partner needs to be held with your partner present too, as the growing tense atmosphere will affect him too and may begin to affect your GC.

Something has happened and you need to know why they're behaving so ungraciously to someone who has done so much. Their behaviour is completely unacceptable and there's nothing wrong with you saying so.

In the long term, a relationship where one is unable to be honest about how they feel about how they're being treated, is not a healthy one.

flowers.

Anomaly Fri 24-Jan-25 09:05:44

Thank you for responding. I am honestly in tears. I didn't sleep at all last night. I am questioning whether I should ask again for a cuddle this morning.

My partner is extremley upset for me and has also suggested speaking to them together. I just don't want to rock the boat, but know that the longer I leave it, the worse it will become.

BlueBelle Fri 24-Jan-25 09:15:35

I don’t think you should ask for a cuddle but you should ask why you are not allowed to see your grandchild and say you need the truth however bad it is and you need to all sit down and get some information out…. all this tip toeing around is doing no one any good
Sounds to me as if the partner asked or told her not to leave the baby with you when she went to the beauty parlour and because she did you re all being punished
It may well be his culture that the woman does his bidding it doesn’t make him a bad person just a different way of seeing and doing things but much harder to work around

Luckygirl3 Fri 24-Jan-25 09:21:47

I think "asking for a cuddle" might not be the way forward. Perhaps try standing back and just saying you are here to help if needed, and then get on with your life.

This must all be so stressful in your own home. Most things like this settle in their own time and I think that standing back is the way to go. If things do not improve then you might need to talk with them both about future plans.

Living in mixed generation families does not always work and maybe this couple need to plan for a more independent life as they are grown adults and now parents.

You are facing cultural as well as generational challenges here; and your DD's partner may simply not really want to be with you at all. But if that is the case he needs to step up and organize an independent life for himself and his partner.

There is no more you can do at this moment I feel. Stand back a bit and see how things play out. There is no reason to think you have done anything wrong here - on the contrary you have been very accommodating.

Anomaly Fri 24-Jan-25 09:38:51

I'm now torn, as her Partner's mum is not restricted to cuddles, neither is her partner's sister. It just appears to me, us. I have even asked for cuddles when my partner is not here in case it was my partner that they didn't want to hold the baby. And her partner's mum is now babysitting for Valentines day so I am confused as to why leaving the baby with me is any different to leaving the baby with his mum.

I am also concerned as my daughter has said his mum has three dogs and she told her partner she was uncomfortable with the dogs being around the baby, and then her partner introduced the dog to the baby. She was upset with this.

So it literally feels like it is only us.

I will keep out of the way today in my office, but this is what life has felt like lately in my own home.

Yesterday my daughter said something which i thought was strange. Her partner was no longer going to work saturdays so that he could have time with the baby. This means a pay cut of £1,000.00 a month my daughter said, but that he would rather sacrifice now. I agreed with her as you can't get thos precious time back, but it kind of blew what I thought. That it was that he just didn't want to be here, because if he didn't, he would be working to move.

Smileless2012 Fri 24-Jan-25 09:38:57

This needs to get sorted one way or another Anomaly as the stress is obviously getting to you.

Having been so incredibly supportive and accommodating, I would think that the last thing they, and especially your D would expect, would be you following your friend's advice and telling them that due to the atmosphere, you'd understand if they felt that living with you was no longer what they want and wish to leave.

This could be the wake up call they need. Of course you don't want to rock the boat but I do agree that the longer you leave this, the worse it will become flowers.

Smileless2012 Fri 24-Jan-25 09:44:51

I think your D's partner taking such a large pay cut when they're living with you is rather concerning Anomaly because it will be even more unlikely that they will be able to move into a place of their own.

You really do need to tell them that the present situation where they appear to be deliberately withholding their baby from you is unacceptable. If they wish to continue living there, there needs to be an honest exchange of opinions and feelings as the current arrangement isn't sustainable.

IMO you D's partner has no right to reduce his monthly income which he can only do because they're living with you, while you're being treated in this way and your D shouldn't be supporting this either.

Lathyrus3 Fri 24-Jan-25 10:36:15

If he can earn £1000 for four Saturdays work, they can afford to rent somewhere!

Normally I’d say be careful or they might cut you out of their lives altogether, but actually they pretty much have already, except as a financial support. And the way things are is just making you unhappy.

