Gransnet forums

Blogs

EmilyGransnet (GNHQ) Wed 15-Oct-14 13:28:41

The invisible elderly

Why do our perceptions of people change as they age? Are they not the same people just because they have a few more lines on their faces? Author Nicci Gerrard discusses the invisibility of the elderly and that strange moment when she looked in the mirror and didn't recognise the older lady looking back at her.

Nicci Gerrard

The Twilight Hour

Posted on: Wed 15-Oct-14 13:28:41

(173 comments )

Lead photo

Nicci Gerrard

Not so long ago, I was charging along a narrow aisle of a large department store, on an errand, late, harassed, hot, grumpy and unkempt, and I met a middle-aged woman coming running towards me. I noticed that she looked a bit like a demented crow; she had a gaunt face and lines around her eyes and on her face was an anxious expression. I think her shirt was wrongly buttoned. She was obviously in a hurry. I put up a hand in apology and she put her hand up as well – and I realised that she was me. I was looking at myself in a mirror. I was that demented crow.

So this was how I looked to strangers when I was running through a department store on an errand: not slim and poised and purposeful but scrawny, worried and slightly unhinged. It was a grim and hilarious revelation. We think the world sees us more or less the way we see ourselves, but in fact there’s a radical mismatch. The older we get, the more the gap between our own sense of our self and the world’s widens. How many of us look in the mirror and think: but that’s not me, not the real me, the one I carry round inside myself.

My gallant and fabulous mother is in her eighties. She is registered blind, has had multiple strokes and cancer; she has been an invalid for decades because of botched medical treatment for a bad back; she has arthritic hands and swollen ankles. But she thinks of herself as young and has the spirit of someone in her twenties (or maybe younger), someone endlessly ardent and hopeful, setting out on life’s journey. When strangers meet her, they look past of her complicated, resilient, stubborn character and what they see is her age and her frailty. They admire her because she is old. They no longer see the person that she is, so brimful of ambition and desire.

The older we get, the more the gap between our own sense of our self and the world's widens. How many of us look in the mirror and think: but that's not me, not the real me, the one I carry round inside myself.


My beloved father has always been a mild-mannered, courteous, private person, very stoical and very sweet-tempered, but also a practical joker and an eccentric inventor of devices to make my mother’s life easier. He was always proud of being a doctor – but now when people meet him, they bend down to him and call him dear and ask how ‘we’ are doing, as if even the correct pronoun has been lost to him and the singular erased. Or they don’t bend down at all – they talk to me and my siblings, or his carer. The nurses and doctors I have loved in hospital – where he has spent much time recently – have been the ones who sit by his bed and call him ‘Dr Gerrard’, who see beyond his wrinkles and his white hair and his vulnerability, and are respectful and attentive.

Sometimes I catch myself saying that my mother ‘was’ beautiful, when of course she still is. Or my father ‘was’ clever and kind - as if the old become like ghosts in their own life. I hear people talking about their parents, using words like ‘naughty’ or ‘silly’, like small children. (In the same way, people will often say ‘I love children’ and ‘I love old people’, stripping them of individuality and slotting them into a simple category.)

If we are lucky, we will become old. And yet our culture denies old age; we talk of ‘them’ rather than ‘us’. In my novel, The Twilight Hour, I wanted to make what is invisible visible again. Through the central character, 94-year-old Eleanor, I intended to show a whole vivid and richly complicated life: Eleanor is old, but she contains all the selves she has ever been – the stubborn child, the independent young woman, the woman in love, the teacher, the mother, the grandmother. Eleanor stands for all of us: we all want to be recognised, to be seen as individual, human and unique. We can start by the way that we look at the world, seeing others the way we want to be seen ourselves.

