Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Winter Flu Jabs - for or against?

(180 Posts)
grannysue05 Sun 08-Oct-17 14:27:15

The letters have dropped on our mats this weekend....You know, the invitation to attend for flu jabs.
DH and I have never opted for the jabs, and , fingers crossed, have only had real flu twice in all our years (late seventies).
We have friends who religiously take up the offer. Most have a 'reaction" within days, but that passes. The sore arm goes on for a week or more.
Most of the friends have then gone on to catch flu later in that paticular winter. Mostly from GC's .
I have read that the treated virus's are taken from the previous years' flu epidemic, and a mix is made up from this.
The flu that arrives each season has mutated from the previous year, so the actual vaccination serum is not really relevant.
Are we wise to keep pumping in these foreign bodies?
Can we not rely on our immune systems?

LizHand Wed 11-Oct-17 11:40:57

Always took advantage of office freebie but will continue at own cost...just to be safe or at least reduce worst of symptoms apparantly and spread as carrier. Wish Uni's also did for vulnerable students!

David1968 Wed 11-Oct-17 11:14:22

Like Craftycat, I paid for mine before I was 65 and got it free. (I had real flu' once - it's awful and I felt like I would die.) I understand that the jab is £5 at Asda this year. (Other supermarkets also offer it but it seems Asda are the cheapest.) I can't understand why you wouldn't have the jab. Sandelf has summed it up beautifully, I think.

maryeliza54 Wed 11-Oct-17 11:12:35

www.nhsemployers.org/flumatters

I think a GP or any front line health worker who doesn’t have a jab ( and it’s official advice that they do) is being very irresponsible. By definition they will often be seeing more older/younger and more vulnerable patients Given how many patients a GP sees in a day, think how many patients could be infected in the few days before they realised they had it.

Maidmarion Wed 11-Oct-17 11:07:48

I've had to rearrange my flu jab from next Saturday as am 'down with the flu'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Craftycat Wed 11-Oct-17 10:59:13

I've had it for years-I paid before I turned 60. I had it done last week with one to protect against Peumonia- which I cannot spell. One in each arm. Never have had any sort of reaction or sore arm & although am not keen on needles it is over in a flash.
Having once had real flu I am not risking that again

granoftwins Wed 11-Oct-17 10:55:55

I have just had mine-free as I am an NHS volunteer. OH had his at Morrisons where it was £8.
No reaction at all.
I started having one after I had flu one year and was ill from Christmas Eve until March. I never want a repeat if that.

henetha Wed 11-Oct-17 10:52:05

I had my flu jab last week and as usual no bad reaction at all,
I've been having them for about 20 years now and they work for me. No flu, and no bronchitis which used to plague me before flu jabs started.
Real flu is a dreadful thing, much worse then just a cold.
And I've had the pneumonia jab.
We are so lucky to have these preventatives.

SusieB50 Wed 11-Oct-17 10:49:50

I read an article last week in the paper guardian or times I can't remember which, that the flu jab for the over 65's doesn't work . I've had mine even though I'm over the hill . My mother of 95 has declined this year -"not worth it " she says !

sandelf Wed 11-Oct-17 10:46:01

For yourselves - flu is a killer - at best, if you get, it you are properly ill for 4 - 6 weeks and weakened for months - during which you are more vulnerable to any other bugs about - the 'social' season is rapidly approaching.
For other people - the fewer people have influenza, the fewer to pass it on - the effect of immunisations is cumulative in the community. We are so lucky to live in a country that encourages us to care for ourselves and others.

2mason16 Wed 11-Oct-17 10:42:27

I returned recently from a 3 wk stay with daughter and family in Australia. We all caught the flu 3 days after I arrived! So my whole stay was dreadful. I'm 65 and never had it before. It knocked me out completely. I certainly hope it does'nt arrive on our shores. As yet I have'nt had flu jab - not sire what to do!

maryhoffman37 Wed 11-Oct-17 10:39:51

I have it every year as I have in the past had pneumonia and chest infections. My lungs are my only weak point - I was born with bronchitis. If this can stop any URTI viruses, I'm happy to have it.

ExaltedWombat Wed 11-Oct-17 10:33:39

I asked my GP if he had the flu jab. He doesn't, so I don't.