So really you’ve got nothing to lose by telling them it’s time to find a place of their own. You still love them and will help them when they want, but this is making you unhappy.

Katyj Fri 24-Jan-25 10:38:07

Goodness what a terrible situation for you both. I can understand you don’t want to rock the boat and make things worse, but how much worse can they be, your not allowed to see your grandchild even though you are in the same house.
They should be grateful you’re giving them a roof over their head.
I don’t think you should ask for cuddles at the moment as it’ll just be pushing their buttons.
Ask your daughter for a day and time you can all sit down and talk, no matter how difficult, you need to find out the problem. Clearly there’s something very wrong here, and it’s impossible to move forward until it’s aired.

Katyj Fri 24-Jan-25 10:45:39

Just another thought. Could they be thinking of moving away? And they don’t want you to become too attached to the baby. Although if that were the case I would have thought he would have needed the extra money. He can’t afford to turn down 4k a month.

woodenspoon Fri 24-Jan-25 10:58:44

Could there be an element of coercive control going on here. Does he want to move in with his mother and sister? You mention he didn’t want to leave his mother. Why would his sister get control of the baby if they split up? It sounds very strange.

Anomaly Fri 24-Jan-25 11:43:57

Thank you for all your helpful comments. It has been really useful.

I guess my relationship with my daughter and what we have built really came through this morning. She came down and the baby was really clingy. I obviously looked really sad and down and she said I can tell you are upset and we had a heart to heart.

I am so grateful for that talk. It has taken us years to get to this stage. Communicating healthily without getting angry. I did what luckygirl3 suggested and asked if I could be any help and she gave the baby to me.

It does seem he was angry that she went to the beauty parlour. I did say I could hear some of what he was saying even though I had the door shut and the TV on so she couldn't really deny it. I also said how I was hurt that I was no longer baby sitting valentines day, but that it will be nice for his mum (whom he hasn't actually asked yet). I am sure I will get another chance.

She also said because he is back to work, he wants to see the baby in the evening, with no interuptions which I fully understand and I will respect that boundary. She also said I can come upstairs, she only stays up there because the baby is asleep and she will come down and do bottles etc whilst the baby sleeps. I just didn't want to encroach.

What her partner doesn't realise, is that I don't actually see the baby during the day. I mostly work from my home office, and do a lot of site visits, sometimes all day. So I think he feels I see the baby all day and his mum doesn't, which is not the case.

I was very proud of her and she stood her ground and did say he was trying to alienate her family. His response to all the baby items was that my brother can have it all back and my daughter stood her ground. One thing he has said though is her best friend can no longer be godmother as she did not come over soon enough after the birth and hasn't called enough. She has said that he will need to tell her that. That is not a fair position to put my daughter in.

There has been a lot of compromising. I am so proud of her. His sister wanted to have the baby Friday to Monday every month, and she has said no. It is too much. They also go to his mums a lot and she is getting exhausted everyone wanting to see the baby, and having to drive around. I once again, said that his family is more than welcome here anytime if its easier for them to visit and I will go out for the day to give them space.

His mum is on her own, and does have other grandchildren too from her daughter, so I guess him being her son, she doesn't see him as much as she would like, or as much as she did her daughters children when they were young. For me, this is my first grandchild, so I obviously want to see him as much as I can as well.

I am away next weekend, my son is back to uni, so they have the whole house to themselves and I susggested maybe they could tell both families they are not doing any visits and having a quiet family weekend/or invite his family over.

I think he is just not used to communicating healthily/ practising conflict avoidance, he is in his early 20s and my daughter and I have worked on our communication a lot, and he just has never had to do that, and normally festers resentment and is unforgiving.

He now feels awkward after me asking them if I had done something wrong yesterday. To be fair, my daughter said that I am just upset. There was no raising voices, I simply said I was hurt, and saying how I felt, and everyone is entitled to their feelings. She also said, that is my mum and I don't want to see her upset (my heart is filled with pride at how far we have come).

She also said that I didn't speak to him last night, but I pointed out that actually, he came home, I waved at him from my office window, and opened the door to him and said hi darling, which I always say. I also said that it goes both ways, he can also say hello too. I will make more of an effort tonight with him, as I don't want him to feel uncomfortable either.

As for not working saturdays, I am going to be selling and moving in a year, and they also want to be in their own place by the end of the year so there is a mutual understanding there. She did actually say they want to stay as long as possible, so it isn't that they don't want to be here. I cannot see them as a family wanting to move with us, nor my partner wanting to purchase a home in the scenario we are in now.

