Gransnet forums

Blogs

LucyGransnet (GNHQ) Thu 01-Oct-15 12:17:18

Why do people make so much fuss?

Veteran journalist and author, Bel Mooney wonders why on earth the next generations seem to take everything so very much harder than her own does?

Bel Mooney

Why do people make such a fuss?

Posted on: Thu 01-Oct-15 12:17:18

(113 comments )

Lead photo

"Why do people make so much fuss?" asks Bel Mooney

It happened over a few days – an accumulation of irritating pinpricks of feebleness that led me to conclude that we have become a nation of wimps. I’m very active on Facebook (with a personal page as well as a community page, Bel Mooney-Writer) and it was there I started noticing the bleats.

The young author of a single novel confided that writing was 'agony' and 'an unbearable strain.' A woman whose daughter was packing to go off to university wailed that she felt full of 'grief' at the parting, and many people 'liked' this - agreeing that waving goodbye to their teenagers was one of life's cruellest traumas.

Then a reader of my Daily Mail advice column wrote to chide me for being 'mean' and 'hurtful' in my robust reply to a problem, when I had merely suggested that the guy who fancied himself in love with a woman he'd known for five minutes was deluding himself and needed to get real.

Naturally I'm continuously driven mad by the on-going rows in our universities about 'offence' given to this minority group or that. And I often wonder how many people who even go to law because of their hurt feelings were treated with kid gloves when they were children, turning them into adults who can't cope with the rough and tumble of life. A society which encourages nervous young mums to use antiseptic spray cleaner on every surface including the high chair is in thrall to wimpishness of the highest order.

Whenever I ask my mother if she felt upset by something that happened during her hard life, her response is always the same: a philosophical shrug and "You just got on with it."


When did we start making so much fuss about everything? As a child of
the fifties I remember falling over and skinning my knee and accepting this as a natural result of play. If my mother saw the graze she'd say briskly, "It'll be all right' – and carry on with what she was doing. In contrast, the other day I saw a young mother almost have hysterics because her child has scratched his arm on a rose bush and she blamed the dad for not preventing this grave injury.

"Oh come on!" I want to shout, "Toughen up - all of you!" My parents' generation (born in the 1920s) had to put up and shut up, because there was no alternative.

Whenever I ask my mother if she felt upset by something that happened during her hard life, her response is always the same: a philosophical shrug and "You just got on with it."

We baby boomers were the same, weren't we? Nobody I knew moaned about freezing floors and iced up windows (on the inside), or masses of homework, or having to write lines for misbehaviour in school, or strict uniform rules, or measly jam sandwiches for tea…because that's how it was. For everybody. Yes, we 'had it so good' later on, but as kids we were packed off to play out in all weathers. And never got a cold.

But now crying and complaining seem to be the common responses to everything. Young women take offence and get angry if a man pays a compliment and the fuss goes on for weeks. Each one of life's hardships sparks discussions of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, when the truth is this: pain is normal and so is sadness and you do - in the end - get over it. So try to control the fuss factor. Please.

Bel's new book Lifelines: Words to Help You Through is published by The Robson Press and is available from Amazon now.

By Bel Mooney

Twitter: @Gransnet

thatbags Fri 02-Oct-15 08:52:23

That's how I felt too, anno (2203 yesterday). Of course there is a sort of break in that you don't see them so often as you're used to, but that's all it is: a step in their lives and yours.

My dad (giver of loads of soundbite advice wink) used to say: Take it in your stride. I think a bit more of taking things in stride generally wouldn't go amiss.

annodomini Fri 02-Oct-15 08:54:44

My experience with my next generation is that they don't make a fuss and especially my DiLs. They don't encourage whingeing either from my DSs or from my GC!

thatbags Fri 02-Oct-15 08:56:48

Same here. I never fail to be impressed by my grown up kids' practical competence and philosophical rationality.

Elegran Fri 02-Oct-15 09:35:27

Mine are wonderfully too. I sometimes feel that I may not have achieved a great deal in my life, but knowing that we turned out three competent adults and stayed friends with all of them and their partners is a source of pleasure pride.