*The Twilight Hour by Nicci Gerrard is published by Michael Joseph on 23rd October 2014, £7.99 paperback or £4.99 ebook*

By Nicci Gerrard

Twitter: @gransnet

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 17-Oct-14 18:23:39

I must admit there are times, when I'm really feeling a bit unsure - going through airports springs to mind as an example - I'm ok with being smiled sweetly at and being made to feel "looked after". grin

(I do try to adopt the air of a world weary, very experienced traveller, but it quite often goes completely down the pan.)

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 17-Oct-14 18:24:57

(usually when the big exclamation mark comes up on the eyeball scanner because I looked at the wrong bit)

Ana Fri 17-Oct-14 18:58:43

grin

Some of you on this thread are nowhere near 'elderly' anyway!

Come back and tell us how you feel when you're over 60 and feeling even older...hmm

Ana Fri 17-Oct-14 18:59:59

Apart from feeling even older, that is...must remember to preview!

FlicketyB Fri 17-Oct-14 19:14:12

thatbags I disagree, labels attached to people should be relevant to what ever is being said about that person and, like it or not, peoples attitudes to the event are coloured by these labels.

I noticed on our local news that a road accident was reported as: 'man killed in road accident' when it first happened. When more details, like the age of the deceased was known it became 'pensioner killed in accident'. Why? What is more the moment it was described as that I bet many people would immediately have assumed it was the pensioner who was responsible for the accident 'Some old buffer that shouldn't have been driving', even before they knew he circumstances or even whether the 'pensioner' was driving.

thatbags Fri 17-Oct-14 19:28:15

I take your point, flick, but I'm not sure I agree that people "immediately", or even ever make the sort of assumptions you mention. That may be simply because I don't make those assumptions.

Everybody knows that the word pensioners covers a huge range of ages and that pensioners are not all "old buffers who shouldn't be driving".

And, even if people do make stupid and wrong assumptions, the way to challenge them, in my view, is to under-react, to take no notice, to show them the real mccoy.

I suppose I think of it in the same light as not 'feeding' the trolls.

Ana Fri 17-Oct-14 19:38:37

Isn't it more likely that the editor thought 'pensioner killed in road accident' would attract more sympathy/readers than for just 'a man', Flickety?

I suppose it boils down to the same thing though - everyone must have a label!

thatbags Fri 17-Oct-14 19:43:27

Yes, I think that explains it well, ana. And since we know how overused labels are, we can ignore them. Knowing that a man killed in a road accident is a pensioner is no more significant than knowing the man was young/black/white/third generation immigrant, a father/grandfather/the cousin of somebody famous. One can cut labels off, so to speak.

thatbags Fri 17-Oct-14 19:43:58

A man's a man for all that.

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 17-Oct-14 19:52:46

You feel more sorry for a pensioner. He can't move so fast.

What's wrong with being called a pensioner anyway?! confused

thatbags Fri 17-Oct-14 19:56:24

Your second sentence is what I'm asking too, jings.

thatbags Fri 17-Oct-14 19:58:06

Or you feel more sorry for a young man/father of two... etc, etc. The labels are used to arouse interest, to make a story. That's all.

janeainsworth Fri 17-Oct-14 23:05:42

The Newcastle Evening Chronicle usually affixes the label 'North' to anyone it is describing in any of its headlines, as in 'North Man in Transatlantic Yacht Scare', presumably so that it will resonate with, and attract the sympathy of, the maximum readership.

FlicketyB Sat 18-Oct-14 07:27:40

I have just made a complaint to the BBC. It had a news item on its online site that said that the CAB would be giving free advice to those approaching retirement on what to do with the money they had set aside in pension savings. This would be money for a pension over and above the state pension.

It should have been illustrated with a photograph of a person in their mid-60s, and probably still fit and healthy enough to be still working. Instead they used a photograph of the hands of an extremely elderly person fumbling with a few coins.

The BBC consistently illustrate all items on older people with pictures of very elderly and vulnerable people, usually women (and age and vulnerability do not go together), nor are all older people female.