So thank you for all your messages. I was so beside myself upset this morning as this has been going on a week and it was unbearable. I am more a peace keeper, and I don't like conflict.

I just hope this continues, and no issues come up like this again.

Angelnan Fri 24-Jan-25 11:47:10

A very awkwardly situation. You have been extremely accommodating and understanding.
Please can you and your daughter and respective partners sit down and discuss the situation and future plans?
Generational and cultural differences aside that should be a given while they are supported family and you are all adults.
There are several issues:-
The reduction in contact with your grandchild
Their refusal to discuss the issue Perceived preferential treatment of others
A lack of ongoing planning for their future in your home.
Your grandchild is a position of birth, it carries no rights but is assumed a given.
I know from my own experience that we somehow need to gain trust. You've done everything right (bar asking for cuddles; it makes you sound needy), so there is clearly something else wrong.
Coercion may not be far off the mark.

dragonfly46 Fri 24-Jan-25 11:53:22

So good to hear your update Anomaly, communication is key and it seems to be working. I hope things work out for you.

Katyj Fri 24-Jan-25 13:46:50

Ahh glad to hear you’ve had a chat. It’s not easy living together especially with a baby. Hope it works out for you all.

Smileless2012 Fri 24-Jan-25 13:57:16

Great to read your update Anomaly, your D sounds marvellous and more then able to stand her ground when she thinks her partner is in the wrong.

Telling him he will have to tell her friend she can't be godmother was exactly the right approach. Like woodenspoon and Angelnan, I suspect there is an element of at least an attempt to coercive control but as long as your D stays strong and true to herself she'll be OK.

I hope you can rest easy and just enjoy being the loving mum, GM and potential m.i.l. that you clearly are,

AmberGreen Sun 23-Mar-25 14:11:00

There is a mindset of anti-M.I.L. feed by stereotypes which are outdated and harmful. You have crept about in the hope of avoiding them, some of us have crossed the line and been totally misrepresented for suggesting a newborn has a family names proposed Enter slammed door and demands for apology.

It is more vicious when the partner is of a different culture and the daughter less inclined towards equality than she might be and your situation is a case in point. Your daughter's wants to be in charge, but how can he be? It is your home, your money, and it humiliates him. So he plays the card he can to make himself feel better. Who is this other man who can look after his child for an hour and a half while your daughter is out? Questions which do not need to be asked come into play at a point where she has just given birth and is susceptible.

If she has an ounce of gumption or common sense she will eventually see this. Meanwhile do not be hurt. Do not do anything. Smile. Any discussion at this point will end badly. I know it it hurts when the MIL stereotype is thrown at you, but you are not alone and, eventually, if you just go on being the kind and good parent you are his antics will be exposed for what they are, pure jealous nastiness.

Skydancer Sun 23-Mar-25 17:05:28

The bottom line is she’s scared of him. I don’t think you are the problem.

Oreo Sun 23-Mar-25 17:41:20

Marrying into another culture is fraught with problems.Women aren’t thought to be equal to men and there are no liberal Western values.
Tbh I don’t know how you and your partner and daughter can stand for it.Doesn’t bode well for a long happy marriage.

eazybee Sun 23-Mar-25 18:28:48

Your daughter has got herself into a mess, and I don't think this time you are going to be able to sort it for her. The partner is increasingly controlling, beginning to isolate her from family and friends, cutting down his income and threatening her with taking the baby away and letting his sister bring him up, should 'anything' happen. It doesn't sound like a peaceful relationship.

Lack of cuddles and missed baby-sitting opportunities are trivial by comparison.Unless it is imperative don't sell your house just yet; say nothing to either of them but watch and note.

Franski Sun 23-Mar-25 18:36:52

Dear anomaly.
I just read the whole thread including the update.. Gosh. It's a lot. It sounds like you have a really good friend who can see what's going on and might be a good sounding board going forward. I know how layered and complex family dynamics are and if there was a simple solution to things like housing/ rental then it wouldn't be a problem. Do there is no quick fix. You sound like an incredibly caring, self sacrificing and sensitive soul. It can lead to tiptoeing around a bit and that can lead to you being used and then disrespected even by your DD. Please take good care of yourself because your needs matter too. Love and all good wishes xx please update us again