Gransnet forums

Blogs

EmilyGransnet (GNHQ) Wed 15-Oct-14 13:28:41

The invisible elderly

Why do our perceptions of people change as they age? Are they not the same people just because they have a few more lines on their faces? Author Nicci Gerrard discusses the invisibility of the elderly and that strange moment when she looked in the mirror and didn't recognise the older lady looking back at her.

Nicci Gerrard

The Twilight Hour

Posted on: Wed 15-Oct-14 13:28:41

(173 comments )

Lead photo

Nicci Gerrard

Not so long ago, I was charging along a narrow aisle of a large department store, on an errand, late, harassed, hot, grumpy and unkempt, and I met a middle-aged woman coming running towards me. I noticed that she looked a bit like a demented crow; she had a gaunt face and lines around her eyes and on her face was an anxious expression. I think her shirt was wrongly buttoned. She was obviously in a hurry. I put up a hand in apology and she put her hand up as well – and I realised that she was me. I was looking at myself in a mirror. I was that demented crow.

So this was how I looked to strangers when I was running through a department store on an errand: not slim and poised and purposeful but scrawny, worried and slightly unhinged. It was a grim and hilarious revelation. We think the world sees us more or less the way we see ourselves, but in fact there’s a radical mismatch. The older we get, the more the gap between our own sense of our self and the world’s widens. How many of us look in the mirror and think: but that’s not me, not the real me, the one I carry round inside myself.

My gallant and fabulous mother is in her eighties. She is registered blind, has had multiple strokes and cancer; she has been an invalid for decades because of botched medical treatment for a bad back; she has arthritic hands and swollen ankles. But she thinks of herself as young and has the spirit of someone in her twenties (or maybe younger), someone endlessly ardent and hopeful, setting out on life’s journey. When strangers meet her, they look past of her complicated, resilient, stubborn character and what they see is her age and her frailty. They admire her because she is old. They no longer see the person that she is, so brimful of ambition and desire.

The older we get, the more the gap between our own sense of our self and the world's widens. How many of us look in the mirror and think: but that's not me, not the real me, the one I carry round inside myself.


My beloved father has always been a mild-mannered, courteous, private person, very stoical and very sweet-tempered, but also a practical joker and an eccentric inventor of devices to make my mother’s life easier. He was always proud of being a doctor – but now when people meet him, they bend down to him and call him dear and ask how ‘we’ are doing, as if even the correct pronoun has been lost to him and the singular erased. Or they don’t bend down at all – they talk to me and my siblings, or his carer. The nurses and doctors I have loved in hospital – where he has spent much time recently – have been the ones who sit by his bed and call him ‘Dr Gerrard’, who see beyond his wrinkles and his white hair and his vulnerability, and are respectful and attentive.

Sometimes I catch myself saying that my mother ‘was’ beautiful, when of course she still is. Or my father ‘was’ clever and kind - as if the old become like ghosts in their own life. I hear people talking about their parents, using words like ‘naughty’ or ‘silly’, like small children. (In the same way, people will often say ‘I love children’ and ‘I love old people’, stripping them of individuality and slotting them into a simple category.)

If we are lucky, we will become old. And yet our culture denies old age; we talk of ‘them’ rather than ‘us’. In my novel, The Twilight Hour, I wanted to make what is invisible visible again. Through the central character, 94-year-old Eleanor, I intended to show a whole vivid and richly complicated life: Eleanor is old, but she contains all the selves she has ever been – the stubborn child, the independent young woman, the woman in love, the teacher, the mother, the grandmother. Eleanor stands for all of us: we all want to be recognised, to be seen as individual, human and unique. We can start by the way that we look at the world, seeing others the way we want to be seen ourselves.

*The Twilight Hour by Nicci Gerrard is published by Michael Joseph on 23rd October 2014, £7.99 paperback or £4.99 ebook*

By Nicci Gerrard

Twitter: @gransnet

annodomini Sat 18-Oct-14 15:21:36

FlicketyB, I cannot understand the antipathy shown by you and some other grans to being called 'granny'. I have been 'granny' for almost 23 years. My two youngest GC have four grannies (one of whom is her dad's second wife and another is her GGM). That family comes from Northern Ireland and mine is from Scotland. In both countries, 'granny' is far more common than it is in England which I think is where the difference lies. I happily accept the title as an honorific

thatbags Sat 18-Oct-14 17:50:59

My mother is snooty about the word "granny". She prefers grandma so that's what we call her to her face. I think granny is much friendlier. Taking offence at an inoffensive word used inoffensively is just silly (or snooty).

She's also silly about carrying a white stick even though she's blind. I have mentioned to her that the white stick is a helpful sign for other people but I may have been wasting my breath. Hey ho.

As soon as I need a stick of any kind, I shall use one, possibly two, and if people want to think I'm a hobbly old woman, that's just fine because I will be a hobbly old woman when I need a stick (or two).