Seeing how they in turn are bringing up thir children is another. Not always exactly as I would have done it, but the results are excellent. All the grandchildren have inherited something from both of the families, from us and from their other parents and grandparents.

gettingonabit Fri 02-Oct-15 11:26:14

I agree about taking things in one's stride. Or "sucking things up". One thing I've noticed about parents today is how invested they are in the minutiae of their offsprings' lives. They have to be involved in everything, they have to know about the fine detail of everything: school, friends' parents' lifestyles, what they are being taught, how they are being taught, what they're eating. It's never-ending and must be exhausting, especially as everyone has to be so busy these days.

I think the one thing that stands out for me, though, is the hysteria around the trustworthiness of adults. This, as far as I can see, is a recent development. I can remember being told not to get in a car with strange men but that's about it. The current paranoia has not only created a lucrative child protection business, but has created a shift in attitude towards adults who may come into contact with children, the overwhelming majority of whom are completely blameless. So vetting has taken over from trust. Under this system, we are guilty until we are proven innocent. And that's not what civilised human society should be about.

WilmaKnickersfit Fri 02-Oct-15 11:50:32

I agree about the lack of trust in adults and I can only remember the 'don't go off with strangers' rule too.

My parents certainly didn't know everything we got up to as children. We played outside with our friends all the time and never thought twice of going out to play in the morning and not coming home until lunchtime. We never went far really, but our parents would not have been able to say what we did during the time. Until I became a teenager, it would probably be only on the odd occasion I would 'play' in a friend's house. We were used to playing outside with lots of local children. Not a gang, just a large group of children of different ages. I wasn't allowed to go into town or go swimming on my own until I was a teenager, but I had a lot of freedom in my local area.

Yesterday when I was at the hairdressers, my hairdressers was talking about her 11 year old son being allowed for the first time to go to the local park on his own to meet some friends. It's only now I realise I did that from a younger age.

Children do seem more protected these days. We didn't have a car so we walked or got a bus to go places. Children seem to be driven everywhere now. Everything seems to be down to protecting the child, but I am not sure if this is overkill most of the time.

Victoria08 Fri 02-Oct-15 12:58:15

I really don't understand why some parents get upset and depressed when their offspring leave home.

I was only too relieved when my daughter left to go to university.
The constant demands and financial outlay was getting a bit wearing on the nerves. Of course, my husband and I supported her as much as possible, but oh the peace and quiet was lovely.

For those who feel differently, I say "get a life".

Anyway, they always come back eventually. It's not as though you will never see them again.

She has now settled down with a baby but the demands and financial outlay are even greater.

ffinnochio Fri 02-Oct-15 13:08:38

Good post Elegran. I feel the same about my sons.

Anya Fri 02-Oct-15 13:26:42

I've noticed this trend too gettinginabit and Wilma - it's not to say these are bad parental traits, but they certainly seem to want to pry into every little nook and cranny, especially about school life.

On the odd occasion I asked my children what they did at school, the answer tended to be vague and I left it at that. Usually anything worthy of interest same out around the dinner table in general chit chat.

But I feel my DD and SiL in particular seem to grill their boys (5 & 9) about the school day and even what they had for lunch, and are not satisfied with being told everything is 'fine' or 'can't remember'.

Both are good, caring parents, but like others have posted seemed over concerned about the minutiae of their children's lives. I wonder what will happen in the teenage years when instead of 'fine' the answer is 'butt out of my life'?

annodomini Fri 02-Oct-15 13:30:53

Victoria08 - a woman after my own heart! Elegran, you sum up just the way I feel about the way my sons have turned out. They now seem to feel some responsibility for me!

rosesarered Fri 02-Oct-15 13:33:30

I agree with that Anya, in fact teachers have had the wearying job for years of listening to gripes by parents, who interfere in all aspects including why their child isn't in the top rugby/ cricket/ netball team etc.

thatbags Fri 02-Oct-15 13:59:20

School attitudes don't help, anya. Just had a text from Minibags's school saying that "tracking reports" were given out today. Tracking reports!?!? Makes them sound like criminals.

