Gransnet forums

Blogs

All you need is a good man

(154 Posts)
CariGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 25-Apr-13 07:40:11

In middle age Anna Wallas came to the conclusion that the feminists had it wrong and that having a good man to look after is what happiness is all about.

Do you agree? Read her guest blog post and let us know.

Sel Mon 06-May-13 23:53:53

Respect to your son in law Greatnan that's a horrible stretch of water.

Greatnan Mon 06-May-13 23:19:31

Galen - he is a captain on the Interislander, the huge ferry that connects North and South Islands. He gave up deep sea trips when he met my daughter!

Sel Mon 06-May-13 22:38:51

How breathtakingly sensible ps I couldn't agree more. As an adult, I have never been dependent on another person to provide for me, male or female. I have never believed in stereotyping and am happy to pitch in, whatever needs doing. I am more than happy to accept that there are things which a male can do better than me - equally there are things I can do better than my partner. I really don't understand either the feminist or alpha male perspective, what you describe as unadulterated drivel, either. We're all people with often complimentary strengths. Get over it and get on with it and stop whingeing grin.

Galen Mon 06-May-13 22:23:37

Greatnan as a ships captain does he ever come to Avonmouth or Portbury?

Nonu Mon 06-May-13 21:44:01

I like your post , PS

However, don"t think many will , ho hum

ps Mon 06-May-13 21:37:40

I am both surprised and a little dissapointed in the reactions posted here. Whilst I agree no one, whether female or male, should be dominant or submissive in any relationship I would have thought that one based on mutual respect, love, trust and caring would negate any thoughts of anyone taking advantage or seeing their partner burdened with either domestic chores or financial obligations. I don't think it is a case of "looking after a man" or woman for that matter. Surely it is a case of doing what each of us can for our partners because we want to. If we don't want to then perhaps there is something lacking in the relationship.
I can only speak for myself but if I thought any partner of mine was being burdened by any domestic chores or financial matters I would consider myself at fault and guilty of either not helping enough or providing accordingly. As it is I can wash, Iron, use a dishwasher, vacuum etc. I am slowly learning to shop efficiently and would willingly share all domestic chores. I would like to think however that chivalry is not dead and as much as pseudo feminists or alpha male stereotypes keep feeding the rest of us mere mortals unadulterated drivel we must resist their preachings and live our lives in a way that is acceptible to both parties without any advantage or otherwise being taken and have enough respect for our partners to ensure they can live and enjoy their lives without feeling they are burdened. How very sad for those that do not, in my humble opinion.

Stansgran Mon 06-May-13 09:44:52

I have Read the article. What she should be addressing seriously is her desire at all costs for publicity. On the same page in the DM is an article about weekly shopping around the world. Much much more interesting.

Greatnan Mon 06-May-13 08:03:15

You may be right, anxiousgran, and I was certainly glad that I had a good career when I wanted to divorce my husband.
My son-in-law is indeed an exceptional man. My daughter had a well paid job in England, but since they emigrated to New Zealand she does not go out to work, but she does keep pigs and chickens and grows almost all their fruit and veg. His salary as a ship's captain is enough to support them in some comfort and he loves having her at home - he works week on, week off, so they are able to enjoy the outdoor lifestyle together when he is home - the whole family loves walking, cycling, kayaking and camping.
Two of their six children are still at home, at 15 and 14, and of course they love coming home to find her there, usually cooking. She feels that it is just as important for them now as it was when they were younger.
She spends a lot of her time schooling and riding her horse and also volunteers at Riding for the Disabled, as do the two children.
She has been offered a job in New Zealand similar to the one she had in England, in Drug and Alcohol Services, and possibly when the last child has left home she may consider returning to work, although she will then be in her mid fifties.

Her three girls have been brought up to believe that a woman should be able to support herself because no matter how good a relationship you think you have, tragedy in the form of death , illness or unemployment can strike any family.

anxiousgran Sun 05-May-13 18:25:18

Never get yourself willing into financial dependence on a man.
Through bad health reasons I stopped earning my own money after 35 years of working, (with breaks to have children). I am now in what I feel is a very precarious position living off my husband's income, and I hate it.
I think it would take a special type of man not to take some sort of advantage of this situation.
My DIL is expecting her and my DS's 1st baby soon and she is intending to return to full time work after 12 months. I haven't influenced her decision at all, but I am quite relieved, even though the man involved is my loving and reliable son, brought up to respect women. Luckily I am in a position to help with child care.

Nonu Sun 05-May-13 15:17:20

Sheer bliss eh, Noodles .

smile

noodles Sun 05-May-13 15:00:35

Nonu Yes, and yes again. (())

Nonu Sun 05-May-13 14:16:57

ANA , ^ I know ^ x

Ana Sun 05-May-13 14:07:24

Nonu smile

Nonu Sun 05-May-13 14:04:02

I am also of the opinion that these retirement years with DH are the bestest ever .
smile

liminetta Sun 05-May-13 08:34:39

Sansgran; I agree with you; I was alone for years, but not with a career, but with three children to bring up.All that, and working made me into a thoroughly independant minded person.Then I met the man who is now my husband.28 years on, and I have seen both sides of the argument.I can now say that looking back, I am glad that I was able to experience all of it.But now, in retirement, I believe that these years with my husband are the very best of all.

LullyDully Sat 27-Apr-13 14:51:34

Married mine on the understanding that his mother never lived with us!

FlicketyB Sat 27-Apr-13 14:09:08

DH and I got married on (his) stipulation that I didn't become a domestic slave. He had had a girlfriend who he described as being lively and interesting until they became engaged when she went into full domestic slave mode and it frightened him stiff. The engagement didn't last long.

As I had already determined I would never ever be anything of the kind it was good to know I was marrying somebody who wasn't going to expect it of me.

Greatnan Sat 27-Apr-13 08:52:29

A pathetic woman? Or one with a book to sell?

FlicketyB Sat 27-Apr-13 08:49:03

To be honest, who wants to be with the kind of pathetic man who wants his wife to be a domestic slave?

Greatnan Fri 26-Apr-13 14:15:57

It is pretty obvious that she meant the blog to cause discussion. If you can't stand the heat, don't blog about your kitchen!

Notso Fri 26-Apr-13 14:15:03

Like your style when grin

Ana Fri 26-Apr-13 14:09:44

D'you think the posts were deleted just because she's a GN Guest Blogger? Perhaps she reported them!

whenim64 Fri 26-Apr-13 13:57:11

Just wondering.......what about asking for the blog itself to be deleted for offending US? grin No? Worth askin'......grin

whenim64 Fri 26-Apr-13 13:54:22

Bags I thought your deleted comments were quite kind, rather than insulting. A bit like being told what a daft ha'porth you are. Wouldn't boher me a jot! grin

Greatnan Fri 26-Apr-13 13:45:53

Bags - grin You are a little minx sometimes, but I like you!