JanaNana Wed 11-Oct-17 10:28:39

I have had the flu a couple of times over the years and is not something I would like to experience again, so I always have a flu jab now. I was also given a pneumonia jab as well about five years ago which should last for ten years. This year I was invited for a shingles jab which initially I did"nt think necessary as I had shingles ten years ago (another very unpleasant experience) however I spoke to the practise nurse who told me you can get it more than once so took the advice and had the jab.

MinniesMum Wed 11-Oct-17 10:17:35

I am asthmatic with COPD so I have had flu jabs for years. Like another poster the only time I felt unwell was when I had the pneumonia jab as well but it passed off quickly.
I used to get at least four or five nasty colds every year but rarely get even one now. I think the last one was 18 months ago. I think it does offer a high level of protection and we had ours last week. Tiny sore lump on my arm for 24 hours but only felt it if I rubbed my arm.

Nezumi65 Wed 11-Oct-17 08:00:27

Take some vitamin D (& go outside on sunny days if you can - although it's not always easy to get enough vitamin D in the winter)

www.nhs.uk/news/food-and-diet/add-vitamin-d-to-food-to-prevent-colds-and-flu-say-researchers/

Anya Wed 11-Oct-17 06:50:47

Of course people who want to should have the vaccine but don’t rely on it to fully protect you. Older people in particular should take measures to help prevent themselves being infected, and they can also look at lifestyle changes which might give them the best change of boosting their immune systems too.

Anya Wed 11-Oct-17 06:46:59

NanKate ‘Fluarix Tetra’ means it contains four (tetra) subtypes of flu virus. The Australian outbreak was type H. Despite what your chemist has told you there simply hadn’t been time to manufacture a vaccine to specifically include the type H3 in this years vaccine - it was ordered months ago.

Here is a quote from Simon Stevens, CEO of NHS England

“Australia and New Zealand had just experienced a heavy burden of winter flu cases, raising concerns that Britain may experience the same in the next few months.

“The signs from Australia and New Zealand, who are just coming out of their winter, are that it has been a heavy flu season and many of the hospitals down there have struggled to cope,” Stevens told the Health and Care Innovation Expo in Manchester.

“The southern hemisphere has just experienced its worst flu season in many years, and previous experience suggests Britain may be hit by the same H3 strain this winter.

The World Health Organisation is now reviewing the efficacy of the flu vaccine used in Australia and New Zealand to prepare for the last winter. The NHS’s own annual campaign is due to start within weeks, using a vaccine ordered months ago. Questions may now be raised about whether it will prove effective if the same H3 strain arrives in Britain.”

ajanela Wed 11-Oct-17 01:33:30

Grannysue your impression of the flu jab doesn't seem to be supported by gransnetters comments. A heavy cold is not the flu.

After WW1 there was a flu pandemic which is thought to have wiped out 1/5 of the worlds population.

I would rather benifit from any protection the flu jab can give me, it must be more than crossing my fingers,

NanKate Tue 10-Oct-17 19:32:20

Hi All, as I said earlier the Pharmacist at Boots said that the flu jab he was giving us covers 4 strains of flu - two A virus subtypes and two B types (whatever that means) he confirmed the Australian one was one of these. It was called Fluarix Tetra.

However you may be receiving a different brand that does not cover the Australian strain. We shall all have to face the waiting game ?

gillybob Tue 10-Oct-17 19:09:47

Maybe I didn't make myself clear . Sorry.

I do pay for my prescriptions but got my flu jab free due to an underlying condition. I was just wondering for someone else I know .
Thank you for your replies .

Barmyoldbat Tue 10-Oct-17 19:04:01

Never had the flu jab but this year, yesterday in fact, I actually had one. I have never had the flu and can't remember the last time I had a cold or chest infection but around Christmas I am going to have my new knee and I don't want anything to get in the way of that. So I thought just in case...

glassortwo Tue 10-Oct-17 18:56:26

gilly I had to pay for mine before I was diagnosed with asthma, I am also a carer for FIL and DM so given free,

harrigran Tue 10-Oct-17 17:21:38

I have been given an appointment for flu jab for tomorrow. We are having a family get together and everyone is poorly, I am taking no chances.

Anya Tue 10-Oct-17 17:19:30

You are correct valerie - I’ve been doing a bit of research and as Faye also pointed out this years vaccine will NOT protect against the Australian strain.

valeriej43 Tue 10-Oct-17 13:54:00

Crohns disease