MiceElf Sat 18-Oct-14 17:56:05

Bags, tell her the Queen's grandchildren call her granny smile

MiceElf Sat 18-Oct-14 17:57:21

I'm granny too. That makes the title the one to aspire to smile

thatbags Sat 18-Oct-14 18:06:59

Shall do, mice! It'll make her think on't anyway smile

Nonu Sat 18-Oct-14 18:18:45

Mind you the queen probably takes after her own Mum, who was Scottish, I did THINK about GRANNY but one of others pipped me to the post and to be quite honest I am glad, sounds awfully OLD to me . Heyho to be sure !!grin

HollyDaze Sat 18-Oct-14 18:39:58

It probably is down to location. On the Island, the usual term is 'nana', in the Midlands, it's 'nan' or 'nanny'.

I'm not too keen on granny either. I don't know about elsewhere but a common saying in Birmingham was 'she's a real granny grunt' - not sure who granny grunt was but it was not meant as a compliment! So I tend to associate the name with that.

My eldest GD, when she's in the car with me and I'm doing a modest 40, will say 'stop driving like an old granny'! I tell her 'I am a granny' and she replies 'no you're not, you're nanny, grannies are dead old' - ouch.

annodomini Sat 18-Oct-14 18:57:46

I don't like 'granny' being used (sometimes pejoratively) as synonymous with 'old woman', especially as I was a granny at 51. However, when my GC call me 'Granny A', I feel nothing but pride.

Nonu Sat 18-Oct-14 18:59:09

HOLLY
grin

HollyDaze Sat 18-Oct-14 19:08:21

Nice to see you back Nonu - did you have a nice holiday?

FlicketyB Sat 18-Oct-14 19:54:27

I have no antipathy to being called 'granny'. I object to being called it because it is inaccurate. My DGC call me something else.

Agus Sat 18-Oct-14 19:57:27

When GD1 was born it wasn't questioned what she would call me. Granny has been a family tradition and I was thrilled to be one.

Other people have referred to me as GD's gran which doesn't bother me. How are they supposed to know what I am called? I explain I am actually granny. GDs have also corrected people by telling them, "this is my granny". Oh, how I love hearing that.

thatbags Sat 18-Oct-14 20:03:18

I don't mind if a child thinks I'm "dead old". They probably all do think that anyway. Big deal. Not.

In fact, I don't mind if anyone thinks I'm dead old. People can think what they like. Their thoughts don't make any difference to who, what and how I am.

thatbags Sat 18-Oct-14 20:09:00

What my GSs call me is Granny plus my first name. Their other granny is Granny plus her first name.

If someone speaks of me or to me as their grandma, grandmother or gran (or as a grandma, grandmother or gran) they are not being "inaccurate" because those things all mean the same thing—namely, the relationship I hold to my GC.

Regional and family preferences ditto. It all means the same.

hildajenniJ Sat 18-Oct-14 20:35:11

I'm Granny and love it.

When my DGD was born, she had three grandmothers and five great grandmothers. Some of them step-grandparents you understand. I chose to be Granny to differentiate myself from the others who are, for the most part Grandma. It's the best feeling ever to hear my little people shouting "Hello Granny" as they see me approach.

Anya Sat 18-Oct-14 20:45:57

Reading between the lines I think Flickety has a reason for saying that calling her 'granny' is inaccurate.

thatbags Sat 18-Oct-14 20:52:14

I'm sure she has a reason. That's why I only spoke about my reaction to someone referring to me with a term other than granny.

Ana Sat 18-Oct-14 20:52:40

Yes - she's called Grandma by her DGC, that's all. As she said.

thatbags Sat 18-Oct-14 20:54:45

Technically speaking, it would be inaccurate for anyone other than my GC to call me Granny, but it isn't inaccurate for anyone at all to call me a granny (or whichever equivalent term they prefer).

Anya Sat 18-Oct-14 20:55:27

I don't doubt thatbags that you were only talking about yourself - but someone accused her of antipathy.

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 18-Oct-14 20:56:13

Flickety is a granny. But she is obviously not Granny.

thatbags Sat 18-Oct-14 20:58:30

Antipathy to the word "granny" was shown. I quote: "I am not a granny".
If flickety has grandchildren, she is a granny. She is a granny who likes to be called Grandma by her grandchildren. Same as my mum.

thatbags Sat 18-Oct-14 20:59:37

None of my kids call (or called) me Mummy but I am their mum.

ffinnochio Sat 18-Oct-14 20:59:43

I really just don't get this concern with aging - how one is seen or what one is called by others.
I am how I am today. I look how I look today. All this representation by the media is just that, a representation - useful labels to use for any number of reasons as a form of shorthand.
I once did a charcoal sketch of my mother, who hated it because she said it made her look so old. What I pity. I thought it a face full of character and it captured her well.

Nonu Sat 18-Oct-14 21:06:42

HOLLY didn't I just have the best time , temps in the 80"s to 100"s.
xx