Gransnet forums

Blogs

Whatever happened to grammar and spelling?

(231 Posts)
CariGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 27-Sept-12 08:42:20

This week's guest blog post is one to appeal to the pedants amongst us <raises hand enthusiastically>

Do add your comments here.

The authors of the post - Katherine Fry and Rowena Kirton - have two signed copies of their book to give away and will be picking their favourite comments left between now and midday on Thurs 4 October to win them. It goes without saying that comments are welcome at any time - not just up to the closing date.

Beachee Mon 22-Oct-12 20:28:00

Many moons ago, when my children were in primary school, the class had been copying a photo of a leopard in their art lesson. The teacher had put all of their wonderful artwork on the wall and had written a big sign underneath ... "Do you like our lepers?" hmm

Joan Tue 23-Oct-12 03:22:47

AAArrrgh - he/she'd probably been misled by spell check after getting leopard wrong. But how could he/she not have realised?

absentgrana Tue 23-Oct-12 09:10:38

Beachee My daughter when little wrote about visiting her grandparents and taking the dog for a walk along the sward, which is what they called the expanse of grass behind the beach where they lived. Her teacher "corrected" it to sword. Quite an achievement for two adults, one child and a Yorkshire terrier.

Beachee Tue 23-Oct-12 12:30:16

absentgrana smile

Greatnan Tue 23-Oct-12 17:23:12

My grandson's class were studying the Boer war . Unfortuntely, the teacher labelled the display 'The Boar War'. I didn't tell her.

absentgrana Tue 23-Oct-12 17:26:22

Greatnan Would that have been the one that ended at Bosworth Field in 1415?

annodomini Tue 23-Oct-12 17:27:00

Nice one absent.

crimson Tue 23-Oct-12 17:35:32

I was reading an article bout Edna O'Brien last night, and she said how well she wrote when the urban foxes had kept her awake and she was 'unslept'. I was trying to work out [not being very up to speed with grammar] what sort of word unslept is. I felt that she'd used it in the wrong way, but it sounded perfect. I intend to steal it and use it for myself in the future.

AlieOxon Tue 23-Oct-12 18:12:14

Underslept is good too! That's me today....

annodomini Tue 23-Oct-12 18:57:07

If one can oversleep, logically it should be possible to undersleep. When was our language ever logical?

Jendurham Wed 24-Oct-12 14:28:50

I was a teacher at the time your daughter was at school. I always used to correct spellings, though not always all of them. It could be too discouraging to some pupils. However, I never used to put sp. in the margin, and I never used a red pen.
What is the point of telling children they cannot spell and then not giving them the correct spelling? They would have to write out the correct spelling in a small book, after I had written it in their work.
However, what was more important was to tell children they could spell most words correctly. In most pieces of writing there are only a few words misspelt. I consider myself fortunate that I do not have problems with spelling. I taught myself to read sitting on my dad's knee, while he read the newspaper to me before I was 5.

FlicketyB Wed 24-Oct-12 19:02:06

Underslept? Irish English, like 'having drink taken'

My 5 year old GD, in a primary school recently classed as failing for very minimal reasons, is busy mastering the rules of punctuation; commas, full stops, exclamation and question marks.

Spelling is can be taught formally but is mainly learnt by reading. My spelling was good because I was an early and omniverous reader. Pronunciation was a bit wobbly because I could read many words before I ever heard them said.

Ana Wed 24-Oct-12 19:47:25

Yes, same here - pictureskew for example! grin

AlieOxon Wed 24-Oct-12 22:19:32

Not surprised at the Irish comment - I could get an Irish passport....

My spelling ok except for one or two quirky words - an early reader again. But I still remember the first time I met 'ascertain' in dictation!

annodomini Wed 24-Oct-12 22:26:36

Now I remember dictation. I'm sure children nowadays don't have that exercise. I was a good speller in primary school but when I got to secondary school I suddenly became a perfect speller, and I could never understand what made the difference. Maybe learning other languages? When I taught second language speakers in Kenya, in almost five years, I only ever had one pupil who was a bad speller.

Beachee Wed 24-Oct-12 22:30:00

in my experience (as a TEFL/ESOL teacher), the "bad spellers" are more often than not the GB variety smile

Ana Wed 24-Oct-12 22:34:59

confused

annodomini Wed 24-Oct-12 22:36:54

I suppose, Beachee that the reason is that the second-language students are learning the spelling at the same time as they are learning the language whereas native Brits learn to speak long before they learn to read or spell.

Beachee Wed 24-Oct-12 22:41:27

I think you are right there Annodomini.
We native Brits don't need to understand it in the same way

absentgrana Thu 25-Oct-12 08:42:29

It's not spelling that's a problem – it's my tendency to type in chords as my fingers attempt to keep up with my thoughts.

FlicketyB Thu 25-Oct-12 08:55:41

My fingers get confused and go on the keys in the wrong order; fro, teh and wehre are regular examples

Greatnan Thu 25-Oct-12 09:57:46

I have noticed that my ability to recall the spelling of any word I have ever met seems to have diminished with age. I usually do know the correct spelling, but I have lost some of my confidence, so I always press check before I post. Some of the interpretations make me smile!

AlieOxon Thu 25-Oct-12 13:52:56

I think my fingers have dyslexia, especially in the evening!

Stansgran Thu 25-Oct-12 15:37:18

and today in S'bury's their delicious guinea fowl were of course FOUL- I'm optimistic that the poor creatures will be on the reduced shelf tomorrow night and I will be able to bag a few for the freezer.

absentgrana Thu 25-Oct-12 16:00:05

I have just remembered my favourite of all time – a sign on a south coast beach. Do not collect muscles from the groin.