It is by challenging stereotypes that attitudes change

Anya Sat 18-Oct-14 08:05:30

I've not seen that advert Flickety and I agree that's It's a good example of the worst kind of stereotyping.
But not all uses of the word 'pensioner' are intended to portray us as feeble. I'm often reading 'pensioner fights off burglars with hand bag/rolling pin' or a versions thereof in our local paper.
So perhaps the criminal fraternity (at least round here) need to learn we're not such as easy target as they imagine.

thatbags Sat 18-Oct-14 11:46:22

Well challenged, flick. I haven't seen it either but what you describe is clearly lazy journalism, of which fault the BBC is often guilty.

But I still don't think that calling me a granny (I am one) and a pensioner (I hope I shall be one) is the kind of 'stereotyping' I shall ever worry about. I don't see plain truth as stereotyping.

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 18-Oct-14 11:51:19

But, it's the very old lady fumbling with a few coins we have to worry about under the proposed new pension rules. It's a warning of how we'll all be if we go on a spending spree once we get our hands on our retirement money.

annodomini Sat 18-Oct-14 12:03:24

Opposite my house there's a road sign of a figure hobbling with a walking stick signifying elderly persons crossing. My sons seem to think it applies to me O:-)

FarNorth Sat 18-Oct-14 12:13:44

In Tesco I am almost always asked if I would like help to pack my bags. I never do want help, but it never bothered me to be asked because I know it is Tesco policy to ask all customers that.
Then a friend, in her 40's, complained to me that she would like help to pack her large amounts of shopping but it is almost never offered.
Strange....

FlicketyB Sat 18-Oct-14 13:37:13

Well, I am not a granny, I am a grandmar and would object if somebody called me a granny, in the same way I would feel if someone, other than fellow posters on Gransnet referred to me by any diminutive of FlicketyB.

What bothers me about the new relaxed pension pot rules is that there will be no restrictions on access to benefits on those who choose to waste their pension pots on reckless living. Currently if you qualify for assistance with care fees the authorities can examine how you have used any capital you had and if they think you spent or given your money away in order to qualify for state assistance they can act as if you still had that money. I think the same should apply to those who misuse pension savings.

Why should poorer working taxpayers subsidise pensioners who could have financed their old age but chose not to.

HollyDaze Sat 18-Oct-14 13:49:33

Old age is being dinned into the younger generation in a negative [way]

It certainly is - by both media and government (which is ironic given that many politicians (and male newsreaders) are hardly spring chickens themselves). Each time I hear 'and the problem of a growing population of the elderly' I could hurl something at the tv. The main issue I have with that comment being said on tv is that older people have no right of reply at the moment the comment is made or to the person saying it so the comment goes unchallenged.

Ana Sat 18-Oct-14 14:02:01

And what's more the 'problem' could have been foreseen by any of various previous governments (more people living longer because of advances in medical treatment, better nutrition in youth etc.).

But of course they chose to bury their heads in the sand because it would have cost money to even attempt to make adequate provision for the elderly and old.

HollyDaze Sat 18-Oct-14 14:17:55

Or they could put the other side of the coin Ana by stating 'and weren't we lucky to have all that extra income that paid for the NHS and pension funds from so many extra taxpayers'. Neither do they mention all the people who have paid all their various taxes for 30/40+ years but die before retirement age (so no pension) or before needing the NHS on a regular basis.

If they have mismanaged the money, the should just own up to it; that money has gone somewhere!

Ana Sat 18-Oct-14 14:22:27

Well, that's part of the problem, isn't it - that there never has been a separate 'pot' for NHI payments. It's been treated as general Treasury income.

HollyDaze Sat 18-Oct-14 14:37:30

I don't believe that either. All income would have been allocated to various needs within government so although they say it goes into one pot, the funds will have been directed into other pots so that things could be paid for. The upshot is, they still had the funds that they took and it was up to them to manage those funds efficiently.

As usual, they blame everyone but themselves.

And breathe ..... grin