Anya Fri 02-Oct-15 14:30:29

Well there's two issues raised there bags, the tracking reports confused and the fact that you now get texts from schools (and emails probably).

In the 'good old days' one could choose to destroy lose letters send home from school as they were usually handed to the culprit pupil with a terse message to 'make sure you give that to your mother'.

thatbags Fri 02-Oct-15 14:53:43

No, they haven't started emails yet, but one can check details of whether school is open in v bad weather, for instance, on Twitter.

TriciaF Fri 02-Oct-15 14:54:18

I honestly can't remember one example of my parents visiting my schools to check on how I was getting on.
Apart from once when I was about 10 and got into trouble about something blush
They trusted the teachers and let them get on with their job.
Our eldest daughter teaches Biology etc in a "public" school and parents often check up and complain ie blame her if their child doesn't get a good exam result. Partly because they're paying, I suppose.

thatbags Fri 02-Oct-15 14:55:57

I reckon I know what Minibags's will say before I've seen it.

AnnieGran Fri 02-Oct-15 18:04:00

So, now the discussion has reached education and that it is good to ignore any old upsetting thing that happens?

My 15 year old grandson is in a school which became an Academy a year ago and has switched to a new, probably cheaper, IT provider.

Grandson did his first GCSE, geography, last week, on a school computer, no printing out allowed, no saving allowed, and when he clicked it through it disappeared. No copies anywhere and the IT man at the school couldn't help. No, evidently he can't do the exam again. Zero mark expected. We have since heard this has happened before to other students.

So are we going to behave like Doris Day and say never mind, worse things happen at sea? You bet your life we are not.

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 02-Oct-15 18:05:28

No! You shouldn't. Kick up one helluva fuss!!! shockhmm

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 02-Oct-15 18:07:28

Victoria08 you can take your "get a life" comment and stick it where the sun don't shine. And I hope it hurts.

smile

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 02-Oct-15 18:09:39

I think this generation of parents, because of their involvement in their children's lives, are quite simply, much better than we were.

You only have to read Mumsnet to see how much they care about their children.

Ana Fri 02-Oct-15 18:13:52

That's terrible, Anniegran! No saving? How ridiculous is that? And how demoralising for the poor boy having done the work but with nothing to show for it. I hope a solution can be found.

merlotgran Fri 02-Oct-15 18:32:27

I'm amazed he was not allowed to save his work, Anniegran. When I was teaching we must have sounded like broken records imploring students to remember to save their work.

If it was an exam or coursework how would it be marked if not saved?

You are justified in kicking up a fuss especially if it has happened to other students as well.

Elegran Fri 02-Oct-15 18:39:40

It doesn't sound like "not allowed" as a policy to me It sounds like a cock-up.

thatbags Fri 02-Oct-15 20:20:18

There's no way he'd have been advised not to save his work by a proper teacher. Kick up a stink, anniegran. Definitely a cock-up.

MamaCaz Fri 02-Oct-15 20:43:13

I've been mulling over what Jinglebellsfrocks said, but still can't agree that increased involvement in the minutiae of a child's life makes someone a better parent.

To me, this overwhelming desire to know every detail of a child's day at school (to pick just one example) says more about the parents' neediness than it does about concern for the child. From the point of view of the child's welfare and development, surely it's much more important to be there to listen if they do want to tell you about their day, and to look out for signs that something might be troubling them and need further probing, rather than persist in this silly and usually unproductive interrogation of their day!

I certainly don't buy into the idea that modern parents care more about their children than previous generations of parents did.
Current approaches to parenthood seem to be very different from anything that's gone before - natural I suppose given the advent and influence of the Internet and social media, but is there any real evidence anywhere that suggests that this makes for better parenting? There might be, but I haven't seen any.

Regarding what happened to AnnieGran's DGS, I don't think anyone is going to suggest for one moment that he or his parents should just suck it up and get a life. It's not the same thing. It's a real and potentially very serious problem. Like all such problems, it requires action, and should most certainly not be taken lying down.
That said, once such problems have been tackled, successfully or otherwise, there surely must come a point in the future where it would be far healthier to let it go if at all possible ...

Just my humble opinion, of course. smile