Gransnet forums

AIBU

Should I have been a better person?

(39 Posts)
DotScot Fri 01-May-26 17:51:29

About 30 years ago, my mother (then in her 60s) saw an offer of topsoil. She ordered 15 tons of it as she was a keen gardener and was displeased with the quality of the soil she had in her garden.
The soil was delivered in a huge heap to the pavement and road at the end of the drive to their house in a cul-de-sac. She then called my brother and me, at the time both working full-time, with small children, and asked us to come the next day, a Saturday, and move it for her. To be honest, I don’t think she’d had any idea what 15 tons of soil would look like. Not that she admitted that.
We both turned up and worked for several hours to shovel and barrow it to the back garden, and to the beds in the front garden. It was difficult to distribute it all because the gardens were not that large.
We both thoroughly resented that we were asked to do this job. Our mother didn’t really give us any room to say no. Our two (younger) siblings were either not asked or did say no - we never discovered. We were thin-lipped when we arrived, and the whole time we were doing it, we grumbled and made sarcastic jokes with each other, although our mother did not hear any of that because she stayed out of the way, inside the house while we worked. It was pretty hard work too, for a civil servant and a teacher, not used to manual labour. We were thanked at the time, but much in the way that you’d thank someone for doing some small thing. The whole thing was never mentioned again (except between my brother and me as a private running joke.)
I think now that my mother was likely embarrassed about having ordered so much, probably in error, and it being so visible to her neighbours. Appearances were always important to her.
My question is this. If I was a better person, having agreed to do the job, should I have done it with ‘a good grace’ and not grumbled about it? Should I have been sympathetic and tactful about my mother’s probable mistake and been pleased to help her out of an awkward situation? Obviously I can’t change the past, and my daughter says I should just forget about it. But it does prey on my conscience that I was not nicer about it at the time. What do you G’netters think?

SheepyIzzy Sat 02-May-26 13:34:29

I read this post today and laughed. YOU have nothing to worry about, thinking back, you should have said no, told her to get a labourer. I say this because also, almost 30 years ago, MY MUM did a very similar thing to my sister and her husband. The house where they live, she deeded it to my sister and because the garden was old, rickety, FIXED WITH CONCRETE broken slabs and wonky, on a slant, mum decided to "order (get free) topsoil from someone she knew" so it could be levelled.

So soil came whilst sister/husband were at work and mum pointed to where it was to be tipped (right where they parked their cars!)

I think there was abit of ranting at the time, don't blame them, "Only trying to help!" Mums comment!

I do remember it took them a hot weekend to shift it all!

Gran22boys Sat 02-May-26 14:52:09

My DH ordered several tons of topsoil some years ago. It was dumped at the front of our house. But it was clay and clearly not topsoil. DH rang the company and insisted they come and collect it all which they did. You should never have been asked to do this. It’s ridiculous.

HelterSkelter1 Sat 02-May-26 14:54:46

My list of things I wish I hadn"t said or done is very long especially when I add the things I should have done and didn"t. Too late now and if anything good comes out of it it is to think before I speak or do now
Forgive yourself OP. What you and your bro did was amazing and I hope Mum brought out lots of drinks and snacks. She should of course have been trundling the wheelbarrow herself as well.
Any chance of you and DB having a dig over in my flowerbeds??

HelterSkelter1 Sat 02-May-26 14:59:19

I have just googled AI and 15 tons of topsoil in a conical pile will be 4 or 5 feet high and 10 or so feet wide at the base. It sounds like that thing in Close Encounters of the Third Kind. Did a spaceship swoop over it?

MissAdventure Sat 02-May-26 17:29:01

15 tons, and what do ya get?
Another day older and deeper in debt.

Gwyllt Sat 02-May-26 21:06:41

Very impressed with your shifting ability. Took me most of a day to shift one tone of gravel not a great distance It was some thirty years ago and as a smallholder I was pretty fit and strong

Whiff Sun 03-May-26 06:43:15

You both did what your mom wanted you to do. Be proud you did it and it showed how much you loved your mom . 30 years ago time to let it go the past is gone .

SpinDriftCoastal Sun 03-May-26 06:50:52

As my offspring says, 'I only have so much bandwidth'. You did the job despite feeling resentful so in reality it got done. If all the resentful tasks of a lifetime were added up we would be drowning in them. Look back, acknowledge you helped your mum and make sure you never do the same to your children. Relax and look forward.

Oreo Sun 03-May-26 08:45:54

We should all have been better people, unless there are a few saints among us.
On this particular OP subject, I don’t blame you for grumbling as you did it, but you did it!
Your Mum didn’t realise it would be dumped at the end of her drive, and turned to family to help her out.Which you did.

Sadgrandma Sun 03-May-26 10:15:13

Goodness if I were to dwell on things I did 30 years ago I would be a nervous wreck! As others have said you can’t change the past. However I would say that, in my opinion, you have nothing to feel guilty about. You did the work for your Mum, even if you did grumble, and she was grateful so take comfort in that. Perhaps it is your younger siblings who should feel guilty.

henetha Sun 03-May-26 10:22:22

I think you did brilliantly. So it's time to close the door on this and move on.
There's loads of things I might have done differently, but now I just try to live in the moment and forget the past.

JaneJudge Sun 03-May-26 10:25:43

I love that you are asking us a 30 year old question smile were you so mad you buried her under it?

LemonJam Sun 03-May-26 10:55:13

You and your brother did a hard and unpleasant job (your other siblings didn't) which I am sure your Mum appreciated. It has given you and your brother the pleasure of a running joke over the years since.

There's no human being on the planet that could claim they did every unwelcome and unpleasant task in their life with "good grace". Cut yourself some slack and you have nothing to feel guilty about. 💐