If only we all scrimped on Christmas, then it wouldn't be the totally commercial obscenity it has become. I don't mean to sound like a Scrooge, as I love to buy gifts for my family, but struggle to know what to get some of them, as 2 of the gc just request money to go shopping (16 & 12). I agree with labazs (I also work in a charity shop) and we have some beautiful items donated, some of which are new, unwanted gifts. Also, in my view, something that has been made is of greater value, as more effort has been put into it. You could make up small hampers to include small pots of jam, marmalade, chutney, sweets, chocs or biscuits. If you're handy with a needle, what about a making a cushion? The pads are cheap enough to buy, and the material can be bought quite reasonably at a local market. Failing that: books, gift vouchers, jigsaw puzzles, games, flowers, plants? So sad that nobody wishes to buy your piano. We had the same problem when selling my late father's, which held so many happy memories for us. In the end, we donated it to a local residential home. Let us know what you decide to do, and don't forget the charity shops!